Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 64 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 12.
over 1 year ago
Andy Is The Best!

Andy made the sale of our condo so easy for us. He was very knowledgeable regarding everything. This included the housing market; he was quite thorough and gave us an analytical review of past sales in the area with a comprehensive breakdown of differences and how they compared to our condo. His expertise helped us make necessary decisions when they needed to be made. He was a constant support, and was always available for questions. He honestly went above and beyond, and exceeded all of our expectations. We are so glad a friend recommended Andy to us when we were looking for a realtor.

almost 2 years ago
Hard working and thorough

Andy helped me price my property for a quick sale. He was extremely gracious. He understands the current market and how to get things sold. I highly reccomend Andy Bathje.

almost 2 years ago
Excellent Agent to work with!

Andy was a fantastic agent to work with. He was on top of any new listings that met our criteria and always made the time to show us a potential property. We were on quite the time crunch to find a new house, but he made the process very smooth and painless. I can't recommend Andy enough for your home buying process. He made what is a very stressful time feel a little less stressful and always advocated for us. We also used him to sell our home which was another fantastic experience. Overall great experience and highly recommend!

almost 2 years ago
Exceeded expectations!

Andy reached out to me that he had someone interested in our home, but we were trying to sell the property without an agent. After our discussion he said his primary job was to take care of his client but would assist in the process. Andy was always a text, email or phone call away, and there was not a day that would go by that he didn't check in. He took a family vacation during the process but still took the time to make sure things were moving towards a closing. Thank you Andy for getting this done and if needed an Agent in the future, it would be an easy decision to select Andy!!

almost 2 years ago
Your go to source for this market and area.

Our second experience with Andy and both times were excellent. He really knows the market and this area and provided valuable insight when listing out home. Would highly recommend him looking to buy or sell.

almost 2 years ago
Such a great person for a stressful situation!!

Andy was a great agent to have! I was selling my home of 37 yrs. and very inexperienced with the market. He was eager to share knowledge and market comparisons with me with patience and grace and was responsive in very timely manner as I was actively looking at homes. Andy made the whole process go smoothly and efficiently and I would recommend him highly.

almost 2 years ago
Above and beyond!

We recently had the pleasure of working with Andy Bathje to find our dream home, and we couldn't be happier with the experience. From start to finish, Andy went above and beyond in every aspect of the process. Communication was always clear, prompt, and professional. Andy kept us informed at every step, making sure we understood all the details and felt comfortable with our decisions. His attention to detail is impeccable, ensuring that nothing was overlooked. One of the standout moments was when he actually crawled into the crawlspace with my husband during a re-inspection to check for any issues. This level of dedication and hands-on approach is truly rare and greatly appreciated. Not only is Andy incredibly generous with his time and resources, but he is also a person of the highest integrity. We always felt we could trust him completely, knowing he had our best interests at heart. His ethical standards are unwavering, and his professionalism is unmatched. We can't recommend Andy highly enough. If you're looking for a realtor who will go the extra mile, communicate effectively, and ensure every detail is taken care of, Andy Bathje is the right choice.

about 2 years ago
Great agent!

Andy went far beyond our expectations as a real estate agent. He was warm and personable, professional and effective. We would absolutely recommend him.

about 2 years ago
Andy goes above and beyond!

Andy Bathje impressed us with his knowledge. From getting our how ready to list, looking for a new house, appraisals, signing documents, etc., Andy helped every step of the way. He had great suggestions of how to get our house to sell. He answered our numerous questions on the process in good detail. Andy went above and beyond in helping us with the process of moving out of our old house and into a new house. His thoughtfulness and time that he gave us showed us that he cares more about us as a family than about making a sale. His wisdom, understanding and support made this extremely difficult process so much easier.

about 2 years ago
Andy helped us find the best house for our family.

Andy was a great help and support during the whole process of buying our house. He and a great team of thoughtful professionals helped make buying our next home as easy as possible. I would highly recommend Andy!!

about 2 years ago
Great Experience

Working with Andy was a fantastic experience. He maintains a high level of professionalism and market knowledge while also being friendly and personal. He is quick to respond to questions and schedule showings, but never made us feel pressured or rushed. We are grateful to have worked with Andy and very happy with our new home.

about 2 years ago
Hard working and great communication

Andy was easy to work with from our first contact and through out the process. He continued to share his knowledge and experience with us as we navigated the home buying experience. He also adapted to our unique circumstances and needs. We felt the entire process was easy with Andy by our side even though we were out of state the majority of the time.

25 - 36 of 64
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent