Paula McCabe

Paula McCabe

REALTOR® at PREFERRED SHORE
FL: SL3494293
  •   5   (10 reviews)

About Paula

I wasn't born here but I was definitely raised here. I moved here when I was 4 and I have witnessed the growth of the Sarasota and Manatee Counties. For over 40 years I have seen neighborhoods start, evolve, diminished and be revamped again. To say I can guide you in the direction of your new home desires, well that is a given. I grew up in this county, I left once to experience the world from a soldiers perspective. A veteran of the US Army and strongly support our military 100%. There is nothing compared to the knowledge you gain as a 19 year old out on your own, serving your country. I wouldn't trade it for any other path that may have been available back then. Real Estate may be my daily grind, but I have a lot of experience from previous careers & businesses that make me great at what I do. Customer service lacks entirely these days no matter what aspect of business you're in. Running your own business and building something from nothing, well it is what drives me for exceptional client satisfaction.

Paula's reviews

  5  
Paula has 10 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 6.
Review Paula
about 3 years ago
Patient patient

She is very patient and answers every question day or night

about 3 years ago
Fantastic

Working with Paula was a fantastic experience. She is a true professional. She sold our property for more than we expected. I couldn’t have asked for a better representative. She was truly a blessing.

over 3 years ago
Helped us get our dream home!

We arrived in Florida from Ohio looking for a home. We had a budget, an idea and four days to find a home. We looked at over a dozen homes in three days; all the while Paula was patient and understanding to our needs. On the last day, the last house we saw was it! After deciding this was the home, thats when Paula really showed what an amazing real estate she is. She began negotiating with the seller's agent, understanding our budget constraints and timing of our move. After only several hours of negotiations, our offer was accepted! It was Paula's determination and willingness to work with us that led to the successful conclusion of our whirlwind house hunting trip. We couldn't have been more happy to have had Paula on our side. Her dedication and expertise won the day. And after the sale, Paula was there for us. Answering our questions, communicating with the seller's agent, providing us with all that we needed once we finally moved in. Even after we moved in, Paula was there for us. She is truly amazing and we would recommend her to anyone looking for their forever home!

over 3 years ago
Great realtor!

Paula showed us a condo in Esplanade at LWR that we came across on realtor.com. She replied immediately to our request to look at the property that afternoon. She was very nice, knowledgeable of the area and thorough. We decided to make an offer and she suggested a price but was very open to what we felt was a comfortable offer. She negotiated well with the seller's agent and we were very happy with the price we settled on. She recommended a fantastic inspector who came out in two days and gave a great report that was easy to read. She was on top of all "to-do" items throughout the process. She's extremely pleasant and easy to work with along with knowledgeable. We bought the first property we looked at and Paula made it a seamless experience. Highly recommend.

over 3 years ago
Absolutely wonderful

Where do I even begin with this review… Paula is truly such a wonderfully incredible human being and realtor. This was our first time buying a home and Paula was not only informative throughout the whole process but also so willing and determined to help us find a home in our budget. She constantly went above and beyond to set up showings for us and then when we finally did find the one, to help us get the best outcome possible despite how crazy the market was at the time we bought. Instead of telling us that our budget or expectations were not a reality in that market, she made it happen for us and helped us find something that was perfect for our family. Not only that, but when we did do showings she helped us with our toddler who absolutely loved her as well! :) Paula is such a genuinely kind and good hearted person, our family will continue to use her for any other realtor services we may need in the future and we will be referring her to anyone who needs realty services as well! :) thank you Paula from the bottom of our hearts!

Show all 10 reviews

Paula's properties

Paula has 9 properties for sale and sold 3 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$369,900
11016 Daybreak Glen
Manatee County FL 34219
3
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of COMPASS FLORIDA LLC
For Sale
$420,000
418 Edwards Drive
Sarasota FL 34243
2
1
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of COMPASS FLORIDA LLC
Pending
$278,000
24-201/3758 Parkridge Cir
Sarasota FL 34243
3
2
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of COMPASS FLORIDA LLC
Pending
$267,000
110/304 108th Street West
Bradenton FL 34209
2
2
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of COMPASS FLORIDA LLC
Show all 12 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent