CAROL's profile

CAROL's reviews

  5  
CAROL has 142 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
CAROL's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, great negotiation, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
If you’re buying or selling in southern NJ, you need to call Carol Menz
over 2 years ago
If you’re buying or selling in southern NJ, you need to call Carol Menz

If you’re buying or selling in southern NJ, you need to call Carol Menz. She knows the market and everyone knows her! We weren’t planning on selling for a few years, but decided to interview a few agents. We knew immediately she was the one for us. That was last year. This year, she told us is the year to sell - she is aware of the big picture and how things are likely to change. We listened and our house sold within 2 weeks. Selling it much more complicated than it was 2 decades ago - so many rules and regulations. We needed help for sure with all of this. We didn’t need help with staging, but she did have helpful comments about things we should change out or remove - with the buyers in mind. All good comments. She also understands what value is being sold (emphasizing things like location and setting over house if it is being missed by potential buyers.) She listened to us and also listens to them and has good answers or gets them. She is always available by phone or text to answer the multitude of questions that came up. We felt protected by her professionalism and knowledge. We found her to be amazing.

Seller review
Carol Menz, Broker at Coastline Realty, has been an exception agent for me on both the selling and b
over 2 years ago
Carol Menz, Broker at Coastline Realty, has been an exception agent for me on both the selling and b

Carol Menz, Broker at Coastline Realty, has been an exception agent for me on both the selling and buying sides! Our relationship started many years ago when she sold my parents’ home in Cape May. When I was ready to purchase my own house, I went to Carol. She showed me the ones I selected but had the insight of my tastes and low and behold showed me a random condo that I fell in love with! She provided advice on the bidding price of which the sellers accepted. Now, 6 years later, I needed more room due to my growing family. Once again I went to Carol. Carol found us a larger home and was able to sell my condominium within 2 weeks! Settlement on both houses was within a month from agreement to settlement! I can’t thank Carol enough for her expertise in the real estate market and getting all the documentation and inspections completed within 30 days! If you are looking to buy or sell your house, Carol is the agent you want to connect with! Thank you Carol for your dedication and hard work as a realtor!

Buyer review
Carol Menz, Broker at Coastline Realty, has been an exception agent for me on both the selling and b
over 2 years ago
Carol Menz, Broker at Coastline Realty, has been an exception agent for me on both the selling and b

Carol Menz, Broker at Coastline Realty, has been an exception agent for me on both the selling and buying sides! Our relationship started many years ago when she sold my parents’ home in Cape May. When I was ready to purchase my own house, I went to Carol. She showed me the ones I selected but had the insight of my tastes and low and behold showed me a random condo that I fell in love with! She provided advice on the bidding price of which the sellers accepted. Now, 6 years later, I needed more room due to my growing family. Once again I went to Carol. Carol found us a larger home and was able to sell my condominium within 2 weeks! Settlement on both houses was within a month from agreement to settlement! I can’t thank Carol enough for her expertise in the real estate market and getting all the documentation and inspections completed within 30 days! If you are looking to buy or sell your house, Carol is the agent you want to connect with! Thank you Carol for your dedication and hard work as a realtor!

Buyer review
Repeat client
almost 3 years ago
Repeat client

Coastline Realty, with Carol and Ami Menz, make your listing, search, transactions easy. We have used them to buy and sell, and will happily call them in for any future real estate needs we may have.

Buyer review
I was so impressed with how much Carol knew about construction when we toured houses, especially tho
almost 3 years ago
I was so impressed with how much Carol knew about construction when we toured houses, especially tho

I was so impressed with how much Carol knew about construction when we toured houses, especially those with custom additions. When we found our house, it already had one offer in and an open house about to happen, and we were not yet pre-approved for a mortgage. She helped us to negotiate against multiple other offers while advising us on what she believed our house was likely to appraise for and connected us to a lender who got us the very tight closing date we needed before an upcoming trip away from internet access. We always felt confident with her, and I'd recommend her to anyone home-searching in the area.

Buyer review
I was so impressed with how much Carol knew about construction when we toured houses, especially tho
almost 3 years ago
I was so impressed with how much Carol knew about construction when we toured houses, especially tho

I was so impressed with how much Carol knew about construction when we toured houses, especially those with custom additions. When we found our house, it already had one offer in and an open house about to happen, and we were not yet pre-approved for a mortgage. She helped us to negotiate against multiple other offers while advising us on what she believed our house was likely to appraise for and connected us to a lender who got us the very tight closing date we needed before an upcoming trip away from internet access.We always felt confident with her, and I'd recommend her to anyone home-searching in the area.

Buyer review
I highly recommend Carol if you are looking to sell or buy in the Cape May area! She has years of ex
almost 3 years ago
I highly recommend Carol if you are looking to sell or buy in the Cape May area! She has years of ex

I highly recommend Carol if you are looking to sell or buy in the Cape May area! She has years of experience, local knowledge and was super responsive. Her listing was clear, she took the time to answer all my questions, connected me with people in the condo building and local professionals, all of whom helped make the sale move forward seamlessly. Thank you, Carol!

Seller review
Best agent in Cape May
almost 3 years ago
Best agent in Cape May

Carol Menz is a very knowledgeable and professional real estate agent. We have used her service for the purchase and sale of several homes and wouldn't dream of using any other agency. Her entire staff is helpful and they get the job done. Also a great rental agent. Thanks Carol.

Seller review
Carol is, without a doubt, the absolute BEST in the business
almost 3 years ago
Carol is, without a doubt, the absolute BEST in the business

Carol is, without a doubt, the absolute BEST in the business. We used Carol twice on the sell side and once on the buy side and in each instance, she delivered amazing results. She is very responsive, detail oriented, and makes what can be a difficult and challenging process easy. Carol has all the local connections and every question you have will get answered and any issue that surfaces gets quickly resolved. Most importantly, Carol’s insight into and experience with coastal market trends are unmatched, and nobody will work harder to satisfy your real estate needs! If you want to work with an expert, call Carol and the Coastline Realty team!!

Buyer review
Carol was wonderful to work with
about 3 years ago
Carol was wonderful to work with

Carol was wonderful to work with. In the past my parents house was for sale and sat on the market for awhile. Within two months of Carol taking the listing the house was under agreement and sold. As I looked for an investment property off shore Carol continued to send real estate listings for more then a year and a half before we located the right property. Once the property was under agreement, Carol provided a check off list with dates on items that needed to be done to get us to settlement. The list proved to be very helpful. Carol has excellent knowledge of the real estate market in Cape May County and was a pleasure to deal with. Thank you for your expertise.

49 - 60 of 142
© 2026 RateMyAgent