Andy's profile

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 70 reviewsacross 19 different locations, showing 12.
11 months ago
Real estate happiness is working with Andy Bathje!

Andy Bathje’s knowledge of the Jessamine county real estate market is profound as he lives in the area and is an active member of the Wilmore community. Thus, there could not have been anyone better suited for our needs and to help us sell a property at Bethel Pointe. Not only was his real estate expertise an asset, but so was his knowledge and assistance in facilitating work by specialists in home repairs and any other property improvements required for the sale. Andy’s communications with us were spot on, and we were always well informed with respect to the sale and closing of the residence. Andy’s professionalism and engaging personality made the entire experience a walk in the park. We are most grateful to Andy in all regards, and highly recommend his services.

about 1 year ago
Andy is the BEST! Would highly recommend!

We had a fantastic experience working with Andy to sell our home. From start to finish, he was extremely professional, knowledgeable, and communicative. He took the time to walk us through every step of the process, explaining our options clearly and helping us feel confident in every decision. Andy provided us with a wealth of resources as we prepared the home for market, including a well-vetted list of professionals—everything from a do-it-all handyman to a plumber, as well as yard professionals, a plumber, and movers—which made a huge difference and saved us time and stress. He was always available for questions, provided honest and thoughtful guidance, and went above and beyond to ensure things stayed on track. We truly appreciated Andy’s attention to detail and the way he made the entire process feel manageable and smooth and calmed us down when anxiety creeped in. Selling a home can be overwhelming, but with Andy, it felt like we had a trusted advisor in our corner the whole way through. We’re very grateful for all his hard work and would highly recommend him to anyone looking to sell their home.

about 1 year ago
first time home buyer

I had a wonderful experience with Andy Bathje as my realtor. He advocated for me and made my home buying experience very smooth. As a first time home buyer, I had a lot of questions and he was incredibly knowledgeable about the market in Lexington. Andy communicated clearly and I felt confident during the whole process.

about 1 year ago
A Successful Move Was Ensured

As first-time homebuyers we were unsure about how to even begin the process much less take it all the way through. Our realtor, Andy Bathje, made the entire process seem easy. He helped us locate a property that perfectly fit our needs and wants in the location we desired and at the price we could afford. He's a top-of-the-line realtor who knows his stuff. We would recommend him to anyone looking to purchase a home.

about 1 year ago
Wonderful!

Andy is the best! He helped us buy our first home and we couldn’t be happier!

about 1 year ago
He was very knowledgeable and made the process easy!

I’m grateful for Andy’s clear communication and obvious knowledge of the area we were buying in. He made our buying process easy! I’d highly recommend him to anyone in need of a realtor

about 1 year ago
Eager and Willing to Help Find the Right House

I honestly did not think it was possible for me to find a house that I could afford and that I would like in an area that I would enjoy. Andy did a great job of sending me all possible houses. Anytime I was interested in a house he was quick to offer to show it to me and schedule an upcoming time. He was also good at walking through the house and giving his feedback and input. When I had decided I wanted to put an offer in on a house, he encouraged me to see it for a second time. All throughout the process, his communication was great, and he helped me understand all of the paperwork and contracts every step of the way. He connected me to an excellent and helpful lender and an awesome inspector. He even referred me to a handyman he personally knew who could help get the little things fixed once I closed on the house. I would definitely recommend Andy as a realtor and in fact I do tell anyone I know looking for a house that they should contact him.

about 1 year ago
A Realtor Greater Than Which None Could Be Conceived

You'll know from the headline both (a) that I'm probably a philosopher and (b) that I thought Andy was simply superb. He was extremely professional throughout all interactions while maintaining genuine friendliness and helpfulness. His feedback on homes (which we had to assess sight-unseen except for virtual visits) when touring them over Zoom with us was detailed without being over-the-top, and he was great at suggesting creative and practical ways for using the space we'd see on camera. He was prompt in communications no matter the situation, and when he happened to be stopping near us on a brief vacation, he took the time to meet with me in person for a coffee and walk me through the buying process some more. Given that we were living about 14 hours of driving away, this was a huge gift! I should also add that we visited the house we bought after our offer on it was selected. Since we hadn't spent much time in the area, Andy offered to give us a personalized tour, and that tour was easily the most meaningful and memorable portion of our visit. And it clearly shows that Andy is a realtor that cares deeply about his clients not just as clients but also as people in themselves. He's a stellar guy with serious knowledge of what's going on in the Lexington/Wilmore/Nicholasville/etc. area. If you're looking for a home, you should absolutely get in touch.

about 1 year ago
Above and Beyond

Andy was always available to answer questions and made my husband and I feel comfortable and informed as this was our first time to buy a home. Though it was unexpected, he even put in the time to help us while on vacation because we found a home we really wanted! Andy has the best friendly demeanor and clearly cares about the community being built in the area as well. Highly recommend!

over 1 year ago
Trustworthy & Caring Agent

Andy Bathje impressed us with his knowledge. From getting our home ready to list, looking for a new house, appraisals, signing documents, etc., Andy helped every step of the way. He had great suggestions of how to get our house to sell. He answered our numerous questions on the process in good detail. Andy went above and beyond in helping us with the process of moving out of our old house and into a new house. His thoughtfulness and time that he gave us showed us that he cares more about us as a family than about making a sale. His wisdom, understanding and support made this extremely difficult process so much easier.

over 1 year ago
Informed Knowledge of Lexington Area

Andy has lived in the Lexington area for decades. He has been very engaged in the community. He knows the area’s history and this informs his expertise as a realtor. He is accessible, friendly, a good listener, and has extensive knowledge of the real estate market. From understanding pricing to negotiating to recommending local craftsmen for renovations…Andy is a remarkable realtor! We highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in the greater Lexington area.

over 1 year ago
Great Agent

Andy was phenomenal to work with. He was very professional, courteous, and knowledgeable about the home buying process. He helped us navigate the ins and outs of every step and I couldn't have asked for a better agent to work with.

13 - 24 of 70
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent