CAROL's profile

CAROL's reviews

  5  
CAROL has 146 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
CAROL's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, great negotiation, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Carol Menz is the Best!!!  I was very fortunate to have Carol as  my realtor
about 5 years ago
Carol Menz is the Best!!! I was very fortunate to have Carol as my realtor

Carol Menz is the Best!!! I was very fortunate to have Carol as my realtor. It took a very long time for me to find the place I wanted to call home but Carol never lost her enthusiasm in continuing to work with me. She was honest, always had my best interest at heart, available to answer all of my questions and concerns even while she was on vacation. She said her door was always open and I believe her, settlement is over and she continues to be helpful. Carol Menz is the cream of the crop. I highly recommend her to everyone.

Buyer review
Carol was e a tremendous resource for us when purchasing a home earlier this year
over 5 years ago
Carol was e a tremendous resource for us when purchasing a home earlier this year

Carol was e a tremendous resource for us when purchasing a home earlier this year. Carol is truly top-notch and lives up to her reputation! She is super knowledgeable on the broad Cape May area and her expertise was a true asset to use successfully purchasing a home. With such a challenging market and covid restrictions we were successful in finding a home that perfectly suited our needs. Carol went above and beyond our expectations every step of the process! We also are super appreciate of the broader Coastline team, Rebecca, Cody, Kim, and others that helped show us homes and counsel us on our options. They were familiar with our needs and pitched in with the fast paced market . We are so thankful for all of your support and would highly recommend Coastline!

Seller review
Carol is a top- notch agent who knows her business
over 5 years ago
Carol is a top- notch agent who knows her business

Carol is a top- notch agent who knows her business. She has expertise in every aspect of the real estate business, and it shows when you’re buying or selling your home. Carol walked through every step of the process with us in selling our high end home in Cape May, during the pandemic. We were thrilled with her performance, advice and the ultimate outcome.

Seller review
We just closed on our second home in the Cape May County area with Carol as our agent
over 5 years ago
We just closed on our second home in the Cape May County area with Carol as our agent

We just closed on our second home in the Cape May County area with Carol as our agent. She is efficient, fair, and extremely knowledgeable about the area. We have also recommended Carol to many of our family and friends who have also used Carol's real estate expertise. Finally, there is no resource that she does not have to share with a home buyer. I highly recommend Carol and her team!

Seller review
This the 2nd time in 2 years that Carol sold a property for us
over 5 years ago
This the 2nd time in 2 years that Carol sold a property for us

This the 2nd time in 2 years that Carol sold a property for us. Giving another well deserved review. Carol is truly an expert in her field. Her understanding of the Cape May market along with her drive to succeed makes her an outstanding Realtor. All questions and concerns are addressed immediately. Carol is a true professional and I would definitely recommend Carol.

Buyer review
Carol Menz is THE agent in Cape May! Her knowledge of the area is incomparable
over 5 years ago
Carol Menz is THE agent in Cape May! Her knowledge of the area is incomparable

Carol Menz is THE agent in Cape May! Her knowledge of the area is incomparable. We were constantly amazed at how much she knew about real estate in Cape May. During the extremely competitive market of the pandemic, Carol was an incredible guide in navigating us to our lovely new home! We couldn’t have done it without her!

Buyer review
During our search for a home in the Cape May area it seemed that as soon as a home we liked came on
over 5 years ago
During our search for a home in the Cape May area it seemed that as soon as a home we liked came on

During our search for a home in the Cape May area it seemed that as soon as a home we liked came on the market it was sold before we had the opportunity to view it. In what could have been a very disheartening experience, Carol was always there to keep our spirits up and always able to show us homes we never even knew were on the market. She got to know my wife and I very well and in the process knew exactly what we wanted, and even more importantly, what we didn't want. That enabled us to look at homes that were only what we needed which saved us a lot of time. Carol was always asking s questions as we toured a home. Is this what you really want? Did you see this? Are you certain about this? That was extremely REFRESHING to know that a realtor was seriously interested in you and not to just make a sale. I very, very highly recommend Carol to any prospective home buyer in the Cape May NJ area. She is simply the BEST!

Seller review
Carol went beyond expectations to support the listing and sale of our home
over 5 years ago
Carol went beyond expectations to support the listing and sale of our home

Carol went beyond expectations to support the listing and sale of our home. She found ways to make the process as easy as possible for us. Since this was a second home there were times we could not make it to an appointment with a contractor and she stepped in to meet them at our house on our behalf.

Seller review
Having Carol as your buying agent is the best decision you can make regarding buying a home
over 5 years ago
Having Carol as your buying agent is the best decision you can make regarding buying a home

Having Carol as your buying agent is the best decision you can make regarding buying a home. This is the second home that that Carol was my buying agent for and the second time she represented my interests and performed flawlessly. From finding the home until the keys were in my hand, Carol took care of every aspect of the buying experience. She fought for my wants and needs and made sure I was kept in loop every step of the way. I can not emphasize enough what a great real estate agent Carol is.

Seller review
Carol made selling our condo easier than we could have ever expected
over 5 years ago
Carol made selling our condo easier than we could have ever expected

Carol made selling our condo easier than we could have ever expected. She staged, listed and sold our property in two months ...over the winter holiday season during a pandemic no less! We do not live in NJ, so it was very important to have a good working relationship with our agent from a far. From our first phone call to the closing, Carol was always available and took care of everything in an extremely responsive and efficient manner. She's really a master at real estate transactions. We highly recommend!!!

109 - 120 of 146
© 2026 RateMyAgent