CAROL's profile

CAROL's reviews

  5  
CAROL has 144 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
CAROL's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, great negotiation, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
I have been in the real estate appraisal business for over 40 years
over 4 years ago
I have been in the real estate appraisal business for over 40 years

I have been in the real estate appraisal business for over 40 years. As expected I have had dealings with all types of people. Carol Menz is a true professional in every sense and is highly recommended for all of your real estate needs.

Seller review
When we were ready to put our shore house up for sale
over 4 years ago
When we were ready to put our shore house up for sale

When we were ready to put our shore house up for sale. We knew that a local broker who knew the area and had name recognition were imperative attributes. We did our research and the name of Carol Menz continued to surface to the top of the list. She is a Platinum Broker in Cape May County and has been for a number of years. When we made the call, Carol actually picked up the phone. We had a discussion about our desires and wishes regarding the property. Carol came prepared with current comps, recent sales and the current activity in the area. Carol gave us sound advice and counsel from the time we signed the agreement of sale to the day we settled on the property. We never experienced a disconcerting moment or feeling. Carol is the real deal. She always listened and gave back constructive clarity when needed. We have no qualms or reservations recommending Carol Menz at Coastline Realty. If you are buying or selling in Cape May do yourself a favor and reach out to her. You will not be disappointed.

Seller review
It was/is an amazing experience to work with Carol and her team at Coastline Realtors
over 4 years ago
It was/is an amazing experience to work with Carol and her team at Coastline Realtors

It was/is an amazing experience to work with Carol and her team at Coastline Realtors. We never had a disconcerting feeling or moment from the time we signed the agreement of sale to the settlement. Carol was there every day advising and counseling, as we moved forward with our sale. Carol was the person we dealt with always, not someone on her team. She was on top of everything and had the answers. Carol is like the Energizer Bunny, always available, knows the details of what is going on, and is professional and courteous in her demeanor and delivery. When we decided to sell. We wanted to have someone who knew the Cape May area. When we did our research for a broker Carol's name continued to come up. She is a Platinum Broker, most of the realtors on her team are Gold, Silver or Bronze, that's impressive. We have bought and sold seven homes in our 57 years of marriage. We have bought and sold homes in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Virginia. We have dealt with a number of brokers in our excursion of home ownership this by far was the most restful and efficient. From the day we first met Carol to the day we made settlement we knew we were in good hands we never had any anxiety or uneasiness. We have no qualms or reservations about recommending Carol Menz for your sale or purchase. I am just thinking about this as we write this endorsement, and we are not being compensated for this....."If you want the Best get Carol Mentz".

Seller review
I owned a property that was very challenging to sell
over 4 years ago
I owned a property that was very challenging to sell

I owned a property that was very challenging to sell. It was a low value condominium and I struggled with it for years. Carol stepped in and made me feel like I was listing a million dollar home even though it was a tenth of that. She and her team worked tirelessly to get the deal done and made it happen. Her expertise and drive are definitely 5 star quality. I will definitely trust her with my future real estate deals. I can’t say enough about how impressed I am with the service I received from Carol and I 100% recommend her!

Seller review
LOVE, love Carol and her team
over 4 years ago
LOVE, love Carol and her team

LOVE, love Carol and her team. Not only was this was our first time purchasing a home but it was an important purchase in that it was an ideal property for our future home/business plans. Add to that, timeliness was a big factor as our business was contingent on closing as soon as possible. WOW ... Carol was on top of the deal, was always available 24/7 (even on her vacation!), no detail was too small for her to follow up on AND she did double duty as the seller did not use an agent to assist with his portion of the sale. I still am amazed at how she remembered every little detail that needed to be done or that the seller needed to do for the sale to go through. We know Carol deals with multi million dollar properties and ours was nothing close to those prices but we were treated as if we were and like we were her only clients.

Seller review
This is house number THREE with Carol, and if there are anymore in my future I'll have her right by
over 4 years ago
This is house number THREE with Carol, and if there are anymore in my future I'll have her right by

This is house number THREE with Carol, and if there are anymore in my future I'll have her right by my side. She's that good! Due to the seller's market we're in, we had to look at many homes until I was able to get the latest, and Carol had no issues with the leg work. We went through multiple home negotiations and she knew exactly what to do in every situation that came up. I can't say enough good things about her. If your buying or selling a home, you need to use Carol, period.

Buyer review
Best real estate agent ever!!!
over 4 years ago
Best real estate agent ever!!!

Having Carol as your buying agent is the best decision you can make regarding buying a home. This is the second home that Carol was my buying agent for and the second time she represented my interests and performed flawlessly. From finding the home until the keys were in my hand, Carol took care of every aspect of the buying experience. She fought for my wants and needs and made sure I was kept in loop every step of the way. I can not emphasize enough what a great real estate agent Carol is

Seller review
Carol Menz was an excellent agent for us and the process was not easy in the current market
almost 5 years ago
Carol Menz was an excellent agent for us and the process was not easy in the current market

Carol Menz was an excellent agent for us and the process was not easy in the current market. She made sure she had our best interests in mind every step of the way. She is very knowledgeable of the area and was able to guide us every step of the way. We would recommend Carol and would use her time and time again when purchasing or selling a home.

Buyer review
Carol is an exceptional real estate professional.
almost 5 years ago
Carol is an exceptional real estate professional.

I’ve had the pleasure of working with Carol on two transactions, and both have been exceptional experiences. She knows the market. She is quick to respond. She is a true real estate professional. I highly recommend Carol.

85 - 96 of 144
© 2026 RateMyAgent