CAROL's profile

CAROL's reviews

  5  
CAROL has 146 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
CAROL's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, great negotiation, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Amazing realtor!!
28 days ago
Amazing realtor!!

Carol Menz is amazing. She is extremely knowledgeable and was always available for questions and showings. She was very responsive and efficient in helping to sell our house in short period of time in Rio Grande. If you want the best, get Carol Menz. She is the best.

Seller review
Stellar!
28 days ago
Stellar!

We can't say enough about Carol Menz! We knew that when it came to selling our home that there was no other alternative. We have used Carol over the last 15 plus years to buy and sell many times. Extremely professional yet personable. She will guide you on what to do to sell your home so you get the most return. She also has brought only serious buyers. Through the years we have learned to make your home look like a model home when selling. Carol's influence was key. Stellar says it all. Don't waste another moment. When it comes to a transaction as large as buying or selling your home, Carol is the one to choose. She will strive to get you the most for your home and negotiate in your best interest when buying.

Seller review
The Gold Standard in Cape May
4 months ago
The Gold Standard in Cape May

This was our second time working with Carol Menz and her team, and we wouldn't even consider calling anyone else in Cape May. They have a way of making what should be a stressful process feel effortless. We always knew they were one step ahead, taking care of the details before we even had to think about them. What really keeps us coming back isn't just their knowledge of the market, it's the way they treat people. By the end of the process, you feel like you've gained friends who genuinely care about finding the right home for you. Carol and her team are in a different league. If you're buying or selling in Cape May--call them first!

Seller review
Caring quick, and efficient- that's Carol
5 months ago
Caring quick, and efficient- that's Carol

Living out of state, Carol did a remarkable job in selling my home in a timely manner. She handled all the necessary work to make the sale as stressless as possible. I thank her for her help throughout the whole process.

Seller review
Carol is excellent
5 months ago
Carol is excellent

Carol is very professional, friendly and knowledgeable. She was always ready to answer all our questions and addressed our needs. She put our house on the market, in three days our house was sold. She walked us through the closing and went beyond to help us after the house was closed. We were so impressed with her that we recommended her to my sister to be her agent.

Seller review
She was excellent!
5 months ago
She was excellent!

From the first minute I met Carol, I knew she would get my house sold quick. Her expertise and years of knowledge really impressed me! My Cape May house was very special to me and Carol understood that. Carol and her marketing team had the house well advertised on all platforms. Which then lead to many showings and multiple offers. I would highly recommend Carol for selling or buying, she was wonderful!

Seller review
Knowledgeable, Informative, and Enthusiastic
5 months ago
Knowledgeable, Informative, and Enthusiastic

Carol shared her vision of the marketplace, sales strategies, and sales plan the first time we met her. Carol listed the home on a Thursday and we had an agreement on Sunday! Her professional guidance led us through the entire process seamlessly. I have no hesitation in recommending her and Coastline.

Buyer review
Excellent communicator very detail oriented and organized highly responsive
5 months ago
Excellent communicator very detail oriented and organized highly responsive

We were out of state buyers and Carol made the experience seamless. Her knowledge of the area, excellent communication skills, and overall patience with our numerous questions put us at ease. We felt comfortable having Carol be our “eyes” in Cape May while we were living in Pennsylvania.

Buyer review
Highly recommend Carol Menz in Cape May, NJ
9 months ago
Highly recommend Carol Menz in Cape May, NJ

We feel so lucky that we found Carol to help with our home purchase in the Villas! We visited the area on a whim for the first time for a long holiday weekend and fell in love. Carol was able to meet us while we were there to look around at what was available. She kept us updated on properties that fit what we were looking for. She was flexible with my crazy work schedule to meet us for showings. She was so quick when we were ready to put in an offer. She gave very grounded advice when our initial offers fell through. She guided us through every step of the buying process. Even the folks she referred us to for various things (inspections, loan advisors, etc) were wonderfully professional and helpful. She really is the best of the best. Whether you are buying for a primary residence or looking for a rental property, she gave us wonderful advice and things to think about every step of the way. She even made a recommendation during one of our walk throughs to have the builder add in an outdoor shower- we never would have thought of this! Even after we have closed- Carol continues to help us navigate the outstanding items on our build. Truly don’t know how we would do this without her. Responsive, professional, efficient, knowledgeable and also a really cool person that was so easy to work with and talk to- would highly recommend.

Seller review
On top of it all all the time,
10 months ago
On top of it all all the time,

From the beginning to the end Carol excelled at her knowledge of the market, addressing head on any issues that needed to be attention and always keeping things at the professional level.

1 - 12 of 146
© 2026 RateMyAgent