Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
204 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, dedicated, reliable, supportive, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Friendly, Informative and Professional
about 3 years ago
Friendly, Informative and Professional

These are the three words we would use to describe Crystal! We walked into her office on Tuesday morning and she was SO friendly and willing to tell us all about Orofino. We felt welcomed to the community and informed about how houses and properties we were looking at. She then took us to some on Wednesday and by that afternoon we had made an offer and it was accepted!!! Her knowledge of the process and her professionalism is certainly unmatched in this business! If you are looking for a realtor, look no further!!! You just found one!

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
Absolutely Outstanding!
about 3 years ago
Absolutely Outstanding!

Keith was the epitome of a well-informed professional who never gave up despite the problems of trying to deal with a reverse mortgage that had been sold to the US government, which was a real nightmare to try to deal with or even to get a payoff. To this day, the government has never acknowledged my husband's death after almost eighteen months. But Keith never gave up, and his perseverance has paid off with me ending up owning 5.6 acres of land and a three-bedroom, two bath house, free and clear.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Buyer review
Beyond just an agent!
about 3 years ago
Beyond just an agent!

Are you after an agent that will just assist in the buying/selling of a home or would you rather have an agent that actually pounds ground, puts in the footwork to make sure every aspect is as smooth as it can be? Crystal was a joy to work with, be around and went above an beyond any agent we've ever worked with and this is our 4th home purchase. Do yourself a favor and look no further. This woman is actually amazing!!

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
Top Quality Realtor!!
about 3 years ago
Top Quality Realtor!!

Keith was great to work with, his knowledge and experience is excellent! Keith delivered on everything we had discussed regarding the sale of my house and property! I highly recommend Keith!

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Seller review
Home sale Idaho
about 3 years ago
Home sale Idaho

I listed my home with Keith, immediately I knew I made the right choice. His professionalism, and knowledge, are beyond what I’ve experienced. From the beginning, all the way to the end of the property sale, he was on top of everything, and anything that came up. Selling a property can be a stressful experience. Having Keith as your agent, made it all a great positive experience. I would Highly recommend him, and will use him on my next listing as well. Thank You for all your efforts Keith.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Seller review
Savvy and Skilled
about 3 years ago
Savvy and Skilled

Crystal was a dedicated professional, able to advise us on the local housing and property market and bid management. So glad she has been our realtor, providing guidance throughout the process.

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
#1 Realtor
about 3 years ago
#1 Realtor

Keith is #1 in our book. He gives good advice, he's friendly and easy to do business with. He will have all our future business as well.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Seller review
Exceptional and positive
over 3 years ago
Exceptional and positive

Keith did everything we asked him to do and more to sell our property. He put it out there every way imaginable. His pictures were excellent, he even did drone shots. He checked in with us frequently and answered our every question. You couldn't ask for a better realtor/broker than Keith!

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent agent and kept me informed
over 3 years ago
Excellent agent and kept me informed

Keith is a great agent. He is not just a 9 to 5 agent. He was there to answer questions in the early morning or evenings. He is dedicated and always there to help his clients. You can count on Keith to get the job done.

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Seller review
Keith is a true professional. I would recommend him to others. He knows his business!
over 3 years ago
Keith is a true professional. I would recommend him to others. He knows his business!

Keith is a caring, knowledgeable broker, highly professional, experienced, balanced and calm. He got us our best price for our home. He kept us informed every step of the way, and explained things so we understood. He is still following up with us to make sure we are satisfied. I would recommend Keith to anyone who needs a professional realtor! Thank you, Keith!

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
Buyer review
Amazing experience
over 3 years ago
Amazing experience

Crystal was so helpful and friendly as can be .She really did make buying a home easy and stress-free. She has such a positive attitude and very professional. She helped us with getting to know the community and good recommendations for services . We are very thankful for her service.

Crystal Gay

Crystal Gay

  5   (43 reviews)
Seller review
I could not have foun a better REALTOR to take care of my homes for sale.
over 3 years ago
I could not have foun a better REALTOR to take care of my homes for sale.

Orofino is not a big town, but KEITH NICHOlS is a big and a great guy in my eyes. I gave him a giant challange of selling not one home, for me, but three and in a time when the market had taken a drop in price also the mortgage rates Started going up. He kept me informed of what was happening each step of the way. He and his employees are the kind of people that every company should have. I was very lucky and very happy to have been able to met them and to have a great relationship with all of them. KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK KEITH

Keith Nichols

Keith Nichols

  5   (141 reviews)
145 - 156 of 204
© 2026 RateMyAgent