Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 57 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Nicole is an excellent realtor and is very knowledgeable in every aspect of her job!
over 4 years ago
Nicole is an excellent realtor and is very knowledgeable in every aspect of her job!

My sister had unexpectedly died and it was up to her three sisters to sell her house etc. Through a dear friend of mine Nicole was suggested! With the crazy house market as it was we actually got an offer the first day it was posted online! Also at this time I underwent a hip replacement so Nicole could not have been more compassionate and helpful! I really do not think we could have done it as well without her! Her knowledge of contractors helped us so much! She is so smart and she certainly knows her job inside and out ! I would highly recommend her!

Seller review
The Best Professional Possible
over 4 years ago
The Best Professional Possible

We had decided to retire here in Findlay, where Scott grew up. Our son and daughter-in-law were helping us in the purchase. Our daughter and son-in-law were in Findlay and were our "eyes" on this end. We certainly presented Nicole a challenge with so many parties involved. She absolutely went above and beyond in every aspect, keeping all parties informed and updated. The seller's agent was less than "ethical" in her dealings, but Nicole kept the transaction above board and honest, resulting in the purchase of our home. We couldn't have asked for a better realtor, and all of us consider Nicole a family friend!! We can't thank her enough and will recommend her to anyone in need of a realtor.

Buyer review
Excellent experience
over 4 years ago
Excellent experience

Working with Nicole was a great experience. She was able to help us find the home of our dreams with such ease in a difficult market. We were always able to contact her with questions or concerns and she was prompt to give us a response.

Seller review
Rock Star!!!
almost 5 years ago
Rock Star!!!

There is so much more to buying/selling real estate than just the purchase contract. Nicole helped us feel comfortable navigating through the entire process. We firmly believe we would not have gotten the best deal had we not utilized the tools of a professional realtor. Nicole has earned our trust on multiple real estate transactions.

Buyer review
Recent Home Purchase Experience with Nicole
almost 5 years ago
Recent Home Purchase Experience with Nicole

We have bought and sold may homes through the years and have had many realtor experiences, both good and bad. Our recent experience with Nicole Hartschuh was one of our most positive experiences. Nicole is very knowledgeable of the Findlay real estate market and extremely responsive to all our questions. She listened to our home requirements and only showed us homes that fit within our budget and specific home "must haves". As we narrowed the search to 2 homes, she gave us excellent insights as to the pros and cons of both homes. We felt she tried to give us as much knowledge as possible so we could make an educated decision on which home to purchase. She was also very helpful in guiding us through a very successful closing. If we buy or sell another home in the Findlay area, there is no doubt we will contact Nicole to be our realtor.

Seller review
Excellent Experience
about 5 years ago
Excellent Experience

We could not have asked for a better realtor than Nicole. She answered all our questions, found answers to those that she didn't know off-hand, kept communication open, and was available whenever we needed her. She took a seemingly overwhelmingly huge process and broke it down for us, made us feel comfortable, kept us in the loop, and made us feel like a priority. I would recommend Nicole to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Super knowledgeable and easy to work with
about 5 years ago
Super knowledgeable and easy to work with

My husband and I loved working with Nicole! You could tell she knew what she was talking about as she saw things we didn't when viewing properties. She also knew what questions to ask to find out more information about properties. If we had questions she was quick to get us answers. She worked really hard to find us the house we wanted for our family in our price range.

Buyer review
Excellent and professional experience
about 5 years ago
Excellent and professional experience

Nicole was quick to respond to all of my emails and questions. She very knowledgeable, patient and professional with the houses that she showed us. She was always in our corner and i would recommend her to anyone including myself if i ever need a realtor again in the future.

Buyer review
Committed to your success
about 5 years ago
Committed to your success

Nicole is wonderful to work with. Her knowledge and experience helped us get the deal we were looking for on multiple properties. Always punctual, even when we're not. Easy to work with and a great friend. She works FOR you so you can get the best/fair deal. Nicole structured a deal for us that had an automatic limited counter-offer increase to beat out opposing bids. Had we not had this, we would have lost the deal. Total credit goes to her dudiligence, knowledge and professionalism. Other instances were her advice on market analysis. She has saved us on many occasions when we thought the deal was "right" for us. She's the one we trust with our real estate investments.

49 - 57 of 57
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent