Key Realty

670 Meridian Way, Suite #169 Westerville, OH 43082
  •   5   (209 reviews)

Meet the team

Get to know the 142 agents at Key Realty.

Kimberly Cumbo
Kimberly Cumbo

REALTOR®

  5   (59 reviews)
About Kimberly
I'm a great people person and love real estate! I've been helping people find their home whether they are downsizing, buying a first home, or moving up since 2013! The past few years 75% of my business was repeat clients or a past client referring me! Let me help you with your real estate needs whether it be selling, buying or both!
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadgeaotybadge
Jay Mattlin
Jay Mattlin

REALTOR® / Principal Broker

  5   (82 reviews)
About Jay
You despise the typical real estate agent bios. Rest assured, we do too. They're like cardboard — stiff, bland, and indistinguishable from every other bio out there. Instead of inundating you with self-praise about awards and accomplishments you couldn't care less about, we're taking a unique approach by providing you with what you actually want — genuine answers to questions you're likely pondering right now. Will we return your calls and emails? Absolutely. No doubt about it. We understand that one of the major frustrations the general public faces when dealing with agents is the lack of responsiveness. We receive numerous calls and emails daily, and we're committed to responding as promptly as possible. Our goal is typically within one business day. We've encountered many Realtors who are less than pleasant. Are we? It depends on who you ask. If you ask certain agents who have stood between our clients and their real estate goals, they might say “yes”. Some may even think we leave golden footprints in the sand. Those are the extremes, and most people's opinion falls somewhere in the middle. Here's what we can tell you: we're honest and candid. We take pride in being approachable and friendly. And if you need a quick real estate brain or a strong dose of honesty, you're in the right place. Loyalty to family, clients, and friends is one of our core values. Want to find out if we're pleasant or not? Mess with one of those people. Do we have experience doing exactly what you need? Until you tell us what you need, there's no way of knowing. Here are our “strong suits”: Working with new buyers First-time sellers USDA / FHA Investment and rental properties Probate and estate sales If your goal or situation isn't represented on that list, don't worry. Contact us anyway. If we can't help, we can connect you with another agent who can.
View Profile
About Siara
First and foremost, I’m a wife and mom to two beautiful children. We live on a quaint little farm in Fairfield County, just a few miles from where I grew up in Amanda, Ohio. Family and faith are at the heart of everything I do, and I believe honesty, integrity, kindness, and hard work are the foundation for success—in real estate and in life. My path to real estate wasn’t exactly traditional. I graduated high school with honors in 2007 and earned my Bachelor of Science in Human Services in 2014. Before beginning my real estate career, I worked as a Director of Social Services in a skilled nursing facility, an experience that strengthened my ability to listen, advocate, communicate, and guide people through important life transitions. In 2015, I became a licensed REALTOR®—and I’ve loved it ever since! 🏡 I’m also the owner of multiple investment properties, so I truly practice what I preach. I believe real estate can be so much more than a place to call home—it can be an incredible tool for building financial security and generational wealth. Whether you’re buying your first home, searching for your forever home, purchasing an investment, adding to your portfolio, or preparing to sell, my goal is to provide the same level of care, attention to detail, honest guidance, strong negotiation, and top-tier marketing that I would want for my own family. From residential homes and investment properties to farms, land, and commercial real estate, I’m here to help you navigate it all. Real estate is my career, but serving people is my passion. And when you trust me with one of your biggest investments, I don’t take that responsibility lightly.
View ProfileRateMyAgent AchievementspriceExpertbadge
About Hannah

Hannah currently has 5 active property listings and 9 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
Delene McNeal
Delene McNeal

Associate Broker / Licensed Real Estate Agent

  5   (7 reviews)
About Delene
I’m a Licensed Broker and Realtor®️since 1999! I’m also a Health & Fitness Professional. My passions are helping you Mind🧘🏻‍♀️Body💪SOLD 🏠!
View Profile
John Moore
John Moore

Licensed Real Estate Agent

  5   (4 reviews)
About John
Your Trusted Real Estate Experts in Columbus, Ohio! At the Moore Home Team with Key Realty, we believe that exceptional real estate service starts with one simple principle: putting our clients first. There are many qualities that define a top-tier real estate professional—integrity, deep market knowledge, strategic marketing, expert negotiation skills, and a powerful professional network. These are the hallmarks of how we work. With years of experience in the Central Ohio real estate market, we’ve built a reputation for delivering results. But more importantly, we’ve built relationships. Our "Client-First" Philosophy means we are always accessible, great listeners, strong communicators, and quick to respond to your needs. We are constantly evolving, leveraging the latest technology to streamline the buying and selling process, maximize exposure for your property, and provide a seamless experience from start to finish. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, we are committed to exceeding your expectations at every step. Let’s make your real estate goals a reality—together. Contact us today!
View Profile
Key Realty

Are you Key Realty?

Contact help@renowned.com and one of our friendly team will assist you to claim your profile, request and receive your first review.

Claim profile

About us

Key Realty is a real estate office. They have 209 verified reviews with an average rating of 5 stars. They currently have 472 active property listings and 934 sold property listings over the past 12 months worth $313,791,481.

Our reviews

  5  
209 reviewsacross 48 different locations, showing 6.
1 day ago
Siara was a pleasure to work with

She explained every question we had. Could get a hold of her anytime, she was very market knowledgeable,great communication and is very professional..We enjoyed working with Siara

Siara Kopis

Siara Kopis

  5   (30 reviews)
14 days ago
Very knowledgeable of the market!

We appreciate Siara and her knowledge of the market. She went above and beyond to help us get the most profit out of our home. We will refer her to anyone needing a realtor!

Siara Kopis

Siara Kopis

  5   (30 reviews)
2 months ago
A top tier agent that makes her clients a priority

Due to no fault of this wonderful agent, our last sale was a challenge. In the midst of building our new home, moving into temporary living, and having a baby, our stress was maxed out. Siara kept us in the loop on what was happening, making constant calls with buyer agents, lenders, etc.. correcting anything from clerical errors on appraisal reports to clarifying deed update requests from title agencies. Above and beyond is an understatement, and there’s a reason I’ve trusted her with the purchase and sale of 3 different homes.

Siara Kopis

Siara Kopis

  5   (30 reviews)
3 months ago
Kim Cumbo Turned a Stressful Process into a Great Experience!

Working with Kim Cumbo was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. She has a gift for explaining every step of the process clearly, which made what can be an overwhelming experience feel completely manageable. No matter how many questions I threw her way — and there were a lot — she answered each one with patience and genuine care. What truly set Kim apart was how valued she made me feel. Not once did I feel like just another client on her list. Every single day, she made it clear that selling my parents home was a priority. If you’re looking for a realtor who is knowledgeable, patient, and treats you like family, Kim Cumbo is the one to call. I can’t recommend her enough!

Kimberly Cumbo

Kimberly Cumbo

  5   (59 reviews)
3 months ago
Kim Cumbo is a awsome real estate agent.

Working with Kim Cumbo, my real estate agent was a great experience from start to finish. She is knowledgeable, professional, and always available to answer my questions. Her guidance throughout the selling process made everything go smooth, and tshe worked hard to get my house sold quickly. I appreciated her communication, honesty, and attention to detail. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home.

Kimberly Cumbo

Kimberly Cumbo

  5   (59 reviews)
Show all 209 reviews

Our properties

Key Realty has 472 properties for sale and sold 934 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$100,000
31 South Morning Street
Sunbury OH 43074
3
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Key Realty
For Sale
$24,000
312 West Miami Street
Degraff OH 43318
Land
Listing courtesy of Key Realty
SoldSep 30, 2026
$390,000
647 Keltonhurst Dr
Pataskala OH 43062
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Key Realty and Howard HannaRealEstateServices
SoldSep 30, 2026
$400,000
5048 Blue Meadow Court
Columbus OH 43231
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Red 1 Realty and Key Realty
Show all 1406 properties

Browse nearby locations

This individual or business has not claimed this profile. Even though this profile is on RateMyAgent, this does not mean they endorse the site, is associated with the site, or confirms the listings or sales data information which we display about them, or any other publicly available information, to be accurate in any way. Read more

Email
© 2026 RateMyAgent