Andy Bathje

Andy Bathje

Real Estate Agent at The Agency
  •   5   (73 reviews)

About Andy

My goal is to attend to your best interest. I am experienced as a Buyer's and Seller's Agent throughout the Bluegrass. Since becoming a Realtor in 2020, I have handled close to 100 transactions of residential homes, multi-family investment properties, new construction, and large parcels of land in over a dozen counties. Prior to real estate, I directed a good works nonprofit, worked in higher education, and managed outdoor leadership programs. I effectively come alongside clients to support them in the difficult home transition process. I am a quick and clear communicator that acts when you need me. I will do all I can to make sure you are served and well-informed!

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 73 reviewsacross 19 different locations, showing 6.
Review Andy
about 1 month ago
Working with Andy to sell our home was an excellent choice!

Andy has excellent communication skills and is highly personable while also being professional. He was very clear throughout the whole process of selling our home and we felt very fairly represented. We would highly recommend working with Andy!

about 1 month ago
Patient, helpful, and genuinely great to be around—exactly what you want in a realtor!

We had such a great experience working with Andy as first-time home buyers. He was incredibly patient with us and helped us through every step of the process. He showed us several properties and was always willing to make himself available, answer our questions, and help however he could. If he wasn’t available, he always made sure to find someone who could help us. More than anything, he was someone we genuinely enjoyed being around. He made the entire process feel easier and less overwhelming, and we never felt rushed or pressured. He was exactly what you want in a realtor—knowledgeable, patient, dependable, and someone who truly wants to help you find the right home. We’re so grateful for everything he did for us and would absolutely recommend him to anyone looking to buy a home!

about 1 month ago
Absolutely fantastic

Andy was absolutely wonderful. We were moving from across the country and Andy helped us get everything sorted with ease. He went above and beyond in every possible way, anticipated needs long before we asked, made time for us across time zones, and was all around wonderful. Cannot say enough wonderful things about Andy.

about 2 months ago
Excellent, Creative insights and Dedicated Agent!

Andy offered us great advice and counsel as our agent. Additionally he gave creative insights on how best to ready our property for sale. And, most importantly, Andy was dedicated to seeing our sale all the way through - from start to finish - with great professionalism and warm, personable charm. We highly recommend him as an agent!

about 2 months ago
Deeply personal touch, patient, and friendly

Andy was always responsive to our requests and needs. He helped us buy our first home remotely and then sell it when we moved. He kept in touch, worked with us around complex schedules, and connected with us on a personal level. He gave us a good range for our what to list house, and helped us get top dollar for it. A great realtor to work with!

about 2 months ago
Above and Beyond

The owners were out of state and Andy Bathje made that aspect very smooth. His communication was excellent and prompt. He was very knowledgeable about the market and property and he was instrumental in getting contractors to help do necessary maintenance and updates. We could not have done it without Andy's help. We highly recommend him as a realtor.

Show all 73 reviews

Andy's properties

Andy has sold 19 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldAug 28, 2026
$230,000
312 Bellevue Avenue
Wilmore KY 40390
4
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker McMahan and The Agency
SoldAug 7, 2026
$62,500
4 Bellevue Avenue
Wilmore KY 40390
Land
Listing courtesy of The Agency
SoldJul 22, 2026
$276,000
557 Cold Hill Rd
London KY 40741
3
3
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of WIECHERT REALTORS-FORD BROS and The Agency
SoldJul 14, 2026
$325,000
2183 Stephens Lane
Lexington-Fayette KY 40504
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of The Agency and KELLER WILLIAMS GREATER LEXINGTON
Show all 19 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent