

Heidi Nuhfer
Real Estate Agent
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 316 Prentiss Ave, Findlay
Heidi is a kind hearted go getter. I’ve used her as my realtor for several houses now and have yet to be disappointed. She communicates quickly and well, keeping you in the loop for everything. You can tell she wants the best for you and is willing to help you every step of the way. I’d recommend Heidi to anyone looking to buy or sell a house, she’s keeps it real.
Buyer of 225 19th Street, Findlay
Heidi was very nice to work with! I’m a first time homebuyer so I was uncertain of what would happen going into this process, but from the get go, Heidi made everything very easy. She moved things along at a good pace but yet didn’t want to rush anything, and she was very polite and knowledgeable. She answered my questions and made sure all the boxes were checked. She even gave me a housewarming gift! I would recommend Heidi to anybody for their house-buying needs.
Seller of 522 West Front Street, Findlay
I watched YouTube videos on how to pick a realtor. Heidi met all the suggestions on what to look for. She had a manageable number of houses for sell close to my houses price range, which allowed me to get the attention I wanted (answering questions timely, helping provide guidance when needed) and indicated to me that she understood who our targeted buyer would be. She had comparable properties and made a suggested price for the house that she could back up with reasons for pricing it the way she did. And her sell history indicated to me she sold previous house for at asking price or above asking price a majority of the time and typically did not have to lower the house price to get it moving. These reasons plus the smart suggestions she made for final touches made me confident I had picked the right realtor and getting the offer that lead to closing in 4 days and 4 hours proved it.
State Top 10
Ohio2026County Winner
Hancock County2026City Winner
Findlay2026

Kim Leeper Agent
REALTOR®
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 228 East Wallace Street, Findlay
Selling our home with Kim was just as incredible as buying our forever home with her. From the moment our house hit the market, we knew we were in the best hands. Thanks to her expertise, marketing, and guidance, we received multiple offers within the very first day! What could have been an overwhelming and stressful process quickly became exciting because she walked us through every offer, explained our options clearly, and helped us make the best decision for our family with complete confidence. Her communication, professionalism, and genuine care are unmatched. She always made us feel like we were her top priority and was there every step of the way to answer questions and ease any concerns. If you're looking to buy or sell a home, we can't recommend Kim enough. She made both experiences seamless, stress-free, and successful. We are so thankful for everything she did to help our family through two of the biggest milestones in our lives!
Buyer of 823 Nutmeg Lane, Findlay
There truly aren't enough words to express how grateful we are for everything Kim did for our family. From the very beginning, she made us feel like more than just clients—she genuinely cared about us and was invested in helping us find the perfect place to call home. Buying a home can be stressful and emotional, but she was there every step of the way with patience, encouragement, honesty, and endless support. She always had our best interests at heart and never made us feel pressured. No question was too small, and she was always quick to respond and guide us through every decision with confidence. Because of her hard work and dedication, we found our forever home—a place where we'll make memories, watch our children grow, and build our future together. That is a gift we will never take for granted. If you're looking for a realtor who is kind, trustworthy, knowledgeable, and will truly go above and beyond for you, look no further. We are forever thankful for everything she did to help make this dream come true. We couldn't have asked for a better person to help us through such an important milestone in our lives. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts!
Seller of 1807 Pebblestone Drive, Findlay
She got our house marketed very quickly! She had 2 offers the first day and 2 more the second day. She was super easy to work with and extremely knowledgeable with all the skills you could ask for! I highly recommend her and will use her talents if I ever need a realtor again!!
County Top 5
Hancock County2026

Nicole Hartschuh
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Scott Keller
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 0 Glenmar Parkway, Findlay
Scott is absolutely amazing to work with! Incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and always two steps ahead. We have worked with him for years and he has made buying/selling stress-free. Highly recommend!