Elise's profile

Elise's reviews

  5  
Elise has 352 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Elise's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, supportive, detail-oriented, great negotiation, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
List your home with Elise
over 1 year ago
List your home with Elise

Selling a home in todays market is not easy. Don't tell that to Elise Fay. She made the process stress free, handled everything and sold our home in no time. Her ability to communicate with us made every hurdle painless and manageable. Combine that with her negotiating ability and professionalism, Elise gave us peace of mind and ultimately more money for our home. Thank you Elise. You're truly the best.

Seller review
Recommended Agent
over 1 year ago
Recommended Agent

Elise is awesome. That's all there really is to say.

Seller review
Review Headline: Exceptional, Compassionate, and Professional Service
over 1 year ago
Review Headline: Exceptional, Compassionate, and Professional Service

Working with Elise Fay has been a truly remarkable experience. Despite the distance, as she is based in Arizona and we are in Ohio, Elise seamlessly managed the entire process of selling our property. Her punctuality, attention to detail, and proactive communication ensured we were always in the loop, making us feel included and informed at every stage. Elise went above and beyond, not only keeping us updated but also including us in critical homeowner discussions, making this a truly collaborative effort. Her compassion and genuine passion for her work are evident in every interaction. She treats her clients like family, ensuring they fully understand the process and feel confident in every decision. Recommended to us by Marcus Muhammad, a trusted realtor in Ohio, Elise exceeded all expectations, providing exceptional guidance and support from start to finish. If you are looking for a dedicated, thorough, and genuinely caring real estate professional, look no further than Elise Fay. Thank you, Elise, for making this experience smooth and stress-free.

Buyer review
Highly recommend Elise
over 1 year ago
Highly recommend Elise

Elise took the time to understand our needs and preferences, making us feel like more than just prospective buyers. Her personalized approach and commitment to our best interests ensured we found the perfect home. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience!

Seller review
Excellent Service on Peoria, AZ Home Sale
over 1 year ago
Excellent Service on Peoria, AZ Home Sale

Ms. Fay was exceptional on same if our lease home to existing tenant. She assisted us in presale repair options, tenant handholding, and final closing documentation. As we live in NY, we could not ask for a better local agent. Highly recommended. Thank you Elise!

Seller review
Elise Fay is superb.
over 1 year ago
Elise Fay is superb.

I highly recommend Elise! She is a true expert in the field and was incredibly helpful in finding the perfect home for my family. She was attentive to our needs and preferences and helped us secure a great deal. Her dedication and hard work truly paid off.

Buyer review
Great Experience
over 1 year ago
Great Experience

Elise is a professional realtor, highly experience in this field along with a wonderful personality. Elise responds to emails, texts and phone calls immediately. Always listened to what I needed. Elise will provide you her advice when needed and welling to help in any way to make you happy with final decision. I was lucky to have Elise as my realtor.

Seller review
Speedy Home Selling Process During a Stressful Time
over 1 year ago
Speedy Home Selling Process During a Stressful Time

Elise did a phenomenal job helping me sell my late father's home. She had a wealth of resources that helped us decide if it would be worth it or not to do any remodeling to the home before putting it on the market. Elise also had many contacts that she reached out to regarding the purchase of property, which helped us get an even better deal for the home. All of my family was happy with both the price of the sale as well as the speed of it. I would highly recommend her to anyone in my situation in the future.

Seller review
#TeamElise
over 1 year ago
#TeamElise

We have now partnered with Elise for 4 transactions now. She recently helped us purchase our dream home & sell our other home in a challenging market. We followed her staging team’s advice to get our home staged for a quick sale & got it sold in less than 30 days. Elise is both professional & personable. We highly recommend her!!

Seller review
Elise Fay with eXp Realty is an amazing realtor - so happy to have found her!
over 1 year ago
Elise Fay with eXp Realty is an amazing realtor - so happy to have found her!

Elise asks a lot of questions to find out what you are all about - she gets to know you and what you need, and gives great advice on what you need to do - that is why she is so successful. She acted as the buyer's agent on my current house and selling agent for my house I just sold. It is obvious after only a couple of minutes meeting with her, that she has a ton of experience in the business as well as dealing with people of all types. I now consider her a friend. I could not have gone through this wtihout her as I was working full time through both transactions. (I also know about the business as my mother was a realtor most of her life - so I have some experience in making a rating. Elise has a lot of connections in every phase of buying and selling your home. builders, electricians, plumbers, landscapers, bankers, and just everything to do with a home - she has a connection for it. She was there for my septic inspection on the home I sold, home inspection for the home I purchased. Countless times she reminded me when there were documents waiting to be signed. She worked with the title company on my behalf when I was too busy at work to make phone calls. I seriously could not have this without her. If you need a realtor, who has years of experience, is incredibly nice and fun to work with, call Elise. It was honestly the smoothest experience I have ever had in dealing with property and I have owned many in several states - Debbie Downing

Buyer review
Second time hiring, we love her!
over 1 year ago
Second time hiring, we love her!

Elise was very thorough and helpful through the whole process with buying my home so I wanted to use her as my realtor when I needed help buying an income rental property. I just love Elise and can’t say enough good things about her. She is always easy to get a hold of through text or phone call, which is how I usually prefer to communicate. She is thorough and had questions in the purchase process that I hadn’t thought of to ask and helped me get all the answers I needed. She makes things happen quickly and smoothly and makes herself available right away every step of the way. Working with her feels like working with a trusted friend. I have used several vendors she’s recommended as well and was very happy with all of them. She just goes above and beyond, for example, she made a point to get my house re-inspected for termites with a better company and I didn’t have to lift a finger when the company my home had a termite warranty with just wasn’t cutting it after a treatment. She really cares that you are happy with everything and she cares about making sure every single thing is taken care of properly, and in a timely manner; and she is very personable while she does it!

Seller review
Quick and Easy Experience
over 1 year ago
Quick and Easy Experience

Working with Elise was a seamless experience. Elise was able to get us a solid price for our home very quickly in a slow market.

37 - 48 of 352
© 2026 RateMyAgent