Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
605 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
about 5 years ago
Very supportive, informative, and hands on through the whole process.

The Pepper Team helped us sell our house in Palmetto. You don't know how munch is involved with selling a house until you start down that path. Andrew and his excellent team were very supportive, informative and hands on through the whole process. Of course there are always curves and dips to navigate around. Andrew and his team did a hats off job in getting us to the finish line. Very pleased with the whole process. Thanks Pepper Team!

Andrew M Pepper

Andrew M Pepper

  5   (21 reviews)
about 5 years ago
"Andrew was the best

"Andrew was the best. He felt like a friend and i felt he gave his honest opinion on properties we were not able to visit ourselves. He was never too busy and made us feel we were his prize clients. His office made every detail go smoothly and they were all knowledgeable, or found the answer quickly to our every question. I would never hesitate to recommend Andrew Scherer to anyone of my friends - buying or selling."

Andy Scherer

Andy Scherer

  5   (32 reviews)
about 5 years ago
Really enjoyed working with Miranda and her team

Really enjoyed working with Miranda and her team. The amount of knowledge that she has about the area is amazing! Miranda and her team were with us every step of the way -- from helping us find the perfect home right up until closing. Would highly recommend them.

Miranda Oswald

Miranda Oswald

  5   (24 reviews)
about 5 years ago
Above and beyond!

From the beginning of our search, Mike has gone above and beyond to make the home buying experience a breeze. My fiance and I are fortunate to have found such a devoted and professional realtor. We are new to the Sarasota area, so Mike made sure to help us find the right house in the perfect neighborhood that catered to our exact needs. Mike provided his services to us throughout the entire process, even after his job was done. During this incredibly busy market, Mike really made us feel like we were his only clients!

Mike Martino

Mike Martino

  5   (90 reviews)
about 5 years ago
"We had previously followed the golden rule that one should never select a relative or a friend as a

"We had previously followed the golden rule that one should never select a relative or a friend as a realtor. Previous experience with a friend and neighbor became disastrous when we had to fire her for lack of performance. After Andrew had negotiated the contract on our new home we had definitely become friends, despite this, we decided to proceed with Andrew as our realtor for selling our current home! Andrew made the stressful purchase and sale of our homes bearable. We were particularly impressed by the way his team organized the listing of our home with some brilliant pictures in a matter of a few days. Within 18 hours of the listing being posted, we had 3 showings, 2 offers, and a signed contract. Andrew was also very much in control of the complex legal and financial matters with both homes. We could always rely on him to resolve whatever issues arose We heartily recommend Andrew Scherer as your realtor, he is a consummate professional."

Andy Scherer

Andy Scherer

  5   (32 reviews)
about 5 years ago
First time home buyers

My wife and I were moving from Pennsylvania to Florida because of a job transfer. The move had to be swift and Mike knew this. He guided us on areas that fit our wants and budget. He was always available and was full of knowledge. This was our first time purchasing a home, and Mike always took the time to teach us and walk us through the process. His customer service skills are amazing and his work ethic is like none other. We live out new home and we are grateful that we had Mike to help us find it. Highly recommend him as an agent!

Mike Martino

Mike Martino

  5   (90 reviews)
about 5 years ago
Best experience ever

In my experience, Mike was very honest, informative, and very knowledgable about the market, and providing advice. Never did I feel pressured, or mislead when shopping or negotiating. Mike went above and beyond to help me with every aspect of the process, making it easier to weigh my options and come to a favourable decision. He will definitely be the only real estate Agent I will be doing business with in the future.

Mike Martino

Mike Martino

  5   (90 reviews)
about 5 years ago
Grandmaster of Real Estate Sales

Mike is a great agent, very knowledgeable and professional. It was very easy for me to work with him.

Mike Martino

Mike Martino

  5   (90 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Top notch- One of the best in the business!

Mike was an outstanding realtor who I was lucky enough to have had the chance to work with for our new home in Sarasota. He went above and beyond to help us find the perfect home while we were living in another state. He has exceptional knowledge of the many communities in Sarasota and the surrounding region. I could not have hoped for a better realtor to work with. Thanks for everything Mike!

Mike Martino

Mike Martino

  5   (90 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Karie is one of the most positive and responsive realtors I have ever encountered!!!

Karie is one of the most positive and responsive realtors I have ever encountered!!! She handled our delicate situation with the utmost professionalism and care and got us a ton of competitive offers on our home. She answered all of my daily questions without any annoyance and I felt she truly cared about helping me through the process. I highly recommend her!

Karie Backman

Karie Backman

  5   (72 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Ryan has been a great agent. He's knowledge is amazing

Working with Ryan has been a great experience. He takes time and does the research needed to find what your looking for. He has all the knowledge to make a deal together even in these crazy times with properties getting multiple offers. Ryan continued to work with me to find the right place. When the deal is accepted he also has all the connections you may need for any work you want done. Nice to have an agent willing to give the extra mile.

Ryan Kipnis

Ryan Kipnis

  5   (4 reviews)
421 - 432 of 605
KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S
Contact KELLER WILLIAMS ON THE WATER S
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent