Kayla Maathuis

Kayla Maathuis

Associate Broker at Compass Colorado, LLC
NAR: 038215
  •   5   (44 reviews)

About Kayla

A proud Colorado native, I embrace an active lifestyle on my 50-acre horse property in Pine, CO. My passion for horses includes liberty work, trail riding, working with cows, and Western Dressage. In 2022, I welcomed a mustang into my life, embarking on the journey of gentling and training him. My love for real estate grew from building my own home in 2019, giving me hands-on experience that benefits my clients. With over 14 years in real estate, I’ve helped more than 250 clients across the Denver Metro and foothills areas. As a top-producing agent along the 285 Corridor, I specialize in horse properties, residential homes, mountain properties, and vacant land. I average 15 transactions per year—double the production of the average agent—and have closed over $85 million in sales. Beyond real estate, I support local businesses through community videos, strengthening the connections that make this area special. If you're ready for your next move, I’m here to guide you on Your Journey Home with expertise, dedication, and a passion for Colorado living.

Kayla's reviews

  5  
Kayla has 44 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 6.
Review Kayla
7 months ago
Kayla, absolutely fantastic.

Working with Kayla to sell my home was an outstanding experience from start to finish. She is extremely competent, very professional, and incredibly knowledgeable about every step of the process. What really stood out was how consistently she kept me informed—she communicated clearly, promptly, and made sure I always understood what was happening and what to expect next. Kayla’s guidance made the entire sale smooth and stress-free as possible, and her expertise was evident in every detail. I felt confident throughout the process knowing she was on my side. I highly recommend Kayla to anyone looking for a dedicated and reliable real estate professional.

11 months ago
Quick and Straight Forward

Hey Kayla. Thanks for the great work. Just 21 days on the market was way over my expectations. This process was quick and straight forward. Really appreciated! Thanks for helping me sell! Michael

about 1 year ago
Amazing Experience with Relocating

We had an amazing experience working with Kayla! We were relocating from out of town and starting the search for a home where we could begin raising our family. Kayla understood just how important this next chapter was for us and made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and even enjoyable. Every weekend we came into town, she maximized our time—lining up full days of showings and helping us explore around 50 homes. She was quick on her feet to find alternative listings if needed. Throughout it all, she was incredibly patient, thoughtful, and never made us feel rushed. She truly listened to what we needed for our growing family and stayed focused on finding a space that would not only work for us now but also grow with us in the years ahead. Kayla’s local expertise, responsiveness, and attention to detail were unmatched. She made sure we felt supported and informed at every step, and we always knew she had our best interests at heart. Thanks to her, we found a home we absolutely love—and we’re so excited to build our future there. Beyond being a fantastic real estate agent, Kayla became someone we genuinely enjoyed spending time with. After seeing so many homes together, talking through so many decisions, and navigating all the highs and lows of the process, we truly built a friendship along the way. That personal connection made the experience even more special, and we’re so grateful for it. If you’re looking for someone who is kind, dedicated, and truly invested in helping you find the right fit, Kayla is the one!

over 1 year ago
Smiles are contagious!

Kayla was a great realtor to deal with. She was always positive, had a smile on her face at all times and did her best to help us with everything, right? Our sale went wonderful. I would definitely recommend her to all my friends and use her again.If needed.

over 1 year ago
Fantastic Experience with Unique Property

Kayla worked with us for over a year as we prepared our property for sale, with no guarantee we’d use her as our listing agent. Of course we did, as she’s phenomenal! Our property was a restored mountain home with acreage on the river, and she marketed it wonderfully, highlighting what made it so special. Kayla is very knowledgeable regarding county laws, septic systems, wells, and mountain homes in general. We had other realtors asking to represent us, but we preferred Kayla’s knowledge level and that she was local to our property. Our buyers were from out of state, and she handled the complicated transaction seamlessly. We highly recommend Kayla and wouldn’t hesitate to work with her again!

almost 2 years ago
Our experience was Kayla was great!

Our experience overall with Kayla was great! I do feel like we could have gotten a little more $ for the sale of the home, as we were under contract in 5 days. But it was nice just having one showing/ one offer. I think the photographer she uses did a fantastic job, and her marketing skills were excellent. Her communication was great also. I would recommend her to other sellers!

Show all 44 reviews

Kayla's properties

Kayla has 1 property for sale, showing 1, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$400,000
17465 CR-96
Jefferson County CO 80433
1
4
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REMAX Alliance | Conifer
Show all 1 property
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent