Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 57 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Nicole is Amazing!
almost 4 years ago
Nicole is Amazing!

We were being relocated for my job and had not been to Findlay before. We needed someone that was willing to work with us to find a home quickly. When we reached out to Nicole, it was like she was the answer to our prayers. We were only able to come to Findlay a couple of times to look at houses, but when we did, we were able to look at a lot in a short amount of time. She was able to guide us through the entire process. She made everything seamless. We were able to do everything remotely except closing on the house, but we were already in Findlay for my job by the time we closed. We honestly loved working with her and would highly recommend anyone looking to buy or sell a house to reach out to Nicole, she is fantastic!

Buyer review
Excellent experience!!
almost 4 years ago
Excellent experience!!

Our previous realtor was trying to slow down and recommended we work with Nicole. Nicole was amazing!! We had some very specific things in mind for this property and she was very patient with us. She knows the area, she picked up on what we were looking for and was SUPER diligent on getting us in to newly-listed properties right away. Nicole was so responsive. We had a wonderful experience with her will most definitely call on her for our future needs and I would highly recommend her!

Seller review
Nicole is wonderful!
almost 4 years ago
Nicole is wonderful!

Nicole listed our home in September 2022. The market was volatile and interest rates were going up steadily. She made sure to guide us to a perfect listing price. She what is attentive and put up with our many questions. We sold our home in five days above asking with three offers.

Buyer review
Nicole is amazing
about 4 years ago
Nicole is amazing

Nicole was amazing from the start! As a first time homebuyer, it was reassuring to consult someone with such an extensive knowledge, who also talked us through every step along the way. She really got to know what Charity and I were looking for in a home, but she also got to know us as people. Many thoughtful gestures and encouraging words let us know that we were appreciated and reassured us when we weren't sure if the right house would come. We had a small budget and big expectations, yet Nicole stayed patient, kind, and diligent in finding us a home. I appreciated that she would often reach out when she saw new things come onto the market even though she also set up a portal to automatically notify us. She was very willing to show us homes all the time; her flexibility with scheduling was nothing short of incredible. She definitely made us feel as if we were her main priority. Nicole is very knowledgeable about the market and processes in buying a home. She did not push us into anything, she helped us understand what we didn't know, and it always felt like she was working for us. I would recommend her to anyone!

Seller review
Great job!
about 4 years ago
Great job!

Nicole did a great job! Kept us informed throughout the whole process. Thanks Nicole!

Seller review
Nicole went above and beyond with selling our home.
about 4 years ago
Nicole went above and beyond with selling our home.

We would not hesitate to recommend Nicole for all of your realtor needs.She is always professional and knows the market quite well.Nicole answered any questions we had and kept us apprised of what was going on.

Buyer review
Knowledgeable, Helpful, Friendly
about 4 years ago
Knowledgeable, Helpful, Friendly

Nicole Hartschuh patiently worked with us for several months as we searched for just the right home and with her guidance, we found it! Nicole is very informed about the market as well as being responsive and extremely helpful. With her guidance and leadership, we were able to identify and purchase our retirement home, then quickly list & sell our existing home. If you're looking for a warm and friendly, well informed and SMART agent, please consider Nicole Hartschuh. We are very pleased with every aspect of our real estate purchase and sale with her and highly recommend her. And now we call her Friend!

Buyer review
Wonderful in every regard
about 4 years ago
Wonderful in every regard

Working with Nicole was a wonderful experience. She took a very stressful situation and made it pleasant and quick. The amount of work she did on our behalf made the process of buying our new home seamless, from our perspective. She made herself available and was able to make appointments that worked with our crazy schedule. So thankful to have had Nicole as our realtor.

Seller review
Wonderful experience
about 4 years ago
Wonderful experience

Nicole is very knowledgeable and helpful. Was there to answer my questions. She also helped to calm me down when I got a little stressed with the process. Nicole made this a very pleasant experience.

Seller review
Awesome Job!!
about 4 years ago
Awesome Job!!

Nicole made the process very smooth with great advice and timely updates the whole way through!! We would HIGHLY recommend her!! Couldn’t be happier with the care she gave us.

Buyer review
Nicole did a great job
about 4 years ago
Nicole did a great job

Nicole helped us find our home after some crazy changes in our lives the last few months. She was very supportive, never pushy, knowledgeable about the housing market and the area, and simply pleasant and kind. She did a great job, and we would highly recommend working her.

37 - 48 of 57
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent