Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 85345
235/11411 North 91st Avenue Peoria
Carolyn is knowledgeable and professional, but easy to communicate with. Always friendly and able to answer questions clearly and conciseley. She stayed in constant communication so the closing went very smoothly. She gave us referrals for vendors that have been as thorough and professional as she is - huge help! We will be recommending Carolyn to anyone in need of a realtor - she made the process easy and stress free.
From 343 reviews overall

Elise Fay
Sibbach Team - eXp Realty

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 85345
7014 West Cesar Street Peoria
Elise was our agent when we purchased our townhome in 2020. We turned to her when we needed to sell. With 3 other townhomes in the community for sale, it was a little challenging, but Elise made sure the job of selling our townhouse got done! She makes the process of buying and/or selling property so easy. Thank you so much Elise!
9038 W Orchid Ln Peoria
Elise helped us navigate the sale of our Phoenix home from out of state, which involved a lot of moving parts. She took on the coordination of everything—painting, repairs, carpet—using her own network, which was a huge relief and made a stressful process much more manageable. That level of hands-on help is something we truly valued and honestly wish we had access to in Denver now!
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Arizona2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Maricopa County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Peoria2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
United States2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Southwest Region2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Glendale2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 85345
B/10134 North 97th Avenue Peoria
Karen and I have worked together on many houses I bought and sold several with her. Since I can be a bit of a high maintenance client, Karen was ideal for me as she kept me in the loop all the time communicated through calls and texts.She was checking the market and keeping me informed of what we could do and couldn’t do she kept me calm during inspection times and help me through whatever I needed to fix in order to make the deal go through. The reason I keep using Karen dunston is because she always has done good by me and I’ve always come out ahead and with my brain intact as she takes the pressure on her and not on her client, I’m very grateful for her
From 241 reviews overall

Celeste Mcivor
eXp Realty, LLC (Referral Div - Arizona)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 85345
12630 West Eveningside Drive Sun City West
Being from Chicago/Boston, we TOTALLY lucked out when we met Celeste and Jeff and used their talents and services as our agents to buy our AZ home. Where to even start! They are amazing people. So kind, thoughtful and knowledgeable. Very detail orientated and highly communicative, answering any communications from us quickly while also keeping us proactively informed at every stage of the process. To say they go the extra mile would be an understatement. I cannot recommend them more highly. In a world where finding really good people is hard to do, Celeste and Jeff stand as reminders that straight up good, honest and thoughtful humans still exist. Thank you to you both and we look forward to our new friendship.
16643 West Yucatan Drive Surprise
The Mcivor team was absolutely amazing during a very high-stress period for us. From the moment we started, they kept in constant contact, providing the experienced perspective we desperately needed to meet our goal: selling our house quickly without sacrificing a competitive price. Celeste and her husband are the ultimate professionals. They knew exactly which strategic repairs and upgrades would offer the "best bang for our buck." Perhaps most impressively, they had a plethora of reliable contacts on speed dial who helped transform our home into beautiful, like-new, market-ready shape in record time! We feel incredibly blessed to have found Celeste. We were able to rely implicitly on her advice from the very beginning, and it paid off. If you want a realtor who is proactive, knowledgeable, and genuinely cares about your outcome, look no further than the Mcivor team. We couldn't have done it without them!
15219 West Via Manana Sun City West
Working with Celeste was a truly positive experience. She was always responsive, patient, and accommodating—no matter how many questions I had or how detailed I needed things to be. She coordinated everything around my tight timeline. What I appreciated most was her attentiveness and the sense that she genuinely cared about helping me make the right decisions. She never made me feel rushed or pressured, and she consistently followed through on everything. She was especially helpful during the walkthrough and inspections and recommended excellent, trustworthy contractors Celeste is not only very knowledgeable, but also a great person to work with. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a reliable and supportive realtor.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
Arizona2026County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Maricopa County2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
United States2026Region Top 20
ratemyagent award
Southwest Region2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Surprise2026