Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
209 reviewsacross 48 different locations, showing 12.
about 5 years ago
"Jay was great to work with since we first reached out to him

"Jay was great to work with since we first reached out to him. From that conversation forward, he was always very prompt in answering questions/scheduling things that he could. He always found a way to make time for us when we would want to look for a house within that day (with the crazy market… you had to be there that day lol). After we found a house, and the offer was accepted, Jay was very helpful in navigating the process, by having great resources for us to use, as well as helping us when we had to change lenders. All of this was done very professionally and Jay was clear in communicating what he could and couldn’t help us with."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 5 years ago
"Jay was always available to answer my questions

"Jay was always available to answer my questions. He actually got me in to see the property the first day I called! Jay’s hometown knowledge of the area, along with his attention to detail made me feel comfortable every step of the way. Thank you Jay, for making buying a breeze! I couldn’t be more happy with my beautiful cottage."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 5 years ago
"In addition to serving all persons, more and more LGBTQ+ persons are moving to Lancaster and he w

"In addition to serving all persons, more and more LGBTQ+ persons are moving to Lancaster and he will be the “go to agent” for people of our community. He’s sharp, energetic, intelligent, decent. and HONEST! He actually listens to the client, accesses their needs, and works to make THEIR Real-estate realities happen! He’s not just in it for HIS commission, or to move a property, or get another award to hang on his wall. He has integrity and wants his clients happy and content with their Real-estate transaction. Rare these days in any profession—rarer still in Real-estate agents (hate to say it)."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 5 years ago
"Jay was wonderful to work with

"Jay was wonderful to work with. My mom was in another state and he was very patient with our situation."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 5 years ago
"Jay was fantastic! We had spoken to a few other realtors before we worked with Jay

"Jay was fantastic! We had spoken to a few other realtors before we worked with Jay. The other realtors were not punctual, and we lost out on opportunities because of it. Just days into our home search with Jay and we were in contract! He walked us through every step of home buying, and made sure we received updates. He helped explain our appraisal and inspections, and gave good advice every step of the way. It was a seamless, streamlined process. We felt like we could relax and trust him to handle it, unlike with the realtors we tried before. Honestly, cannot say enough good things about him! We will definitely recommend others to buy or sell their home with Jay! :)"

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
almost 6 years ago
"Jay is very intelligent, friendly, and keeps an open line of communication from start to finish

"Jay is very intelligent, friendly, and keeps an open line of communication from start to finish. His attention to detail is impeccable; he will proactively let you know of anything that’s easy to overlook, as he doesn’t want you to have any “surprises” that aren’t pleasant in the future. He treats you as an equal and a friend and is willing to explain the process of purchasing, always with patience and your best interest in mind. I would recommend him for anyone looking to purchase land or a home, regardless of if it’s your first or tenth purchase."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
about 6 years ago
"Jay was always prompt and courteous in communications

"Jay was always prompt and courteous in communications. He spoke with clear intentions. I am grateful for his professional knowledge and expertise that helped make an already stressful situation enjoyable. Thank you"

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Chad went above and beyond helping us sell our...

Chad went above and beyond helping us sell our home. He was there helping us identify things to fix (and in one instance helped us do it). He setup a great photographer. He did all the little things that helped us get in contract above asking price the day after we listed it. And he helped us all the way through to closing. We had to be out and didn’t have time to clean so Chad had cleaners come in and do the job. In addition to being a great realtor, he’s a great person and we could tell that he really cared about helping our family. He earned every penny of his commission. I can’t recommend Chad enough.

Chad Dailey

Chad Dailey

  4.5   (2 reviews)
over 6 years ago
I’ve known Jay Mattlin for a while personally, but I’ve never actually worked with him professionall

I’ve known Jay Mattlin for a while personally, but I’ve never actually worked with him professionally. I cannot thank Jay enough for everything that he did during my home buying experience. Jay not only helped me through the technical, but the emotional side as well. Being a first time home buyer, he understood my needs extremely well. I had a lot of random scenarios and questions. Some a little ridiculous, but Jay was available almost at anytime when these inevitably popped up. Overall, this experience was made better by having an experienced, professional Realtor.

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
157 - 168 of 209
© 2026 RateMyAgent