Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
792 reviewsacross 44 different locations, showing 12.
about 7 years ago
My parents first met Roger Pettingell over 30 yrs ago when they purchased one of the first top floor

My parents first met Roger Pettingell over 30 yrs ago when they purchased one of the first top floor units at Marina Bay on Long Boat Key. They were impressed with his professionalism and drive back then. As I prepared their condominium to be placed on the market for sale this past Spring, Roger and his team stood out above and beyond as the team we wanted to represent us. From beginning to closing, Roger Pettingell and his terrific team were a delight to work with.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
about 7 years ago
We recognized the professional approach to our listing and sale early on

We recognized the professional approach to our listing and sale early on. Roger has assembled a unique and highly capable staff to work with. Each of them pictured in the sale and offered their expertise. Roger made sure the transaction got done to everyone's satisfaction. He personally took care of many details and smoothed out the negotiations. We can recommend him with great confidence. Jan and Cy Ansary

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
about 7 years ago
Very professional and efficient

Very professional and efficient. Extremely helpful in selling my waterfront condo when I lived out of the area. Great staff, who helped coordinate contractors and take care of small details for me. Roger made accurate strategic decisions on the staging / preparation of the condo. I was relieved to find someone else who agreed that there are buyers for condos in "as-is" condition. Roger and his Team exceeded my expectations.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
about 7 years ago
Eileen Gillen is AWESOME

Eileen Gillen is AWESOME. First she found us the perfect new condo and then she helped us negotiate a great price. She seems pretty laid back, but she's definitely not laid back when it comes to looking after her clients! So of course we listed the old condo with Eileen and she did not let us down. She and Brian explained everything, and were so conscientious through every step of the process. One or the other were present at every showing and provided feedback from other brokers. Closing came off without a hitch and here we are, sitting in our new home enjoying the waterfront view. Thank you Eileen and Brian, you are truly a dynamic duo.

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (109 reviews)
about 7 years ago
Steve was a delight to work with

Steve was a delight to work with. His knowledge of The Oaks was very helpful for us - both in deciding that the community is the one that best suits our needs as well as in finding our ideal property there. Steve represented us, the buyers, as well as the sellers - and did so with fairness (not always an easy thing to do). He was exceedingly prompt with his responses to all of our questions and requests - and did a good job of keeping the sale in track and moving along in a timely manner. I strongly recommend Steve as a realtor - for both buyers and sellers.

Steve Abbe

Steve Abbe

  5   (159 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Roger is very "client oriented"

Roger is very "client oriented". He was easy to contact and responded to our inquiries and questions. He provided great promotional materials for our home, including drone footage and websites. He also kept me informed by sending regular emails regarding home sales in our geographic area, prices, and new listings.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
over 7 years ago
We are "round trip" customers of Roger's -- we used him to buy our home and then again several years

We are "round trip" customers of Roger's -- we used him to buy our home and then again several years later to sell it. He and his team are knowledgeable, responsive and detail-oriented. In a market that has a large percentage of second home ownership, objective and timely local market knowledge is difficult to obtain. We found Roger and his team to have unparalleled insight.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Roger did an excellent job selling my Dad's house

Roger did an excellent job selling my Dad's house. Since my dad is 92 years old, he was unable to do much of the work to prepare and sell the house. Roger did all the necessary work to get the house in condition to sell and then did all the work to get the house sold. While the house was for sale, a water leaked developed in one of the closets. Roger handled everything to fix the water leak and then got everything fixed that was caused by the water leak.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Very Patient!

Very patient! We had to see everything available, revisited the finalists, considered remodeling one, trying to find the best alternative. We made bids on several different properties before finally getting a contract. Steve was very dogged in helping us sort things out. Had a good grasp about what could be done to tailor things to our specs and a good handle on the costs for various projects and who to use to get the work done. He is a very hard worker, and is quick to respond to calls. He has a great staff that helps you make the most of your time and his.

Steve Abbe

Steve Abbe

  5   (159 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Alison is everything you could want in a real estate agent and more

Alison is everything you could want in a real estate agent and more. She is dedicated to doing whatever her clients need. When we visited Sarasota to search for a home, she spent an entire week with us looking at different types of homes in various locations in the area. And then after we left Sarasota, she continued to search for homes we might be interested in, even visiting several and giving us virtual tours by FaceTime. After we decided on a home, Alison’s guidance and continued assistance were invaluable in completing our purchase. Throughout the process, Alison was always energetic, cheerful, and responsive, and also on top of all the details. In short, Alison is a consummate professional as well as a delight to work and spend time with.

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (74 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Attentive to customer needs also no pressure and no false promises

Attentive to customer needs also no pressure and no false promises.Very prompt in all aspects,very knowledgeable and Professional of the whole process.Our closing was very smooth no surprises all paperwork was complete and in order.

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (109 reviews)
697 - 708 of 792
© 2026 RateMyAgent