Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 57 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Outstanding experience!
over 2 years ago
Outstanding experience!

Nicole was excellent to work with. Readily available, super responsive, and knows the Findlay market well. Highly recommend!

Seller review
Thanks for smooth real estate transaction
over 2 years ago
Thanks for smooth real estate transaction

We highly recommend Nicole to anyone looking to sell or buy their home . Her professionalism, expertise, and dedication exceeded our expectations. Thanks Nicole smooth real estate transaction . You are awesome .

Buyer review
Excellent Agent!
about 3 years ago
Excellent Agent!

Nile is very professional, conscientious and patient! She knows the local market very well and brought a lot of knowledge to our various viewings. She followed up on issues with no prompting and offered possible solutions along the way. Buying a house is a BIG deal, and I trusted Nicole’s expertise throughout the process.

Seller review
Easy to Work With
about 3 years ago
Easy to Work With

Nicole did a nice job representing us on the recent home purchase. We would use her again.

Buyer review
GREAT! Put US First!
about 3 years ago
GREAT! Put US First!

Nicole was amazing to work with. Great communication skills and put our needs first. We had never been to Findlay, and she was able to show us around. Due to timing/travel, we had to facetime a few houses and actually bought one that way. We had 100% trust in her opinion and views on the house and market. When my wife and I walked into our house for the first time we knew instantly that Nicole guided our family to the right home!

Seller review
Excellent Experience!
about 3 years ago
Excellent Experience!

Nicole is easy to work with and very knowledgeable. My wife and I used her to buy our current home and then I used her to sell my old home. She answers all questions in a timely manner and does everything she can to make the process easy for you. If you're looking for an agent, you should choose Nicole!

Seller review
Nicole did an outstanding job!
about 3 years ago
Nicole did an outstanding job!

From our very first contact, Nicole was professional and positive. She is clearly in charge of every aspect of selling a house. She is easy to work with, and made the entire process smooth and easy for me. Nicole managed to work around my own failure to get the house ready on time, and once we actually had it on the market, she sold it in two days. In addition, she really did her homework and helped me realize a higher price than I would have gotten without her knowledge and input. I would recommend her to any seller, and I am sure she would be equally as good at helping someone find and buy a house.

Buyer review
Professional and Personable!
over 3 years ago
Professional and Personable!

Nicole was recommended to us by a friend. She was described as patient, not pushy, but knowledgeable. Once in contact with her she was nothing short of any of those qualities. It was our first experience with a realtor and was so prompt from emails, phone calls, and txt. She went above and beyond to reach out to any sources that we needed. Even if it wasnt "realtor" related problems and she has many connections with community. I will not only recommend her but keep in touch with her. She made our buying experience as smooth and quick as possible!

Seller review
Patient and professional
over 3 years ago
Patient and professional

Nicole has been very kind and patient with us. We had many questions and she was able to answer them all. The buyer had some issues and there was a lot of back and forth. She kept us up dated every time. Thanks Nicole!!

Seller review
Fantastic
over 3 years ago
Fantastic

Great knowledge of the housing market. Top notch in getting your home listed. Keeps you well informed and helps guide you through your selling process. I will definitely recommend Nicole Hartschuh and will use her again to sell or buy a home. THANK YOU!

Buyer review
Nicole is Great!
over 3 years ago
Nicole is Great!

We loved working with Nicole. She was so informative and continued to answer all of our questions in a timely manner. She is very personable, knows her job well and does a great job of knowing her clients likes and dislikes. She was great to work with and I would easily recommend her to others!

Seller review
Best realtor out there!
over 3 years ago
Best realtor out there!

Nicole was very professional and friendly. Clearly explaining all options and steps along the way, there was no guess work. She made herself available and was easy to talk to. I would recommend her as a realtor to anyone.

25 - 36 of 57
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent