Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
209 reviewsacross 48 different locations, showing 12.
over 6 years ago
"Jay will ask you to do two things: Provide him with your pre-approval letter and tell him what you

Jay will ask you to do two things: Provide him with your pre-approval letter and tell him what you want most in a home. After that, you really don't have to do anything. I know that last statement is not entirely true, but it feels that way. He covers everything! He answers all of your questions. He takes fear and uncertainty out of the process. This allows you to relax and enjoy the entire experience. He gave me a book at the first showing: "The Ultimate Home Buyer's Guide", by Jay Mattlin. This became a valued reference guide. Bravo!! Take the time to read it, often. Jay is with you every step of the way. From the first showing to the last. Putting in an offer. Explaining every detail of the contract. Attending the home inspection. Negotiating a price reduction as a result of the home inspection. Providing a timeline for your reference during the process. When you are on this journey to purchase a home. You soon realize, you have a team: mortgage broker, insurance agent and your realtor. Jay is the team captain. Yesterday, this single woman became a homeowner. I could not have done that without Jay Mattlin.

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 6 years ago
"Jay is an accomplished professional realtor

Jay is an accomplished professional realtor .. I would recommend him to anyone that may need services concerning buying or selling property..great to work with.. an all around pretty great guy..

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 6 years ago
"Jay is an amazing realtor and paid very close attention to our wants and needs

"Jay is an amazing realtor and paid very close attention to our wants and needs. He made sure that he found the perfect place for us and that we had everything we needed to for the process of buying a home. He found the perfect home for us and I could not be happier using him. Jay is an excellent person and will address any concerns or needs you have throughout the entire homebuying process!"

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 6 years ago
"I’ve known Jay Mattlin for a while personally, but I’ve never actually worked with him professi

"I’ve known Jay Mattlin for a while personally, but I’ve never actually worked with him professionally. I cannot thank Jay enough for everything that he did during my home buying experience. Jay not only helped me through the technical, but the emotional side as well. Being a first time home buyer, he understood my needs extremely well. I had a lot of random scenarios and questions. Some a little ridiculous, but Jay was available almost at anytime when these inevitably popped up. Overall, this experience was made better by having an experienced, professional Realtor."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
almost 7 years ago
"Jay was amazing to work with

"Jay was amazing to work with. We are first time home buyers and the city was being a pain but Jay always kept us updated on the house and made sure we fully understood what was going on. We had a TON of questions and Jay would get back with us instantly with answers that were easy to understand. He would even answer our questions late at night and weekends when we asked them. Jay went above and beyond to get us in our home as fast as he could and we are so appreciative. He made our first home buying experience so much better than it would have been without him. He is a great realtor and awesome to work with. Jay has extensive knowledge of the area and the entire home buying process."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Unfortunately the reason for selling our house is because of a marriage separation

Unfortunately the reason for selling our house is because of a marriage separation. As anyone can imagine this situation required some extra understanding and care. Jay was amazing throughout the process. He was organized and professional from the first contact. He was kind and patient when things got tense. Selling a house is difficult enough on its own. But I can’t imagine going through the situation with anyone but Jay. He was the very definition of rising above and beyond. I would never go with anyone else.

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Jay was amazing to work with

Jay was amazing to work with. We are first time home buyers and the city was being a pain but Jay always kept us updated on the house and made sure we fully understood what was going on. We had a TON of questions and Jay would get back with us instantly with answers that were easy to understand. He would even answer our questions late at night and weekends when we asked them. Jay went above and beyond to get us in our home as fast as he could and we are so appreciative. He made our first home buying experience so much better than it would have been without him. He is a great realtor and awesome to work with. Jay has extensive knowledge of the area and the entire home buying process.

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Jay made the selling process a breeze! Our family dynamic is unique (LGBTQ), and rare in this area

Jay made the selling process a breeze! Our family dynamic is unique (LGBTQ), and rare in this area. We knew that Jay would be sensitive to our needs. We appreciate Jay’s honesty and experience in the field, as well as his lifetime knowledge of the Lancaster area. He was reliable, responded quickly, and was open to any and all questions. We appreciate his accessibility, honesty, and sensitivity. We are so thankful for him!

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 7 years ago
demonstrates tact and very responsive to help...

demonstrates tact and very responsive to help you negotiate a sale. Very familiar with the Columbus market. Insist Chad to that you'd like to negotiate the price at each opportunity. He is dedicated to finding the right home for you and making the sale go through.

Chad Dailey

Chad Dailey

  4.5   (2 reviews)
over 7 years ago
"Unfortunately the reason for selling our house is because of a marriage separation

Unfortunately the reason for selling our house is because of a marriage separation. As anyone can imagine this situation required some extra understanding and care. Jay was amazing throughout the process. He was organized and professional from the first contact. He was kind and patient when things got tense. Selling a house is difficult enough on its own. But I can’t imagine going through the situation with anyone but Jay. He was the very definition of rising above and beyond. I would never go with anyone else.

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
169 - 180 of 209
© 2026 RateMyAgent