Elise's profile

Elise's reviews

  5  
Elise has 352 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Elise's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, supportive, detail-oriented, great negotiation, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Elise is a great communicator!
5 months ago
Elise is a great communicator!

We worked with Elise for both the purchase and subsequent sale of our Peoria home. She is highly effective at meeting deadlines and successfully navigated a very difficult, slow market to get our property closed on our required timeline. In addition, we found Elise's recommendations for professional services such as painting, plumbing and handy work top tier. We're no fans of the buying or selling process which had several plot twists, but glad we had Elise to help us navigate.

Seller review
Elise has a great deal of experience and knowledge.
5 months ago
Elise has a great deal of experience and knowledge.

Elise was our agent when we purchased our townhome in 2020. We turned to her when we needed to sell. With 3 other townhomes in the community for sale, it was a little challenging, but Elise made sure the job of selling our townhouse got done! She makes the process of buying and/or selling property so easy. Thank you so much Elise!

Seller review
Another Great Experience
5 months ago
Another Great Experience

We are return clients to Elise Fay. We knew exactly who to call when we were considering selling our home. Her knowledge and years of experience really show when it’s time to prep and price a property. Elise is instrumental in her communication and negotiation skills. She works very hard for her clients every day of the week. We credit her for a successful sale in a very short time on the market. We have and will continue to recommend Elise to our family and friends.

Seller review
The Mary Poppins of Real Estate
5 months ago
The Mary Poppins of Real Estate

What doesnt she have in her bag? Elise was more than an agent as she guided my sisters and I through a difficult season, the sale of our late father's home. She was a great listener as she learned about our situation and what we needed from her during this season. Each of us were in three different states in three different time zones, working with three different personalities but Elise was clearly there to work for US. And she worked! She helped us with her trusted list of businesses, contacts, and people, to get the house ready to list. She must never put her phone down because I've never worked with an agent as responsive as Elise. She knows her business, this city, and the market. Clear and timely, while also patient and understanding. Elise has the EXPERIENCE and the WISDOM to get you through unique situations. We were so blessed to find her!

Seller review
Excellent experienced agent
5 months ago
Excellent experienced agent

Elise was a pleasure to work with. She was quick to communicate with us and answered any questions we had. Elise has a down to earth personality and was easy to talk to and relate with. She got our house sold....at the end of the day that's the most important attribute. Thank-you Elise.

Buyer review
Pleasure to work with
7 months ago
Pleasure to work with

We are return customers with Elise Fay. Her market knowledge and customer service goes above and beyond! It has been our pleasure to have Elise represent us again in the purchase of a new home. We can always depend on her expertise and guidance. She has excellent communication skills and negotiation power. We really appreciate Elise and the job she does.

Seller review
EFFICIENT AND SWIFT
7 months ago
EFFICIENT AND SWIFT

Elise was very knowledgeable on all aspects of selling my home. She was super helpful in getting the house ready for sale. Staged the house nicely. Communication was great! Definitely would recommend Elise!

Buyer review
Elise is incredibly knowledgable, understanding and she gets things done!
8 months ago
Elise is incredibly knowledgable, understanding and she gets things done!

Elise has helped me and my family purchased and sell multiple homes. She has carefully walked us through the process and my belief is she is more knowledgable and understanding than any other agent I've ever come across. She doesn't miss any details and she's incredibly good at negotiations and managing clients through the sales process. We just purchased a beautiful home in Desert Hills and we're preparing to sell a nice one in Peoria and I know that she is going to help us every step of the way.

Buyer review
Elise is absolutely fantastic to work with!
8 months ago
Elise is absolutely fantastic to work with!

Elise was fantastic! From start to finish, she was very easy and wonderful to work with. She was very knowledgeable and never left anything unanswered or confusing. For first time home buyers, she could not have been better to work with. She made a stressful process easy and exciting!

Seller review
Smooth Sailing All The Way
9 months ago
Smooth Sailing All The Way

The entire experience with Elise on the sale of our home was 1st rate. She was extremely knowledgeable of the Westbrook area which insured we got top price for our home. She pointed out key areas to invest $$$ that would maximize the home's value as well as providing excellent contractor references to get the work done. Elise was especially helpful during the inspection phase where lots of deals hit snags. She was a prompt communicator when issues came up and was also quick to offer potential solutions to keep things moving forward. Our close went seamlessly based on her jumping in using her industry knowledge to follow up with all the key players involved throughout the process. You cannot find a more experienced or professional Realtor than Elise.

Buyer review
My experience with Elise Fay was amazing!!!!
9 months ago
My experience with Elise Fay was amazing!!!!

I have never worked with a realtor that was so knowledgeable about the area and available to answer all my questions. Elise found exactly what I was looking for in the price range that I was happy to find. Her patience and professional handling of my purchase made the process effortless. I want to thank you Elise for all your help and hard work.

Buyer review
Highly Recommend!
9 months ago
Highly Recommend!

Working with Elise was an exceptional experience from start to finish. Instead of keeping us narrowly focused, she helped us explore a range of possibilities and find the home that truly fit our needs. Being from out of state, we relied on her heavily—she toured open houses and showings for us, provided honest insights, and made sure we always felt informed and confident in our decisions. Elise is knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely invested in her clients’ success. Even after closing, she connected us with wonderful local resources and continues to be a trusted support. We couldn’t be happier with our Moon Valley home and highly recommend Elise to anyone looking for a dedicated, thoughtful realtor.

13 - 24 of 352
© 2026 RateMyAgent