Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
191 reviewsacross 44 different locations, showing 12.
over 7 years ago
Kim was excellent to work with as first-time homebuyers

Kim was excellent to work with as first-time homebuyers. We hit several hurdles during our buying experience (a gap in mortgage acceptance, necessitating a break in searching for our home; a large number of long drives for all of us that turned out to be poor options; a successful bid and near-closing that ended up falling through at the last possible second due to unforeseen title issues) but through it all, she was calm and compassionate. She was never afraid to be completely honest with us, telling us outright if she did not think that a home in question was a good fit for our wants and needs. If a scheduling conflict came up, she informed us beforehand as possible so that we knew when she would be available. She never complained, despite having ample reason to do so on more than one occasion, and was truly a wonderful person to shepherd us through the language and process of making such a large purchase. Kim walked us through one step at a time, using language that we could understand and urging us to do certain things that were in our best interest without pushing them on us unnecessarily. We absolutely recommend that others work with her, especially first-time buyers. Kim knows what she is doing, and will help you through the entire process from start to finish with a smile.

Kimberly Cumbo

Kimberly Cumbo

  5   (56 reviews)
over 7 years ago
"Very attentive to our needs to find the perfect house

"Very attentive to our needs to find the perfect house. Was always available for any questions we had and showed us numerous homes. Very friendly and knowledgeable of homes in the area."

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
over 7 years ago
"Hard worker

"Hard worker. Fielded the many isdues that propect buyers threw at us and sold in very timely manner"

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Lee was awesome to work with from the very...

Lee was awesome to work with from the very beginning. We were having troubles with our prior realtor and was randomly recommended to Lee Goodman which was a blessing in itself! He made the process amazing easy and convenient for us and whenever we wanted to see a home last minute, he was there for us and very informative along the way. Our lender barely helped us through this process but Lee was there for us which made this a success. I would recommend Lee to anyone searching for a new home!

Lee Goodman

Lee Goodman

  5   (1 review)
almost 8 years ago
Very attentive to our needs to find the perfect house

Very attentive to our needs to find the perfect house. Was always available for any questions we had and showed us numerous homes. Very friendly and knowledgeable of homes in the area.

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Jay went above and beyond the call of duty with our purchase

Jay went above and beyond the call of duty with our purchase. We closed out of state and Jay drove 3.5 hours to Kentucky just so we didn’t have to close alone. Jay also attended all inspections, and walk throughs in our absence. It was almost like he was buying the home for himself!! Jay was very easy to get ahold of at any time of the day. He was very quick to answer any questions, and kept a very open line of communication. Jay was very informative with the whole process and made the entire purchase very easy. I would recommend Jay Mattlin to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Hard worker

Hard worker. Fielded the many isdues that propect buyers threw at us and sold in very timely manner

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
My family and I relocated to Ohio from out of state

My family and I relocated to Ohio from out of state. We essentially had one day to come up to Ohio, look at houses, and make a purchase. Jay researched HOA requirements and provided us access to our own MLS search app so we could narrow down our search prior to our trip. He went out of his way to explain our situation to the selling agent of the home we wanted to buy in order to get us the best deal and get items noted on the inspection report corrected before purchase. Since we were relocating from out of state we required help form Jay that most clients probably would not. The things I liked and really appreciated were: - He had a list of homes ready to visit with appointments scheduled in advance of our pre-transfer trip. If a home sold before we arrived he replaced it with another on our list. - Since we were out of town he offered to tour homes for us if we needed him to. - He attended our home inspection for us. - He Face Timed us when he completed our pre-closing walk through. - He went above and beyond and drove to Louisville for our home closing to ensure it went smoothly. - We also liked, and got value from, the literature he provided to us about buying and selling at the beginning of the process. - He dealt with our very unresponsive relocation company without complaint.

Jay Mattlin

Jay Mattlin

  5   (82 reviews)
169 - 180 of 191
© 2026 RateMyAgent