From 8 reviews overall

Nicholas Casillo
WNY Real Estate

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Erie County
58 Suzette Drive Cheektowaga
Nick was very knowledgeable and patient with us during the whole process! We were looking for our first house last summer sort of on the fly because we didn’t anticipate buying in 2025, but we decided we needed to get out of our old apartment asap! Nick was incredible about scheduling us in to see different properties and was very down to Earth and easygoing while pointing out very important details to us. We never felt pressure to pick a property. We had placed an offer on one house and it was accepted, but ultimately my husband (and then later on myself as well) decided it was not the right place for us. Nick was so patient and worked with us through that. I had a lot of FOMO (fear of missing out) when we first were looking and we definitely jumped the gun on that one! But it all worked out because the next home we made an offer on was the keeper! And we are happy with where we ended up! Nick was a wonderful guide and we really appreciate him and absolutely recommend him to others as an agent! Thank you again Nick! Bless you and your family!
7 Parliament Lane Lancaster
I would be lying if I didn't admit I considered selling my house without a Realtor, and I'm glad I ended up calling Nick. Nick spent months helping us find the right home, showing after showing after showing. Never once did he get impatient, annoyed, and he always gave us honest feedback. His goal wasn't to get a sale fast, it was to take the time and find the right house. Nick helped us find a beautiful home, guided us on when and how to offer, and helped navigate the entire process. He was always available with perfect communications. He also helped us sell our house fast, with an abundance of offers after an insanely busy open house coupled with numerous private showings. Buying & selling a house can be complex, and scary! Nick made it easy! I 100% recommend Nick!
From 16 reviews overall

Jeanmarie Muscarella
716 Realty Group

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Erie County
55 Princeton Place Buffalo
Jeanmarie was excellent throughout the entire process. Her communication style was clear, prompt, and consistent—she always kept us informed and answered questions quickly. She has strong market knowledge and gave great advice that helped us make confident decisions. Her negotiation skills really stood out, ensuring we got the best possible outcome. On top of that, she was professional, organized, and easy to work with from start to finish. I would highly recommend Jeanmarie to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
3436 Cedar Valley Way Hamburg
Jeanine was such an amazing realtor to work with. My husband and I were brand new to the home buying process. Jeanie kept us grounded and focused on the goal, budget, and the smartest financial investment for our future. She walked us through all aspects of the home buying process including using data & other real estate transactions to further inform our choices! She also got tough when we needed her to, she worked out numerous delays with the seller/ mortgage company & always kept our application top of mind for the lender. We would absolutely go with Jeanie and 716 Realty group for future investments & real estate transactions!
From 5 reviews overall

Salvatore Dentico
Realty ONE Group Empower
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Erie County
210 Clark Street Tonawanda Town
Sal was such a pleasure to work with— It was my first time selling a house and I had all the questions that he was more than happy to sit & answer. Doing that gave me such peace of mind through the entire process! He was calm, cool and never made me feel like my questions or concerns were silly. From listing the house to the closing, he was there and kept me informed of each step to keep it all flowing smoothly. If I am ever in the market to purchase a new home, I would call Sal in a heart beat!
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Erie County