Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 64 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
about 2 years ago
Andy took the pain out of selling our house!

Andy was great to work with. He made selling and buying our new home as seamless as possible. He has great communication skills and we felt well supported by him. Thanks Andy!!

about 2 years ago
Personable and Friendly

Andy is stellar to work with!! He is personable, friendly, and very caring. He listens to our desires and aspirations and makes himself available to assist us in any way he is able. He has made our first-time home-buying experience incredibly positive!!

over 2 years ago
Andy is the best.

Andy came highly recommended and now I know why. I expected him to be professional, knowledgeable, and of high moral character, which Andy definitely is. However, Andy went far beyond these qualities. He made the stressful experience of buying a house into an exciting experience, relieving our anxieties by staying ahead of any concerns we had. Andy attended to every detail. More than that, his warm and caring manner turned buying a house into an enjoyable experience. My wife and I feel Andy is more a friend than an agent. I definitely would choose Andy first if I ever buy or sell another house. And, I will recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell their homes. Andy is the best.

over 2 years ago
Andy Bathje is outstanding in all areas of being an agent.

I was so thankful for Andy Bathje to represent my husband and I as our agent. His expertise helped us in so many ways. He was so efficient at communicating through text messages, emails, and calls which always kept us informed and not wondering what was happening next. Andy went way above his call of duty as an agent and now we are so grateful to call him our friend.

over 2 years ago
It is a gift to work with Andy. He made the whole process smooth and enjoyable right to closing.

What a gift to work with Andy! He explained every detail and simplified the process from the first conversation to closing. His communication was prompt and he stayed ahead of challenges to keep things moving. Andy's help in establishing the listing price was crucial. We listed for more than we expected we could, then received offers and sold above the list price! Just as important to me is that he is so kind, patient, and it was fun anytime we connected. So, Andy simplified the daunting process of selling our home so we could eagerly move ahead, and he led us to a very successful sale. I highly recommend him. He can help turn your desire to sell into reality, and put you at ease if you have any hesitations. Connect with him and use him to sell or purchase your home. You will see what I mean that it's a gift to work with him.

over 2 years ago
Andy is Amazing

Andy helped us buy our home two years ago and of course was our first and only call when we were ready to sell. Andy is very professional at all times, he communicates very well which is much appreciated. You can tell he genuinely cares about his clients

over 2 years ago
Clear communication and great negotiation!

Andy was so responsive to our questions and helpful through the whole process. As first time home buyers, we definitely needed someone to hold our hand. Along the way. In the end we got the house we wanted at a great price during a tough market! Can’t recommend this guy enough!

over 2 years ago
Please see my review in the box below

I was beyond pleased with Andy’s handling of my sale. He patiently answered all my questions and guided me in everything I needed to do. Thanks to his knowledgeable guidance my home sold in 3 weeks. Andy has a thorough knowledge of the real estate business, and he is known and respected throughout the community Andy was both personable and professional, and I came to think of him as a true friend. We often sat and chatted like two longtime buds. Now that my sale is concluded and I’ve moved out of state, I miss him. To anyone considering buying or selling their home, I recommend Andy 100%.

over 2 years ago
Andy Bathje - a joy to work with - I would recommend without reservation - thank you Andy!

Andy Bathje was great to work with in selling my house and farm. He took time to listen and understand what was important to me. He gave helpful advice and was consistently available for any questions I had along the way. He kept me informed of queries, showings, and feedback. Andy offered and provided so much beyond what a realtor generally does including walking the land (27 acres with woods) with potential buyers so they could appreciate the beauty leading to the Kentucky River. He was creative in his efforts to showcase my place by ensuring that the stone fence and springhouse areas were cleared for photos and hiring a drone photographer to capture the land all the way back to the river. Clearly, Andy considered the unique qualities of my property and captured a vision of all it had to offer. He was then able to communicate it well to potential buyers. I felt very well represented and know that "my" beautiful farm and house are now well loved by others. Andy is always professional while also very friendly and easy to work with. I would recommend him to anyone who has need for the help of a realtor in a heartbeat! Thanks Andy for all your help.

over 2 years ago
Andy is the best of the best

Through every step of the process, Andy was excellent to work with. You don't feel like you're working with a realtor. You feel like you're working with a trusted friend who has your best interest in mind. He took great care of us, he'll do the same for you.

over 2 years ago
First Time Home Buyer

I've known Bathje for years, so it was a no brainer once my wife and I decided to buy our first home to go to him. He made the process super-fast and easy. We started out just looking and ended up buying a house in the first few weeks. His communication through the entire process was great, especially when there were some things that popped up on the inspection. He was patient with us while I made sure everything was fixed to our liking. Would highly recommend and will definitely be giving him a call once we decide to start expanding our family!

37 - 48 of 64
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent