Elise's profile

Elise's reviews

  5  
Elise has 347 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Elise's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, supportive, detail-oriented, great negotiation, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Elise was very professional and wonderful to work with!
11 months ago
Elise was very professional and wonderful to work with!

Elise was on top of our sale from the start. She provided insight and support throughout the process. She was always available for questions and provided resolutions. Elise is a straight shooter and is open and honest. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a hassle free agent who has your back. Thanks Elise.

Buyer review
Fun experience
12 months ago
Fun experience

I had the absolute pleasure of working with Elise, and I cannot recommend her enough. From our very first meeting, She was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping me find the perfect home. She was always responsive, patient with my questions, and offered expert guidance every step of the way. What impressed me most was how well they understood my needs and preferences—they truly listened. They went above and beyond to schedule viewings, negotiate on my behalf, and make the entire process smooth and stress-free.

Seller review
If you are looking to sell your house quickly and for top dollar, Elise is your "Must Have" agent!
12 months ago
If you are looking to sell your house quickly and for top dollar, Elise is your "Must Have" agent!

Elise is very knowledgeable about current market trends and knew how to get the most money in a very short amount of time. She listened to all my wants and wishes and worked within my rather short timeline to put together a phenomenal deal, especially given the current market. She is extremely professional with just the right amount of feistiness when called for. Elise is the agent you want on your side for sure!!

Seller review
Minimized the stress of selling from out of state
about 1 year ago
Minimized the stress of selling from out of state

Elise helped us navigate the sale of our Phoenix home from out of state, which involved a lot of moving parts. She took on the coordination of everything—painting, repairs, carpet—using her own network, which was a huge relief and made a stressful process much more manageable. That level of hands-on help is something we truly valued and honestly wish we had access to in Denver now!

Buyer review
Elise is a fantastic Realtor
about 1 year ago
Elise is a fantastic Realtor

Elise is easy to work with. Her expert knowledge of the area was very helpful. She was always available to answer our questions in a timely manner. She listened to our requests and concerns and went out of her way to make the purchase of our new home easy from a distance. We will be recommending her to family & friends!

Buyer review
You totally can trust Elise
about 1 year ago
You totally can trust Elise

Elise is trustworthy and knowledgeable. She can point out the advantages or drawbacks about a house before you realize it. I never felt any pressure from her, working with her felt easy like with a good friend you've known for longtime. Even after I bought the house, she kept checking in to make sure everything was going well.

Seller review
Great service all around
about 1 year ago
Great service all around

I told her what I was looking to do, and that I was looking to sell pretty quickly. She gave me all my options and explained what would work best for me. Throughout the process she answered all my questions. Elise pushed to get me what I was looking for all the way until my home sold. I would definitely recommend her to others.

Seller review
List your home with Elise
about 1 year ago
List your home with Elise

Selling a home in todays market is not easy. Don't tell that to Elise Fay. She made the process stress free, handled everything and sold our home in no time. Her ability to communicate with us made every hurdle painless and manageable. Combine that with her negotiating ability and professionalism, Elise gave us peace of mind and ultimately more money for our home. Thank you Elise. You're truly the best.

Seller review
Recommended Agent
about 1 year ago
Recommended Agent

Elise is awesome. That's all there really is to say.

Seller review
Review Headline: Exceptional, Compassionate, and Professional Service
about 1 year ago
Review Headline: Exceptional, Compassionate, and Professional Service

Working with Elise Fay has been a truly remarkable experience. Despite the distance, as she is based in Arizona and we are in Ohio, Elise seamlessly managed the entire process of selling our property. Her punctuality, attention to detail, and proactive communication ensured we were always in the loop, making us feel included and informed at every stage. Elise went above and beyond, not only keeping us updated but also including us in critical homeowner discussions, making this a truly collaborative effort. Her compassion and genuine passion for her work are evident in every interaction. She treats her clients like family, ensuring they fully understand the process and feel confident in every decision. Recommended to us by Marcus Muhammad, a trusted realtor in Ohio, Elise exceeded all expectations, providing exceptional guidance and support from start to finish. If you are looking for a dedicated, thorough, and genuinely caring real estate professional, look no further than Elise Fay. Thank you, Elise, for making this experience smooth and stress-free.

Buyer review
Highly recommend Elise
about 1 year ago
Highly recommend Elise

Elise took the time to understand our needs and preferences, making us feel like more than just prospective buyers. Her personalized approach and commitment to our best interests ensured we found the perfect home. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience!

Seller review
Excellent Service on Peoria, AZ Home Sale
about 1 year ago
Excellent Service on Peoria, AZ Home Sale

Ms. Fay was exceptional on same if our lease home to existing tenant. She assisted us in presale repair options, tenant handholding, and final closing documentation. As we live in NY, we could not ask for a better local agent. Highly recommended. Thank you Elise!

25 - 36 of 347
© 2026 RateMyAgent