From 100 reviews overall

Andy Anderson
RE/MAX Signature

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Green Valley
A/265 South Paseo Sarta Green Valley
Andy was not afraid to show us other types of properties we had not thought of or considered. When it came to making offers, his market knowledge is spot on. His response time to any questions was amazing. Overall, Andy is a great guy who made our whole buying experience very enjoyable.
30 West Rosa Drive Green Valley
Andy has a knack for making that timely move that puts all worries to rest, and timing is everything. The kind of Realtor who rolls up his sleeves and gets under the house with the spiders to help smooth out an inspection. A+.
641 South Los Diamantes Green Valley
Andy was great to work with--he was super friendly, professional, and very pro-active in helping fix some issues with the house before and during the sale. Very responsive, always a positive attitude. I'd be happy to work with him again.
From 198 reviews overall

Michelle Metcalf
RE/MAX Signature

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Green Valley
641 South Los Diamantes Green Valley
The sale of my house proved to be a lot trickier than any of us expected. Through it all-- market conditions, unexpected repairs, and more--Michelle and her team always had a positive suggestion and belief that the house would eventually sell. When I became frustrated, they were empathetic, and had the information as to why this house was a hard one due to some unique features! In the end it did sell, we recently closed, and I can't thank Michelle, Andy, Joe and the rest of the team enough!!
5812 South Azure Vista Way Green Valley
Michelle is an excellent and thoughtful writer. She paid attention to every upgrade in my house and found a way to mention them seamlessly in the listing. The listing also uniquely showed a floorplan which I would find very helpful if I were buying a home. Michelle also responds quickly to phone calls and texts and does not dismiss seller suggestions out-of-hand. The only reason I did not give Michelle 5 stars, and perhaps it is not fair, was because of her handyman referrals. Both individuals she referred did not call when they said they would causing a delay of several days in an already tight timeline for the completion of repairs. On the other hand, her referral of a cleaning person was first-rate. I recommend Michelle Metcalf wholeheartedly if you are looking to sell your house.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Arizona2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Pima County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Green Valley2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
United States2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Southwest Region2026From 39 reviews overall

Courtney Seely
Realty ONE Group Integrity | Green Valley

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Green Valley
656 West Rio Moctezuma Green Valley
She was great about letting us know how things were progressing through the whole process, super knowledgeable on any questions we had. Great to work with wonderful personality, love her sooooo much. Courtney made this journey to find my lovely forever home a wonderful experience.
A/344 South Paseo Sarta Green Valley
She worked up a program for us even before we signed up with her. She was attentive and honest and gave us realistic expectations. Her market knowledge was spot on. We trusted her to work in our best interests.
From 9 reviews overall

Mary Pickard
Homesmart Advantage Group

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Green Valley
1456 W Desert Hills Dr Green Valley
Mary was thoughtful, friendly and loved showing me homes in the area. She has mortgage experience and walked me through all of the scenarios of home types. She has a strong knowledge of the market and was spot on in showing me the homes within my budget. Looking at homes was a stressful experience for me and Mary helped to keep my calm and focused. Her professionalism shined through!
A/246 South Paseo Pena Green Valley
I met Mary at an open house in January 2025. Throughout the year she sent emails for condos we might be interested in. Fast forward to January 2026 when we were finally ready to buy. I can’t say enough about what a positive experience it was working with Mary. She is knowledgeable, friendly, patient and so very helpful. We were back in Vermont dealing with the off and on again deal. Mary was communicative, organized and helpful through the signing of the contract, inspection and closing. I would recommend her and work with her again!
3467 South Waterfall Drive Green Valley
Mary was a perfect match for meeting all our real estate needs! Her kindness, patience, professionalism, encouragement and responsiveness to ALL our numerous questions was very reassuring! Her great sense of humor was a delight. Always with a smile - every time we met with her. Mary’s knowledge of the entire Green Valley area was impressive, encompassing homes that fit our specific criteria. Mary is also familiar with local Green Valley contractors and service personnel who could help us now and in the future. We knew during our initial meeting, that Mary is someone whom we could trust throughout the entire process - from viewing to making an offer to closing and everything in between. Mary is a wonderful well-respected person whom we now consider a a friend!