From 83 reviews overall

CJ Hegney
Keller Williams Realty - Central Coast
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Arroyo Grande
1250 Manzanita Court Arroyo Grande
CJ found us our dream home off-market and presented our offer to the seller with no competition in this crazy, competitive market. After intense negotiation, CJ secured us a deal that was too good to be true. Our offer was accepted far below market value, and we moved into our new home with INSTANT EQUITY! We were giving up on the idea of buying something new with the countless bidding wars we lost with other agents, but CJ made it a reality. We couldn't be more grateful for this amazing realtor!
From 90 reviews overall

Christa Lowry
Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Haven Properties
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Arroyo Grande
282 Puesta del Sol Arroyo Grande
Chista sent us all the new listings, picked homes we only would be interested in. When we couldn't find anything we liked, we asked her if she would help us talk to the owner of the rental house we had, to see if she would interested in selling it to us. She was instrumental in making a deal with the owner, and we purchased the house!! We were amazed she was able to make the deal. The escrow went very good, and fast. We are very thankful that we had Christa to take care of us during the whole process!!
From 52 reviews overall

Michelle McElrath (Severance)
Keller Williams Realty Central Coast

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Arroyo Grande
853 Mesa Drive Arroyo Grande
This is our fourth transaction with Michelle, she's always been easy to work with and very thorough. This time, after putting so much effort into updating an inherited rental property to modern standards, Michelle took over at the end and staged the interior with just enough furnishings to make it come alive, bringing in multiple offers.
375 Via Las Aguilas Arroyo Grande
Our family was relocating to the Central Coast from Northern California and we had only a little knowledge about the area. Michelle was immensely instrumental in finding us a lovely new home in the best area for our family. Her knowledge of the area and determination to find us the right home in the right neighborhood was evident throughout the process. First, by asking relevant questions and listening to the complicated and varying needs of our multi-generational family. In some ways, I think Michelle knew and understood even better than we did what would and wouldn’t work for us. Secondly, with a slim housing market Michelle worked tirelessly, and stayed positive, confident and encouraging that we would find a home in our price range. She sent out mailings in targeted neighborhoods and kept on top of new listings when they became available. She remained steadfast and optimistic throughout the process. Also, it was through a good working relationship with other realtors in the area that lead to her finding us a beautiful new home, in the area we wanted, in our price range, that pretty closely checked all our boxes! Her skills walking us through the purchase and the stress that comes with any real estate transaction were evident by her cool, calm and collected demeanor throughout. Lastly, I believe that it was more than a job for Michelle, she genuinely wanted us to be happy and generously stepped up and stood behind us when there were a few bumps in the road with the previous owners. We appreciate her commitment and professionalism very much and wouldn’t hesitate to recommend her to anyone. Thank you Michelle, we love our new home and it was a pleasure working with you!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
San Luis Obispo County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Arroyo Grande2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Arroyo Grande
848 Cypress Ridge Parkway Arroyo Grande
From our first meeting to closing of escrow, Alison exceeded our expectations in every way. She patiently answered our endless questions, kept us informed throughout the buying process and provided us with a wealth of information regarding the Cypress Ridge community, complete with contact information from utilities to HOA directors.