Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
95 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, strategic, hard-working, well-prepared, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
We have worked with Karen both as a buyer and seller
almost 9 years ago
We have worked with Karen both as a buyer and seller

We have worked with Karen both as a buyer and seller. She is the best agent I have ever worked with. Seriously. She is a master negotiator, she is honest, she is incredibly hard working and super responsive. Not only that, but she's a great person too. We couldn't be more thankful to her expertise!

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
Buyer review
Karen Kitzmiller has been our broker three times now and never disappoints
almost 9 years ago
Karen Kitzmiller has been our broker three times now and never disappoints

Karen Kitzmiller has been our broker three times now and never disappoints. She is absolutely amazing in everything she does and puts us right at ease. Karen goes above and beyond in every way and is there for us every step of the way. I would recommend her a thousand times over and will never consider using anyone else. We would be lost without her and her services.

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
We had a hard situation with our house
almost 9 years ago
We had a hard situation with our house

We had a hard situation with our house. There were many factors to it that could have been messed up very easily. We chose Karen Kitzmiller because we knew she was able to handle this. Her experience, knowledge and connections to the right people to complete the sale was exactly what we were looking for. We knew she could handle the challenge and she did with flying colors! We closed and it went beautifully thanks to Karen and her crew! Thank you Karen for everything! We are already working on our next deal with her!! If you need someone who can and will get the job done, definitely talk with Karen.

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
It was a pleasure to work with Karen again! We had used Karen's services to rent a house and then ye
almost 10 years ago
It was a pleasure to work with Karen again! We had used Karen's services to rent a house and then ye

It was a pleasure to work with Karen again! We had used Karen's services to rent a house and then years later to buy a house. Karen's patience with us through the process was comforting and her guidance was essential. When we needed to sell our home, Karen's ability to accurately determine a sales price that was both profitable for us and enticing to the market made our sale in days. Our trust in Karen to guide us through such an important process really paid off.

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
We appreciate Karen Kitzmiller so much!  She was very understanding of our wants/needs and didn't wa
almost 10 years ago
We appreciate Karen Kitzmiller so much! She was very understanding of our wants/needs and didn't wa

We appreciate Karen Kitzmiller so much! She was very understanding of our wants/needs and didn't want to push us into anything we might be unhappy with. She always answered our questions or figured them out if she didn't know the answer. She was very personable and got back to us in a very timely manner. Thank you Karen!

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
Karen went above and beyond to make this sale happen
almost 10 years ago
Karen went above and beyond to make this sale happen

Karen went above and beyond to make this sale happen. Not only was she spot-on with her valuation, she was able to market the property and receive multiple offers. Karen always kept me up to date and was always responsive to my needs. Would highly recommend!

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
Seller review
Karen is excellent at her job supporting both my purchase and selling process
almost 10 years ago
Karen is excellent at her job supporting both my purchase and selling process

Karen is excellent at her job supporting both my purchase and selling process. She provides market expertise, makes herself available to discuss concerns and/or questions during the process while making strong recommendations that I truly believe are in my best interest.

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
Buyer review
Our buying experience with Karen was great
almost 10 years ago
Our buying experience with Karen was great

Our buying experience with Karen was great. She explained the importance of getting a survey to us, and It is a good thing; because there was an issue with the deed and land. It was able to be all straightened out, but if she had not explained how important a survey is, we would not have had it done. Her knowledge and experience helped us so much. We had total trust in her and it paid off. We highly recommend Karen Kitzmiller!

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
Buyer review
Karen Kitzmiller is very competent, responsible, professional, and thorough
almost 10 years ago
Karen Kitzmiller is very competent, responsible, professional, and thorough

Karen Kitzmiller is very competent, responsible, professional, and thorough. She went above and beyond to help us and was able to creatively structure a purchasing bid that won in an 8-way competition. She even has the gift of a calming demeanor, which is so needed in what can be a stressful process. While there is no substitute for Karen in our minds, her team was consistently responsive and capable. We highly recommend Karen Kitzmiller and CENTURY 21 Real Estate Consultants!

Karen Kitzmiller

Karen Kitzmiller

  5   (28 reviews)
85 - 95 of 95
© 2026 RateMyAgent