Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
789 reviewsacross 44 different locations, showing 12.
over 4 years ago
Never knew a realtor could offer SO MUCH

(And, my parents and brother were realtors) Alison is so knowledgeable of the market, and the nuances of financing and mortgages. She finds out your needs and looks for ways to please. Through every step in the dificult process of buying one home and selling another, she was our confident guide leading us through it. We know that she genuinely cared about us and it was quite pleasant to see her get just as excited when she is pointing out features she knows we will love. I'm also certain you will have the same experience.

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (74 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Outstanding!

Roger was 'outstanding' in every way possible. We lived on Bird Key for over 40 years and Roger Pettingell was the first name that came to our mind. He has full knowledge of the market and handled everything for us in a very professional manner. Roger has a fantastic Team that works well together. They all are there to help you whenever needed and will give you the correct information. We would highly recommend Roger to everyone. He is extremely reliable and we will use him in the future!

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
over 4 years ago
She's Great!

Yvette is professional and hard working. Her attention to detail is outstanding. I highly recommend her!

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Simply an outstanding real estate agent!

Alison Stottlemyer is simply an outstanding real estate agent!. Her excellence as a realtor is evident in every facet of the home buying and selling process. My wife and I recently sold two properties to purchase our dream home and Alison was paramount to it. From start to finish she was communicative, transparent, prompt and facilitated every in person interaction and subsequent transactions in a most professional and courteous manner. As her clients, she seemingly catered to our every want and need and made the often daunting challenges of buying and selling a home the best of experiences. We could not be happier! We will always recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell property here in Sarasota or anywhere in the Tampa Bay area. Thank you Alison for everything you've done to give us a home we love!

Alison Stottlemyer

Alison Stottlemyer

  5   (74 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
Steve is a true professional

Steve is a true professional. He is very knowledgeable of the business. He has a strong sense of urgency and operates with true integrity. He understands the market in Sarasota and Osprey. He has worked with us on the sale of three of our homes I would recommend Steve for a buyer or a seller that wants a true quality representative that achieves quick results. We love him!!! Tim Capadalis

Steve Abbe

Steve Abbe

  5   (156 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
Awesome Agent

Norma was very knowledgeable. Her response time to requests and any issues was very timely.

Norma Mladineo

Norma Mladineo

  5   (39 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
Mairead is a true professional!

Working with Mairead was awesome. She is very diligent, hard working, and also very responsive. Mairead listened to our wants and needs and worked to find us the home we wanted in a very tough market. We can not recommend her enough.

Mairead Smialek

Mairead Smialek

  5   (1 review)
almost 5 years ago
Well Run and We’ll Organized. Highly Recommended.

Roger and his team are consummate professionals who communicate often and clearly. Having used other agents before and using Roger on our sale, the experience with his team is head and shoulders above anything that I’ve experienced in past. If you want the best, go see Roger and his team.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
Comprehensive Full Service Agent with a great team

Roger has a pedigree of multi-million dollar annual sales and delivered on his experience. He knew all about other agents in the area, other sales, other potential sales and could discuss his recommendations for listing and showing the property with an open mind to seller pre-conceived ideas! He let his marketing and staging team provide input so a really balanced view was presented. He was honest, flexible and not a pressuring agent. He and his entire team worked well with all mediums - email, text, phone you name it. He was completely accessible which was amazing given the volume of interest there is in Sarasota at this time. We felt we got sufficient handholding through the entire process all the way up to the closing (this was our our first RE sale in Florida so there was a learning curve). He/his team made arrangements for possession removal, staging, cleaning, etc and we did not have to lift a finger in this regard. He reviewed all offers and made meaningful recommendations on counters or discussion points with potential buyers' agents. We were selling into the Sarasota Downtown Condo market and we recommend him highly for anyone interested in selling into this market.

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
Great experience with Yvette selling my home!

I recently listed my home with Yvette Sellyn and had four list price offers within two days. Yvette managed the offer process and communication very well. After the contract was signed, Yvette worked hard to resolve all issues so that my sale could close on schedule. Yvette has strong knowledge of the Sarasota real estate market, has been a pleasure to work with, and I would heartily recommend her to anyone looking to sell their property.

Yvette Sellyn

Yvette Sellyn

  5   (46 reviews)
almost 5 years ago
Great Team, Got it done!

Roger and his team put everything into making sure our home sold. We had several items that came up that they assisted with completing to be sure it all went smoothly and we closed when we wanted to. Very happy and would recommend Roger and his team to anyone!

Roger Pettingell

Roger Pettingell

  5   (127 reviews)
469 - 480 of 789
© 2026 RateMyAgent