Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian

8901 S Meridian St Indianapolis, IN 46217
  •   5   (132 reviews)

Our sales performance at a glance

See how Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

44
Reviews
80
Properties for sale
61
Sold properties
$296k
Average sale price
$18.1m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

Meet the team

Get to know the 29 agents at Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian.

Michelle McKnight
Michelle McKnight

REALTOR®

  5   (41 reviews)
About Michelle
With over 20 years of real estate experience, I have helped hundreds of Indiana homeowners successfully navigate changing markets and achieve their real estate goals. My strategic pricing approach, proven marketing plan, strong work ethic, and negotiation skills have helped my sellers achieve over 98% of their original list price with an average of 18 days to an accepted offer. I invest in ongoing professional coaching and training to stay at the top of my profession and provide my clients with the highest level of service. Backed by a local and respected real estate company and recognized for service excellence, I am committed to providing regular, clear communication, expert advice, and results-driven representation.
View Profile
Lacy Nacke
Lacy Nacke

REALTOR®

  5   (26 reviews)
About Lacy

Lacy currently has 1 active property listings and 10 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievementstop20badge
Jim Linville
Jim Linville

REALTOR®

  5   (23 reviews)
About Jim
I graduated from Rushville Consolidated High School. I went into The Marine Corps after high school. I was a Military Police Officer for 4 years. I have been in automotive manufacturing as a production supervisor. I am married with two daughters. I received my Real Estate license in 2004 and went on to get my Brokers license in 2006. I am a full time Realtor with over 15 years experience of selling and buying Real Estate. I have learned that to sell a house, you have to become an expert at marketing. When you list with me you will get weekly updates,and constant updates. I not only show you what is going on. I teach you the process.This helps with our team work of getting your home sold,for the most money with the least amount of time netting you the most money. I also work with buyers. I help them get a mortgage provider if they do not know or have one. I also sit down with you and do a complete buyers consultation. I will teach you the complete process so you will know what is going to happen and what we can do to get you the best opportunity. So you can buy your new home and get the best price. With the least amount of cost and inconvience. I make it my personal mission. To make sure you get the best service possible. Remember it takes more than a sign in you yard to sell your home. It takes advance marketing and a active agent!!!
View ProfileRateMyAgent Achievementstop20badge
Laura Stevenson
Laura Stevenson

REALTOR®

  5   (10 reviews)
About Laura
Established in 2016, The Key Team of Carpenter Realtors was created with the belief that "Communication and Education are KEY to a successful real estate transaction!" After working in the in the communication industry for over 35 years, Laura Stevenson gained a vast understanding of the importance of clear, efficient and precise communication and decided to employ this in the real estate industry. After some time in the in the industry, Laura decided that she could better serve clients by establishing a real estate team. Laura then brought Anne Rhinehart into the fold because Anne also works as a full time educator and understands the importance of working alongside clients and educating them about the real estate process. Anne's background in education pairs wonderfully with Laura's extensive understanding of the communication industry and the importance it plays in life's transactions. Laura and Anne share a common set of goals in assisting their clients to have a successful, well informed, and easy transition into the next chapter of their life as they buy and sell their home. Both women were raised on the south side of Indianapolis, and they have a deep regard for the community and culture of the area. Often you will see them in town with family taking in the many amenities the south side has to offer. As The Key Team, we pride ourselves on our ability to truly listen to clients' needs and connect them with opportunities that best match those requirements. Additionally, we maintain an open-door policy and return phone calls and email promptly to ensure responsive, transparent, and personable service. Please feel free to contact us further about the following real estate services: · Real estate sales/ purchases · Real estate home staging · Local real estate market reports · Local real estate market expertise and guidance · Real estate professional referrals (for those moving to another state or country) · Real estate leasing (commercial, industrial, retail, residential) · Other: Do you have a unique real estate issue that you need assistance with? We are happy to work with you to find solutions. Your friends in the real estate industry,
View Profile
Tracey Brown
Tracey Brown

REALTOR®

  5   (9 reviews)
About Tracey

Tracey currently has 4 active property listings and 6 sold property listings over the past 12 months.

View Profile
Anne Rhinehart
Anne Rhinehart

REALTOR®

  5   (7 reviews)
About Anne
Communication and Education are key to a successful real estate transaction! Anne Rhinehart also works as a full time educator and media specialist and has for 12 years before pursing an additional career in real estate. Working in the education industry, Anne has gained a vast understanding of the importance of working alongside others to teach them the process as needed for success in all of life's ventures. She follows the belief that when you work with others and teach them about the activity in which they are currently involved, they have a better more enriching experience. This vast knowledge can help to guide your real estate venture and keep you knowledgeable of all steps along the way. Anne joined The Key Team with her mother and co-agent, Laura Stevenson. Laura brought Anne into the fold, not only because of the important family connection, but because Anne understands the importance of not only of educating clients about the real estate process but clearly communicating with clients at each step of the way. Anne's background in education pairs wonderfully with Laura's extensive understanding of the communication industry and the importance it plays in life's transactions. Laura and Anne share a common set of goals in assisting their clients to have a successful, well informed, and easy transition into the next chapter of their life as they buy and sell their home. The goal of The Key Team is not just about listing your home, but selling your home at best price and in the least amount of time possible, so that their clients can start the next chapter of their journey with confidence and ease. Anne Rhinehart was born and raised on the south side of Indianapolis, and she has a deep regard for the community and culture of the area. Often you will see Anne in town with her husband, and children taking in the many amenities the south side has to offer. Her favorite moments are spent relishing in the time spent with family and laughter and comfort they bring to her life.
View Profile

About us

Carpenter Realtors' South Meridian office proudly serves Indianapolis and the surrounding southside communities with a commitment to exceptional service, local expertise, and lasting relationships. Our experienced real estate professionals understand the unique neighborhoods, schools, and market trends that make this area an outstanding place to call home. Whether you're purchasing your first home, selling your current property, relocating, or investing, our agents provide personalized guidance every step of the way. Backed by the strength of one of Indiana's largest independently owned real estate companies, clients benefit from innovative marketing, advanced technology, and a network of knowledgeable professionals dedicated to achieving successful results. At South Meridian, we're more than real estate agents—we're trusted advisors who take pride in helping individuals and families accomplish their real estate goals while supporting the communities we serve.

Our reviews

  5  
123 reviewsacross 43 different locations, showing 6.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: attentive, patient, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert, well-prepared.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Exceptional
1 day ago
Exceptional

Wonderful person to help sell our home! Very patient and understanding as we moved out of state. Highly recommended with excellent communication during this process.

Michelle McKnight

Michelle McKnight

  5   (41 reviews)
Buyer review
Readily available
4 days ago
Readily available

Very responsive to our texts and requests. Good communicator and honest when asked his opinions.

Brandon Warfield

Brandon Warfield

  5   (7 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent communicator
5 days ago
Excellent communicator

The best realtor I’ve ever worked with. Very patient and was all done on the phone. Site unseen.

Brandon Warfield

Brandon Warfield

  5   (7 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent negotiator with great communication skills.
7 days ago
Excellent negotiator with great communication skills.

When our congregation found itself threatened with being evicted as part of an estate dispute including the building we were renting, we were in a hard place. We decided to see if we could purchase the building even though it was not listed for sale yet. We turned to Bob who had assisted us tin the sale of our former building a few years ago. Bob was able to reach out to the estate and help us negotiate a purchase. He was able to help us quickly come to agreement with the estate and kept us informed throughout the process.

Robert Lane

Robert Lane

  5   (2 reviews)
Buyer review
Michelle is professional and knowledgeable in the real estate business.
20 days ago
Michelle is professional and knowledgeable in the real estate business.

Michelle keeps you informed and works hard on your needs, whether you are buying or selling a home. Michelle will protect your interests as you go through the process of buying or selling your home. I have used Michelle several times over the years because of the skills she possesses. Randy

Michelle McKnight

Michelle McKnight

  5   (41 reviews)
Seller review
Very professional and very serious
28 days ago
Very professional and very serious

All questions were answered immediately didn't hesitate if we had thoughts that were exactly correct he corrected us immediately but politely

Brandon Warfield

Brandon Warfield

  5   (7 reviews)
Show all 123 reviews
map

Our properties

Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian has 80 properties for sale and sold 61 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$355,000
905 Lions Head Lane
Greenwood IN 46143
4
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian
Pending
$110,000
6912 Dunn Way
Indianapolis IN 46241
3
1
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian
SoldAug 21, 2026
$390,000
6419 East Southport Road
Indianapolis IN 46237
3
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian and My Agent
SoldAug 20, 2026
$203,850
211 S Bloomington St
Greencastle IN 46135
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Advantage, REALTOR and Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian
Show all 141 properties
Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian
Contact Carpenter Realtors - South Meridian
What information would you like?

Browse nearby locations

© 2026 RateMyAgent