Back New Castle

40 real estate offices in New Castle

Sorted by most reviews for offices in New Castle over the past 12 months.
View Carpenter Realtors - Monrovia's profile

Carpenter Realtors - Monrovia

5.0

(110 reviews)

Meet the team

Kim HealdSherri WalstromSara Ivie
+9
  • Reviews in New Castle 1
  • Sold 1
  • For Sale 0
  • Total sales value $128k
  • Avg. sale price $128k
April Rawley8 months ago

Seller of 2118 Vine Street, New Castle

Can’t say enough good about Sherri

Can’t say enough good about Sherri. She helped us find our house and she recently helped us sell it. She makes the process so easy whether buying or selling. She does all the administrative heavy lifting so that no matter how busy you are, you can accomplish your home buying or selling goal with minimal added stress. She is also just so sweet and easy to work with! She becomes more like a family member or good friend than just a hired professional. Every time she sees us she brings little gifts, snacks and toys for our kids, etc, completely unprompted. We just love her - she will forever be our realtor choice as long as we’re in Indiana!

Accolades

View Carpenter Realtors - Plainfield's profile

Carpenter Realtors - Plainfield

5.0

(147 reviews)

Meet the team

Laura VermillionMiranda PayneAndi Middlesworth
+18
  • Reviews in New Castle 1
  • Sold 0
  • For Sale 0
  • Total sales value N/A
  • Avg. sale price N/A
Ronald Shrum11 months ago

Buyer of 2062 East Dublin Pike, New Castle

Wendy went above and beyond what she was supposed to do

Wendy went above and beyond what she was supposed to do. She did more for us than our lending company(she did most of their job also). She never backed down and pushed for what needed to be done. If we didnt have Wendy we probably wouldn't of got our house. I will never use anyone but her for my next home buying. I highly recommend Wendy for anyone buying/selling a home.

Accolades

View Carpenter Realtors - Greenwood's profile

Carpenter Realtors - Greenwood

5.0

(106 reviews)

Meet the team

Derrin PhoenixLaura WrightDeana Hawkins
+19
  • Reviews in New Castle 1
  • Sold 0
  • For Sale 0
  • Total sales value N/A
  • Avg. sale price N/A
Anonymousabout 2 months ago

Buyer of 2712 Brown Street, New Castle

Hands down 10 out of 10 experience!!

I truly can’t imagine going through this journey with anyone other than Derrin Phoenix. She was always incredibly responsive, remarkably patient, and made me feel comfortable asking any question, no matter how small. While she is exceptionally professional and knowledgeable about the market, her warmth makes it so easy to connect with her. Derrin pours so much energy, expertise, and genuine heart into finding the right fit. She understands the emotional and financial weight of buying a home and supports you through every step. The phrase "guiding you with heart and hustle" describes her 100%. Whether you need a fierce advocate to win your dream home or a skilled expert to sell your current place, Derrin is the exact person you want in your corner!

Accolades

View Carpenter Realtors - Greenfield's profile

Carpenter Realtors - Greenfield

5.0

(67 reviews)

Meet the team

Don WhitesellGary RalstonTaylor Doubman
+12
  • Reviews in New Castle 1
  • Sold 0
  • For Sale 0
  • Total sales value N/A
  • Avg. sale price N/A
Anonymous4 months ago

Buyer of 1023 S 20th St, New Castle

Overall good experience

Loved working with Piper. No complaints about the process she explained everything and answered any questions I had. I would recommend her to anyone

Accolades

View F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate's profile

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in New Castle 0
  • Sold 116
  • For Sale 30
  • Total sales value $20.8m
  • Avg. sale price $179k

No reviews in New Castle yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View REMAX First Integrity | New Castle's profile

REMAX First Integrity | New Castle

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in New Castle 0
  • Sold 92
  • For Sale 44
  • Total sales value $16.1m
  • Avg. sale price $175k

No reviews in New Castle yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View REMAX First Integrity | New Castle's profile

REMAX First Integrity | New Castle

N/A

(0 reviews)

Meet the team

Ashley HuffmanAshley Swift MorrisBecky Hawrot
+16
  • Reviews in New Castle 0
  • Sold 47
  • For Sale 46
  • Total sales value $9.8m
  • Avg. sale price $209k

No reviews in New Castle yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View F.C. Tucker/Crossroads' profile

F.C. Tucker/Crossroads

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in New Castle 0
  • Sold 37
  • For Sale 48
  • Total sales value $6.3m
  • Avg. sale price $170k

No reviews in New Castle yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

View MIBOR REALTOR? Association's profile

MIBOR REALTOR? Association

N/A

(0 reviews)

  • Reviews in New Castle 0
  • Sold 13
  • For Sale 0
  • Total sales value $2.7m
  • Avg. sale price $207k

No reviews in New Castle yet

Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here

Accolades

1 - 9 of 164

Zip codes in New Castle

View nearby Cities

© 2026 RateMyAgent