CAROL's profile

CAROL's reviews

  5  
CAROL has 142 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
CAROL's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, great negotiation, supportive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Exceptional market knowledge and person!
about 2 years ago
Exceptional market knowledge and person!

We first visited Carol 6+ years ago to gather information and learn about the CM real estate market. At that time, she created a personal portal for us, and we were added to her marketing distribution list to keep us informed of local news and trends. Fast forward 6 years when we were finally ready to buy, we reached out to Carol who responded immediately and jumped on a Saturday morning call to get reacquainted and start the process. Upon finding a home, we appreciated her honesty and market insight to help us make an informed decision when placing our offer. And she knows EVERYONE! so we were in good hands from start to finish. We feel fortunate that Carol represented us in the purchase of our new beach house and would highly recommend her to anyone in need of an exceptional realtor in Cape May County.

Buyer review
Hands-down the best!
about 2 years ago
Hands-down the best!

I can't wait to work with Carol again. Carol is the best in the business - she's knowledgeable, prompt, and professional. I value Carol's hardwork and tenacity in the home-buying process. She made a complex situation easy to navigate and always had a patient response for the endless slew of questions that seemed to arise. You're in great hands with Carol! Thank you!

Buyer review
True seasoned professional
about 2 years ago
True seasoned professional

Carol is a true seasoned real estate professional. Her patience, knowledge, experience, and skill enabled us to cross the finish line and finally purchase our first shore home. Based on our experience, we would strongly recommend seeking out Carol’s assistance.

Seller review
Stop Worrying and Use Carol
over 2 years ago
Stop Worrying and Use Carol

I am a retired Real Estate Agent who knows what an Agent should do for you. Carol did it all. She’s knows her market; pricing, zoning, what sold and why others didn’t sell. She is very upfront with you and tells you what the housing market is and not what you want to hear. I appreciated her honesty and knowledge. If you text her, expect a response. She kept us posted continuously through the transaction. I never needed to ask her what was going on. Just check your email and you will know. Carol saved us $2,000.00 at closing by realizing that we didn’t receive the “senior discount “ on the NJ transfer tax!! So stop worrying and use Carol. She will guide you through the process and you’ll have a good laugh or two along the way. She’s great!

Seller review
Carol knows everything
over 2 years ago
Carol knows everything

I have done business with Carol for a number of years and she sold numerous properties to buy and sell. She is the best in the business if you don’t believe me just ride around and look at all the Coastline signs. There are twice as many coastline signs in front of homes than any other realtor in this area in this county.

Buyer review
Professional and accommodating!
over 2 years ago
Professional and accommodating!

Our experience with purchasing a home in Cape May was made incredibly easy because of the professionalism and knowledge of Carol. She has a wonderful personality and is really on the ball. There was never a time that we could not contact her, which eased our minds, in the simple fact that we never felt like we were in the dark with any details pertaining to the purchase of our home. We will be using the services Carol and Coastline Realty again in the near future!

Seller review
Knowledgeable and Experienced
over 2 years ago
Knowledgeable and Experienced

Carol was chosen to guide us through a difficult journey of selling our parents home. As a life long resident of the area, she has incredible local knowledge of the sales territory and long standing relationships that made the settlement process go as smoothly as possible. Her guidance truly made the preparation, listing and quick sale much easier than expected. Carol and her team get my highest recommendation.

Buyer review
Seamless Experience with Carol!
over 2 years ago
Seamless Experience with Carol!

I had the pleasure of working with Carol on the purchase of a condo in Cape May. She was super knowledgeable about the area and this particular property, always available to answer questions and help with the closing process - thank you, Carol!

Seller review
I am so grateful that I chose Carol to represent me and my siblings in the sale of my parents home
over 2 years ago
I am so grateful that I chose Carol to represent me and my siblings in the sale of my parents home

I am so grateful that I chose Carol to represent me and my siblings in the sale of my parents home. I invited her and another agent to their home and she won me over with her local knowledge and understanding of the monumental task of preparing the home for sale. Ultimately, the house sold within days, but she was instrumental in navigating through a couple of challenging bids. From agreement to settlement, there was great communication and settlement was a breeze because of the teamwork!!

Seller review
I’m so thankful for Carol’s guidance and expertise
over 2 years ago
I’m so thankful for Carol’s guidance and expertise

I’m so thankful for Carol’s guidance and expertise. She communicates through the whole process. She helped navigate through a failed bid, provided an attorney that allowed me to get to the ultimate buyer. Carol arranged the necessary fire inspection and provided assurance that I was checking all the boxes to get to the finish line with my parents estate. She is super knowledgeable and experienced from listing to settlement, which was well organized, completed in a timely fashion, due in part to Carol’s long standing relationship with the title company and lender representative.

Seller review
Carol is the absolute best!  I have worked with Carol Menz as both a buyer and seller, and she someh
over 2 years ago
Carol is the absolute best! I have worked with Carol Menz as both a buyer and seller, and she someh

Carol is the absolute best! I have worked with Carol Menz as both a buyer and seller, and she somehow makes the process easy and go smoothly. I feel comfortable knowing that she will not let anything fall through the cracks. I have worked with quite a few realtors in PA, NJ, and, most recently, MD. Whenever I have to use a realtor in another state, I miss not having Carol by my side - other realtors are truly not up to par with her. For instance, when I ask for a timeline so I know what needs to be done and when, other realtors just ignore the request. Carol, on the other hand, keeps you informed and on track to meet all deadlines. She is truly the best realtor with whom I have worked, and I have dealt with many.

Seller review
When we started to think about selling our bay front home, I decided to “interview” a bunch of realt
over 2 years ago
When we started to think about selling our bay front home, I decided to “interview” a bunch of realt

When we started to think about selling our bay front home, I decided to “interview” a bunch of realtors and pick the best one. Carol Menz was the first one I spoke to. I never spoke to anyone else! My instinct was correct. Carol is knowledgeable and personable. She helped us through a complicated and challenging negotiation. Our house was sold in a matter of weeks for a price that I would have thought beyond reach. Call Carol, you won’t regret it.

37 - 48 of 142
© 2026 RateMyAgent