Elise's profile

Elise's reviews

  5  
Elise has 343 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Elise's qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, supportive, detail-oriented, great negotiation, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Smooth Sailing All The Way
5 months ago
Smooth Sailing All The Way

The entire experience with Elise on the sale of our home was 1st rate. She was extremely knowledgeable of the Westbrook area which insured we got top price for our home. She pointed out key areas to invest $$$ that would maximize the home's value as well as providing excellent contractor references to get the work done. Elise was especially helpful during the inspection phase where lots of deals hit snags. She was a prompt communicator when issues came up and was also quick to offer potential solutions to keep things moving forward. Our close went seamlessly based on her jumping in using her industry knowledge to follow up with all the key players involved throughout the process. You cannot find a more experienced or professional Realtor than Elise.

Buyer review
My experience with Elise Fay was amazing!!!!
6 months ago
My experience with Elise Fay was amazing!!!!

I have never worked with a realtor that was so knowledgeable about the area and available to answer all my questions. Elise found exactly what I was looking for in the price range that I was happy to find. Her patience and professional handling of my purchase made the process effortless. I want to thank you Elise for all your help and hard work.

Buyer review
Highly Recommend!
6 months ago
Highly Recommend!

Working with Elise was an exceptional experience from start to finish. Instead of keeping us narrowly focused, she helped us explore a range of possibilities and find the home that truly fit our needs. Being from out of state, we relied on her heavily—she toured open houses and showings for us, provided honest insights, and made sure we always felt informed and confident in our decisions. Elise is knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely invested in her clients’ success. Even after closing, she connected us with wonderful local resources and continues to be a trusted support. We couldn’t be happier with our Moon Valley home and highly recommend Elise to anyone looking for a dedicated, thoughtful realtor.

Seller review
Excellent experience
6 months ago
Excellent experience

Always a good outcome with Elise. Have used her many times to either buy or sell. The last sale was on the market one day. Excellent pictures and description of property on listing info. Knowledgeable about the market. Knows how to negotiate for either a seller or buyer. She is the only person I would trust with my sale or purchase.

Seller review
Fast & Expedient My House Was Sold
7 months ago
Fast & Expedient My House Was Sold

Elise sold my house faster than I thought, and for a good price even in this present market. I had previously tried with another agent who promised me the moon in 72 hours but it seemed the house was just stagnating on the market. Elise analyzed the market and the area. She shared her knowledge and how we could best approach the sale of my home at a fair price. She helped me get ready for showings and kept me updated the entire time, which made the entire process less stressful than I expected. We then had an offer that we both reviewed, discussed and arrived at a solution. Once the offer was accepted Elise navigated the sale through the closing and tended to every details. You want a professional in the Real Estate market, hire Elise for her outstanding work and may I also say, her charm.

Buyer review
From Start to Finish Elise will be there for you
7 months ago
From Start to Finish Elise will be there for you

Working with Elise was an absolute pleasure! Her knowledgeable agent insights into the real estate market gave me confidence to purchase my new home. Elise went above and beyond, making the real estate process smooth and stress-free. She moves fast and won't be afraid to share her insights and guide you along the way. She was there for me and rescued me up to the very end. If you’re looking for a phenomenal agent who understands every aspect of the local market, I highly recommend Elise.

Buyer review
Elise Is A Top Notch Agent
9 months ago
Elise Is A Top Notch Agent

I can’t recommend Elise Fay enough! My daughter recently purchased her first home, and I honestly don’t know what we would’ve done without Elise. From the very beginning, Elise was incredibly professional, responsive, and genuinely cared about finding the perfect home for her. What really stood out, though, was her ability to negotiate. The market was competitive, and we were up against multiple offers. Elise was strategic and thoughtful, ensuring we were putting our best foot forward while also protecting my daughter’s best interests. She didn’t just push for any deal—she worked tirelessly to find creative solutions that made the process smooth, even when challenges came up. Whether it was navigating complex contract terms, getting the seller to make necessary repairs, or providing expert advice during inspections, Elise had everything covered. Her attention to detail and commitment to ensuring the entire experience was positive gave us peace of mind at every step. As a broker in another state myself, I am very selective and demanding about other agents I work with - especially when they are representing my daughter. But Elise is truly top notch and had everything covered. If you're looking for someone who will go above and beyond for you, Elise Fay is the one. My daughter is now in her dream home, and we owe that to Elise’s expertise and dedication!

Seller review
Great Experience
9 months ago
Great Experience

Always a pleasure to do business with

Seller review
Elise was very professional and wonderful to work with!
10 months ago
Elise was very professional and wonderful to work with!

Elise was on top of our sale from the start. She provided insight and support throughout the process. She was always available for questions and provided resolutions. Elise is a straight shooter and is open and honest. I would recommend her to anyone looking for a hassle free agent who has your back. Thanks Elise.

Buyer review
Fun experience
10 months ago
Fun experience

I had the absolute pleasure of working with Elise, and I cannot recommend her enough. From our very first meeting, She was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in helping me find the perfect home. She was always responsive, patient with my questions, and offered expert guidance every step of the way. What impressed me most was how well they understood my needs and preferences—they truly listened. They went above and beyond to schedule viewings, negotiate on my behalf, and make the entire process smooth and stress-free.

Seller review
If you are looking to sell your house quickly and for top dollar, Elise is your "Must Have" agent!
10 months ago
If you are looking to sell your house quickly and for top dollar, Elise is your "Must Have" agent!

Elise is very knowledgeable about current market trends and knew how to get the most money in a very short amount of time. She listened to all my wants and wishes and worked within my rather short timeline to put together a phenomenal deal, especially given the current market. She is extremely professional with just the right amount of feistiness when called for. Elise is the agent you want on your side for sure!!

Seller review
Minimized the stress of selling from out of state
11 months ago
Minimized the stress of selling from out of state

Elise helped us navigate the sale of our Phoenix home from out of state, which involved a lot of moving parts. She took on the coordination of everything—painting, repairs, carpet—using her own network, which was a huge relief and made a stressful process much more manageable. That level of hands-on help is something we truly valued and honestly wish we had access to in Denver now!

13 - 24 of 343
© 2026 RateMyAgent