Andy Bathje

Andy Bathje

Real Estate Agent at The Agency
  •   5   (64 reviews)

About Andy

My goal is to attend to your best interest. I am experienced as a Buyer's and Seller's Agent throughout the Bluegrass. Since becoming a Realtor in 2020, I have handled close to 100 transactions of residential homes, multi-family investment properties, new construction, and large parcels of land in over a dozen counties. Prior to real estate, I directed a good works nonprofit, worked in higher education, and managed outdoor leadership programs. I effectively come alongside clients to support them in the difficult home transition process. I am a quick and clear communicator that acts when you need me. I will do all I can to make sure you are served and well-informed!

Andy's reviews

  5  
Andy has 64 reviewsacross 18 different locations, showing 6.
Review Andy
3 months ago
Excellent!

Andy’s market knowledge, timely communication and patience helped us to find the perfect home for our family. A handicap accessible home in a tight market is difficult to find, but Andy got it done. We are so thankful!

4 months ago
Navigaating our sale was not simple!

The sale process started with questions of whether old but serviceable carpet needed to go, and other potential updates. Then, price. Did market data accurately reflect current demand? Next, the home was listed over a holiday weekend, and we wanted a variety of viewers to have a chance to make offers before deciding anything. Then came the inspection. Some demands were reasonable and some dubious. Follow-up inspections and negotiations were required. Andy Bathje acted as a shepherd throughout. He was respectful of our views, offered advice, and was always reassuring. In the end we were happy with the result and thought it was fair to all parties.

4 months ago
Very professional

I spent a lot of time with Andy looking at several homes all over Kentucky. He came prepared with information sheets , ratings and extensive knowledge of the area I was looking to move to. Andy offered great insights and made the whole process easy. He was willing to work with my selling agent from another state without any hesitation. While I expect this to be the last home I ever purchase, if I needed to I would use Andy again and will refer him to any who need to buy or sell.

4 months ago
Great follow-through.

Andy is very conscientious. His follow-through throughout the process of purchasing our home was fantastic. He reminded us of when things were due. He typed up detailed summaries of things we had discussed and sent them to us the same night. It is very evident that he really cares about the well being of his clients. Andy also knows everyone in the area (or so it seems). If you need a recommendation for a handy man, a carpenter, or a radon specialist, he knows them. Andy gets the job done. Is practical and fair-minded. And full of good advice. We highly recommend him.

4 months ago
Knowledgeable & Attentive

Andy knows the housing market and trends of the community. He is quick to respond to questions and reaches out with new information before you think of questions. Andy is dependable and hard working in helping match his clients needs.

4 months ago
Awesome Agent

We've had Andy help us twice in the last 2 years and he has been super!!

Show all 64 reviews

Andy's properties

Andy has 6 properties for sale and sold 17 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$485,000
501 Corbitt Drive
Wilmore KY 40390
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of The Agency
Pending
$139,000
9733 Buckeye Road
Lancaster KY 40444
Land
Listing courtesy of The Agency
SoldApr 22, 2026
$190,000
316 Walters Lane
Wilmore KY 40390
3
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of The Agency
Pending
$375,000
500 Corbitt Dr
Wilmore KY 40390
3
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of The Agency
Show all 23 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent