CAROL's profile

CAROL's reviews

  5  
CAROL has 146 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
CAROL's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, great negotiation, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Amazing Realtor!!!!!!
over 2 years ago
Amazing Realtor!!!!!!

We had the absolute pleasure of working with Carol Menz from Coastline Realty for the purchase of our two homes in Cape May. From the very beginning, Carol impressed us with her deep knowledge of the Cape May real estate market and her unwavering commitment to helping us find the perfect properties. Carol’s professionalism and dedication were evident throughout the entire process. She took the time to understand our needs and preferences, and her expert guidance made navigating the competitive market a breeze. Her attention to detail and proactive approach ensured that every aspect of our transactions was handled smoothly and efficiently. What truly sets Carol apart is her genuine care for her clients. She went above and beyond to address our concerns, provide valuable insights, and make us feel confident in our decisions. Her warm and friendly demeanor made working with her an enjoyable experience, and we always felt like we were in capable hands. Thanks to Carol, we are now proud owners of two beautiful homes in Cape May, and we couldn’t be happier with our purchases. We highly recommend Carol Menz to anyone looking to buy or sell property in the area. She is a true professional and an exceptional real estate agent who truly cares about her clients’ success.

Seller review
Buying Or Selling - Carol Is Your Agent!
over 2 years ago
Buying Or Selling - Carol Is Your Agent!

Tough Market - Not for Carol. My husband and I surprised ourselves with wanting to place our beachfront condo in Wildwood Crest for sale in the middle of January 2024, a year ahead of our "plan". I interviewed four agents and Carol hands down was the best. Why? Her knowledge and experience. We listed after the Superbowl and sold in 30 days. We also liked her organized approach in our preparation to list. That may not seem important, but timing can be everything, especially when you are turning around and purchasing a home 5 states away. Carol is also a broker and the owner of her agency. Carol has over four decades of experience, and she has built an incredible team at Coastline Reality. They are professional, patient and helpful. If Carol is not available, which is rare, one of her team members is quick to assist. Carol also is very well connected in Cape May County, which is instrumental. Carol used all her resources, not just Zillow, to maximize eyes on our home. While interviewing agents, I noticed they were quick to give me a list price. Not Carol. Understanding how fluid the market is showed even more of her talent. Lastly, she communicates well, very personable and genuinely cares. Thank you, Carol. Forever grateful - Jim and Lauren

Seller review
Good Quick Results
over 2 years ago
Good Quick Results

Carol and her team know the market well enough to produce quick efficient results. She worked with me to prepare the house for market which produced a market based sale in record time.

Buyer review
Care Quality Top Notch Experience
over 2 years ago
Care Quality Top Notch Experience

We have been looking for the right home in Cape May for a long time. Carol was there to assist us the entire time. When the right one popped up, she knew it. She walked us through every step of the process, understanding our questions, and showing the care needed answering everything we threw at her. Carol came to be a trusted mentor and we are grateful for her time, experience and efforts. If you need the knowledge, the network of connections, the advice and are looking for a smooth transaction, look no further than Carol.

Buyer review
Exceptional market knowledge and person!
over 2 years ago
Exceptional market knowledge and person!

We first visited Carol 6+ years ago to gather information and learn about the CM real estate market. At that time, she created a personal portal for us, and we were added to her marketing distribution list to keep us informed of local news and trends. Fast forward 6 years when we were finally ready to buy, we reached out to Carol who responded immediately and jumped on a Saturday morning call to get reacquainted and start the process. Upon finding a home, we appreciated her honesty and market insight to help us make an informed decision when placing our offer. And she knows EVERYONE! so we were in good hands from start to finish. We feel fortunate that Carol represented us in the purchase of our new beach house and would highly recommend her to anyone in need of an exceptional realtor in Cape May County.

Buyer review
Hands-down the best!
over 2 years ago
Hands-down the best!

I can't wait to work with Carol again. Carol is the best in the business - she's knowledgeable, prompt, and professional. I value Carol's hardwork and tenacity in the home-buying process. She made a complex situation easy to navigate and always had a patient response for the endless slew of questions that seemed to arise. You're in great hands with Carol! Thank you!

Buyer review
True seasoned professional
over 2 years ago
True seasoned professional

Carol is a true seasoned real estate professional. Her patience, knowledge, experience, and skill enabled us to cross the finish line and finally purchase our first shore home. Based on our experience, we would strongly recommend seeking out Carol’s assistance.

Seller review
Stop Worrying and Use Carol
almost 3 years ago
Stop Worrying and Use Carol

I am a retired Real Estate Agent who knows what an Agent should do for you. Carol did it all. She’s knows her market; pricing, zoning, what sold and why others didn’t sell. She is very upfront with you and tells you what the housing market is and not what you want to hear. I appreciated her honesty and knowledge. If you text her, expect a response. She kept us posted continuously through the transaction. I never needed to ask her what was going on. Just check your email and you will know. Carol saved us $2,000.00 at closing by realizing that we didn’t receive the “senior discount “ on the NJ transfer tax!! So stop worrying and use Carol. She will guide you through the process and you’ll have a good laugh or two along the way. She’s great!

Seller review
Carol knows everything
almost 3 years ago
Carol knows everything

I have done business with Carol for a number of years and she sold numerous properties to buy and sell. She is the best in the business if you don’t believe me just ride around and look at all the Coastline signs. There are twice as many coastline signs in front of homes than any other realtor in this area in this county.

Buyer review
Professional and accommodating!
almost 3 years ago
Professional and accommodating!

Our experience with purchasing a home in Cape May was made incredibly easy because of the professionalism and knowledge of Carol. She has a wonderful personality and is really on the ball. There was never a time that we could not contact her, which eased our minds, in the simple fact that we never felt like we were in the dark with any details pertaining to the purchase of our home. We will be using the services Carol and Coastline Realty again in the near future!

Seller review
Knowledgeable and Experienced
almost 3 years ago
Knowledgeable and Experienced

Carol was chosen to guide us through a difficult journey of selling our parents home. As a life long resident of the area, she has incredible local knowledge of the sales territory and long standing relationships that made the settlement process go as smoothly as possible. Her guidance truly made the preparation, listing and quick sale much easier than expected. Carol and her team get my highest recommendation.

Buyer review
Seamless Experience with Carol!
almost 3 years ago
Seamless Experience with Carol!

I had the pleasure of working with Carol on the purchase of a condo in Cape May. She was super knowledgeable about the area and this particular property, always available to answer questions and help with the closing process - thank you, Carol!

37 - 48 of 146
© 2026 RateMyAgent