Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
209 reviewsacross 48 different locations, showing 12.
about 4 years ago
"I selected Jay because his social media marketing is always on-point

"I selected Jay because his social media marketing is always on-point. He mixes humor with facts and it's memorable. Jay is a hometown guy who cares about his clients and not just the sale. I had Seller's remorse within one week of being in contract, when I could not find a suitable home. I'm sure Jay was naturally disappointed, but his words and actions were always positive. Eventually, I found a replacement home and Jay represented me for that contract in an excellent manner. I will recommend Jay to anyone buying or selling their home."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
about 4 years ago
"Because we had Jay when we bought this house in 2017 it was import to me to have Jay help us again

"Because we had Jay when we bought this house in 2017 it was import to me to have Jay help us again. My husband and I live in Florida we didn't know about what the laws are in Ohio. In 2017 we needed so much help getting things done from down here,Jay got us all the phone numbers that we would need to start a new house up north. I was looking for Jay when we first got to Ohio to sell the house, it took about a week to find Jay and did after awhile."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 4 years ago
"Jay Mattlin has the experience I was looking for

"Jay Mattlin has the experience I was looking for. Jay explained what needed to be done to get the house ready for sale to have a positive impression. He is very knowledgeable. I recommend him and would use him again. The entire process was clearly explained and I was updated throughout. It was a good experience."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 4 years ago
"We highly recommend Jay Mattlin

"We highly recommend Jay Mattlin. He made the selling process super easy and kept us informed along the way. He listened to our concerns and opinions on selling our property and gave his honest feedback. His team did a great job with photos and video highlighting our house and property. We felt comfortable with Jay and appreciated how smoothly everything was handled. Working with Jay and Key Realty was an excellent experience. Jay walked us through the entire process of selling a home. He was professional,quick and efficient. We were relocating out of state and he was able to close the on the sale when we were ready."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 4 years ago
"Would not use anyone else but Jay Mattlin

"Would not use anyone else but Jay Mattlin. Jay was beyond excellent to work with. He worked hard to find available properties within the criteria we gave him. He called us as soon as he knew of new homes available and was always just a phone call or text away, when we found property that we saw first. He kindly dealt with all the text and calls we made with openness and a sense of humor.. He was always smiling and happy and he was like dealing with family. Our home search was through the winter months and we were out in all kind of weather, and Jay never complained. Right after we closed Jay gifted us with a basket of home care products as a thank you gift. I would recommend Jay to anyone looking to buy their first or next home."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Kim is outstanding

Kim is outstanding. My wife and I have purchased 2 homes through her. She was beyond patient. Extremely friendly and down to earth. She made us both feel comfortable and took her time explaining everything. Goes above and beyond for her clients. Highly recommend!

Kimberly Cumbo

Kimberly Cumbo

  5   (59 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Kim is absolutely wonderful

Kim is absolutely wonderful. You will not find a more patient, caring realtor out there. She took us to multiple properties and spent an enormous amount of time helping us find a house with property. We feel extremely comfortable with her. She really listens to your wants/needs as well. We have purchased two homes with her help. We will continue to use her in the future.

Kimberly Cumbo

Kimberly Cumbo

  5   (59 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
"There is no doubt after working with Jay that he has a strong passion for real estate

"There is no doubt after working with Jay that he has a strong passion for real estate. Buying a home is a very emotional experience. Jay helped keep my wife and I in check with reality the whole time! That alone is going above and beyond for his clients. Grateful for his communication skills allowing us to be informed and handled when anything arose during the purchase of our new home!"

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
"It was amazing working with Jay

"It was amazing working with Jay. He understood our needs as a family and was understanding of our crazy schedule and time constraints. Jay Mattlin is simply the best realtor that your going to find in the Fairfield county area."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
about 5 years ago
"Jay was great to work with since we first reached out to him

"Jay was great to work with since we first reached out to him. From that conversation forward, he was always very prompt in answering questions/scheduling things that he could. He always found a way to make time for us when we would want to look for a house within that day (with the crazy market… you had to be there that day lol). After we found a house, and the offer was accepted, Jay was very helpful in navigating the process, by having great resources for us to use, as well as helping us when we had to change lenders. All of this was done very professionally and Jay was clear in communicating what he could and couldn’t help us with."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
145 - 156 of 209
© 2026 RateMyAgent