Nicole Hartschuh

Nicole Hartschuh

  •   5   (55 reviews)

Nicole's sales performance at a glance

See how Nicole has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

8
Reviews
2
Properties for sale
18
Sold properties
$317k
Average sale price
$6m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) as lead and supporting agent and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

Nicole's customer service award

See the RateMyAgent award Nicole has won

  • 2x County Top 5Hancock County - 2025, 2023

About Nicole

I officially earned my Realtor license in 2018, marking the beginning of my dedicated journey in real estate. Since then, my commitment has been to deliver exceptional, personalized service. Prior to immersing myself in real estate, I gained valuable experience in the banking industry, providing me with a unique perspective to guide individuals through one of their most significant life investments. You can rely on me for prompt and transparent communication, coupled with a thorough follow-through, ensuring that your home buying or selling experience is not only seamless but also enjoyable. Beyond my real estate endeavors, I am actively engaged in our community. I proudly serve as a member of the Flag City Morning Rotary and the Findlay Kiwanis Club, emphasizing the importance of giving back. Additionally, I am a proud graduate of the Hancock Leadership class of 2022 and enjoy participating in our local tennis community. As a Northeast Ohio native, I have deep roots, graduating from Willard High School and creating lasting memories at Bethany College in West Virginia. Since 1991, Findlay has been my home, where my husband Mark and I decided to establish the East of Chicago Pizza franchise - a business he still operates successfully today. If you're contemplating a move, don't hesitate to reach out. Let's discuss your goals and tailor a real estate journey that aligns perfectly with your needs. Whether you're buying or selling, I am here to ensure that your experience goes beyond smooth-it's uniquely tailored to you. I am eager to connect with you and make your real estate aspirations a reality!

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 55 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 6.
Review Nicole
Nicole's qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, detail-oriented, stress-free process, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Nicole is an excellent realator
26 days ago
Nicole is an excellent realator

Nicole went above and beyond my expectations to promote the sale of my home. Her advice was extremely helpful.

Buyer review
Awesome realtor
3 months ago
Awesome realtor

Nicole was extremely helpful and attentive throughout the entire process. I would recommend her to anyone!

Seller review
Exceptional Results and Seamless Communication
3 months ago
Exceptional Results and Seamless Communication

Nicole did a fantastic job selling my property. From the beginning through closing, she led the process with professionalism, organization, and close attention to detail. Her communication was impeccable. I was always kept informed about what was happening, what to expect next, and any decisions that needed to be made. Questions were answered promptly and clearly, which made the entire experience far less stressful. What impressed me most was how thoroughly she managed every step from start to finish. Nicole coordinated with all parties, kept timelines on track, and addressed issues early so they never became problems. It was clear she was fully engaged and committed to achieving the best outcome. Selling property can be complicated, but having someone as responsive, knowledgeable, and proactive as Nicole makes all the difference. I would not hesitate to recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor who delivers excellent results and outstanding service.

Buyer review
Exceptional Experience
4 months ago
Exceptional Experience

We had an exceptional experience working with Nicole and cannot recommend her highly enough. She was knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely invested in helping us buy a new home and sell our current one. She was always willing to answer question and explain details we didn’t understand. Nicole was proactive, honest, and calm throughout the entire process. We would highly recommend her to anyone looking for an agent that goes above and beyond!

Buyer review
We had a wonderful experience buying and selling our homes.
4 months ago
We had a wonderful experience buying and selling our homes.

We met Nicole in 2020 when we bought our home in the country. We were impressed with her knowledge of all aspects of real estate,as this is our third home we have purchased with her as our realtor.Nicole answers all questions we had whether buying or selling our homes,offering guidance and reassurance.She is thoughtful and respectful of us and our homes through out the process I do not hesitate to highly recommend her for anyones real estate needs.

Buyer review
A Realtor with your Best Interest in Mind!
9 months ago
A Realtor with your Best Interest in Mind!

We had a wonderful experience working with Nicole! She was timely with all responses and was always on the lookout for homes that came on the market in the area we preferred. She gave great guidance on navigating the home buying process and ALWAYS had our best interest in mind! We would recommend Nicole to anyone without a doubt! Definitely will be in touch in the future if we decide to sell and buy a new home.

Show all 55 reviews
map

Nicole's properties

Nicole has 2 properties for sale and sold 26 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 27, 2026
$80,000
3007 West CR-52
Tiffin OH 44883
Land
Listing courtesy of The Danberry Co
Under Contract
$314,900
15857 State Route 568
Findlay OH 45840
3
2
6
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of The Danberry Co
SoldApr 15, 2026
$180,000
400 Rosewood Avenue
Findlay OH 45840
3
1
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of LPG Realty and The Danberry Co
SoldApr 9, 2026
$188,200
528 Rector Ave
Findlay OH 45840
3
2
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of The Danberry Co and Superior PLUS Realtors
Show all 28 properties

Nicole's sold properties

Nicole has sold 26 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
3007 West CR-52, Tiffin, OH, 44883
3007 West CR-52
Tiffin OH 44883
Land$80,000Apr 27, 2026
400 Rosewood Avenue, Findlay, OH, 45840
400 Rosewood Avenue
Findlay OH 45840
3
1
2
Single-Family$180,000Apr 15, 2026
528 Rector Ave, Findlay, OH, 45840
528 Rector Ave
Findlay OH 45840
3
2
4
Single-Family$188,200Apr 9, 2026
707 Winterhaven Drive, Findlay, OH, 45840
707 Winterhaven Drive
Findlay OH 45840
3
2
2
Single-Family$269,900Mar 18, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent