Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
818 reviewsacross 45 different locations, showing 12.
over 4 years ago
Excellent experience with Eileen and Brian

Eileen and Brian are the ultimate professionals. I was very fortunate to meet them and ultimately work with them on the sale of my home. They went the extra mile on every occasion possible. They were on top of current market conditions and were available to answer questions and concerns all along the way. I am extremely pleased with the process and results in the successful sale of my home!

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Top realtor experience.

Steve has the experience and knowledge for a smooth real estate transaction. He knows the Sarasota and particularly the Oaks lifestyle and can steer you to the right property to fit your family. This is our second real estate transaction with Steve and would call him again in a heart beat, Great communication!

Steve Abbe

Steve Abbe

  5   (163 reviews)
over 4 years ago
This is the agent you want! BEST EVER!!

My wife and I were searching for our forever home in beautiful Sarasota. Yvette took the time to share her knowledge, and show us around. She worked tirelessly for over a year to find the right place for us, and we couldn’t be more excited about our purchase. She is a great communicator, and always quick to respond. Through the competitive process of the purchase, she was a master of her craft and guided us exceptionally. If you’re looking for the right agent, look no further. She is the best!

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Exceptional real estate experience

Eillen is first an exceptional real estate agent and she and Brian are a dream team. She is knowledgeable, connected, effective, efficient while thorough and an absolutely terrific communicator. She is also a wise guide and cheerleader and has adapted supremely to the high stakes rapid fire southwest Florida real estate market. Eileen balances competing agendas with ease. She is patient and able to keep critical timetables intact. She is delightful and able to stand firm and advocate for her clients. She is professional and knows her clients very well. I would never seek another agent in Southwest Florida. I only wish she covered our hometown market!

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Just "so-so"

Brian and Eileen were always friendly and professional. They hosted many open houses and put in effort into selling my condo unit. The reason for the three-star rating is that I don't feel that I received their best effort/work product (compared to the work product I saw for other properties they listed). I feel the photos of our property were inferior compared to photos of other properties (the colors were muted; the angles and staging were not optimal). Also, I had to request for the photos to be ordered in such a way as to show our beautiful view in the fist one or two photos. Eileen resisted, indicating MLS rules; however, the order that I requested was exactly the same as the order they used for other listed properties. In addition, the property description lacked the flare and enthusiasm that I saw in other property descriptions prepared by Eileen. In general, perhaps the time that I worked with Brian and Eileen was a particularly busy time for them, such that we did not receive their highest quality of work product.

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Our good friend

Kelly advised us in selling a property before we could begin to sell the house in Sarasota. Then, when we were ready to sell the Sarasota property, she was kind ,considerate and always positive. We think she is a very special person. We are grateful to have had her as a friend and business advisor.

Kelly Rosenberg

Kelly Rosenberg

  5   (28 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Alison is Simply the Best!

Buying a house with Alison Stottlemeyer alongside as our realtor was seamless! We had been working with Alison for a year as she sent us listings to keep us aware of what was available. When the time was right, we met with her for 2 days as she patiently drove us around showing us multiple houses in Sarasota. This was so helpful for us to get a “lay of the land”. When we found our dream home she made it happen! From contract negotiations to referrals of local contractors, Alison was so professional & helpful. Her bubbly, contagious, caring personality and extreme knowledge of the real estate market in Sarasota was a huge bonus. We can’t recommend Alison enough & feel like we’ve also met a new lifelong friend as she helped us find our Florida dream home.

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (78 reviews)
over 4 years ago
True Professionals

Eileen and Brian were very knowledgeable, responsive and made the buying process truly enjoyable. This is an experienced team with integrity.

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Real Estate Purchase

We purchased a condo in Longboat Key with the help of Brian. The experience went very smoothly and without a hitch.

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
over 4 years ago
First class knowledgeable professionals

In a world where 99% of realtors are an overpaid, greedy necessary evil when it comes to buying and selling property, Brian and Eileen are the breath of fresh air one percenters you want working with you. They are smart, charming, informed and patient. They always answer all questions accurately and totally and always made us feel like we were their most important (only) clients. Their market insight and informed opinions were invaluable. They were hands down our most cherished resource when it came to our recent real estate ventures. I would recommend them without hesitation.

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy  - The Gillen McHardy Group

Brian Gillen, Eileen Gillen & Debbie McHardy - The Gillen McHardy Group

  5   (111 reviews)
445 - 456 of 818
© 2026 RateMyAgent