Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 55 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
over 1 year ago
Great Sense of Support

As a first time home buyer, I was absolutely clueless on what the intricacies of the process of home buying entailed. I am very appreciated of having Nicole there to walk me through this process as she made it very seamless even considering the road bumps along the way that we had to deal with. Additionally, Nicole was quite flexible with my busy work schedule to have meetings and phone calls later in the day. Thank you for everything, Nicole!

over 1 year ago
Nicole is the BEST!!

Nicole was everything we could have asked for in a realtor. Being first time home buyers, we had very little knowledge of what to look for and what to expect. Nicole was always willing to help us with anything. We had been looking for a house for almost a year and Nicole was incredibly patient with us and was always looking out for our best interest. She was incredibly kind and responsive! There is no doubt that we would choose her again!!

over 1 year ago
The best of the best!

My Husband and I had the pleasure of working with Nicole, and I can't recommend her enough. From start to finish, she was incredibly knowledgeable, professional, and attentive to our needs. Nicole made the entire process of selling our house a breeze, guiding us with expert advice and ensuring we understood every step. Nicole’s deep understanding of the market and local area was invaluable, and she was able to get our house sold in under a month over asking! Communication was always clear and timely, and we felt supported throughout. If you're looking for a trustworthy and skilled realtor, Nicole is the one!

over 1 year ago
"Fast, Easy, and Professional—Exceeded All Expectations!"

Working with Nicole was fantastic! Her expertise and guidance were invaluable in maximizing the value of our home, and I was blown away by how quickly the sale happened. She made the entire process so smooth and stress-free, always accommodating my calls and questions with professionalism and care. If you’re looking for a realtor who is knowledgeable, responsive, and truly invested in your success, I can’t recommend Nicole highly enough! She exceeded all my expectations and made selling our home a fantastic experience.

almost 2 years ago
Great experience from start to finish!

We contacted Nicole before we were ready to sell, and she was extremely helpful in answering our questions and setting our expectations. Once we were ready, she was very quick to help us get the property ready, listed, and sold. Excellent communication throughout! And excellent market knowledge - she knew exactly where to price our property. We had a great experience and would recommend her to anyone!

almost 2 years ago
Knowledgeable, professional, easy to work with

We would recommend Nicole Hartschuh in a heartbeat! She is knowledgeable, professional, and so easy to work with. She works with a sense of urgency, is prompt in her responses, and also ensured our desires and needs were heard and met. We couldn't have asked for a better experience buying our new home and selling our old home. We had been looking for a home for quite some time and were looking for very specific characteristics in our new home. Nicole quickly understood what we wanted and worked diligently to find it - within our budget! She made the buying and selling processes straightforward and painless. Highly recommend!

about 2 years ago
5 stars isn’t enough. 11/10 from me!

This was my first house, Nicole made me feel like I’ve done this 100 times. She is very attentive, And did an amazing job explaining everything to a person that had never done this before. Always on time and never late with anything. Not only made this experience, fun, but stress-free as well. My forever realtor! Thank you so much!!

about 2 years ago
Hard Stuff Made Easy

Working with Nicole was very easy, from the initial discussions to closing. While I live a few hours from town, I always sensed a local connection. Finally, the photos arranged by Nicole were excellent, providing the right first impression. Thanks, Nicole.

about 2 years ago
Dependable and Hard Working

Nicole was instrumental in keeping multiple property purchases moving along simultaneously. She was very dependable and kept all parties apprised of each update along the way. I could not have done it without her! Highly recommend Nicole for your next real estate need.

about 2 years ago
Nicole is the best

Nicole is amazing!! As a first time home buyer she made the process as smooth as possible for me. She explained each step thoroughly and had excellent communication throughout the entire process whenever I had questions about anything. She was there every step of the way, from the first time I saw my home to the day of closing. I wouldn’t have been able to buy my first home without her knowledge of the market and experience in the field. She is seriously wonderful at what she does and I would recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor!

about 2 years ago
Outstanding experience!

Nicole was excellent to work with. Readily available, super responsive, and knows the Findlay market well. Highly recommend!

about 2 years ago
Thanks for smooth real estate transaction

We highly recommend Nicole to anyone looking to sell or buy their home . Her professionalism, expertise, and dedication exceeded our expectations. Thanks Nicole smooth real estate transaction . You are awesome .

13 - 24 of 55
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent