From 23 reviews overall

Samantha Jeffrey
Sunshine Real Estate Co
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Tuscola County
2601 Underwood Road Caro
Sam is incredibly easy to work with and has a great vibe about her. We never felt pressured in anything, she did her best to answer all of our questions, and navigated some difficult situations in the end. She's professional yet warm and inviting, 100% looks out for your best interest, and is honest and on the up and up. We purchased our home with her, and reached out and contacted her to sell the same home 5 years later because we knew it was her we wanted to work with again!
5687 Hanes Road Vassar
This is the second home search we have made with Samantha. There is a reason she was hired for a second time, Sam is always there to answer questions, go to bat for you, and occasionally even offer an opinion that may force you to look at things a different way, which is a good thing. Sam is knowledgeable, professional and at the same time compassionate to the needs of your family. We stumbled upon her by chance years ago, when searching for our first home in the area. We hired her again when we wanted to sell and move, we were beyond satisfied with Sam. You won't be disappointed.
4567 Seeger St Cass City
Sam goes out of her way from day one to explain the specifics to make sure you are completely understanding what the process entails. She uses her own photos and words to help potential buyers capture an image in their heads before ever stepping foot inside. Even when things don’t go out planned she makes every effort to accommodate and ease the stress. This is a second time working with Sam and we will continue to only work with Sam for any future real estate needs because Sam doesn’t sell your house FOR you she sells it WITH you. Thank you Sam for all your hard work!
From 57 reviews overall

Brett Hubbs
Hubbs Realty Co.

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Tuscola County
9373 Birch Run Rd Millington
Brett’s service is second to none. His communication is clear and I always felt confident knowing everything is taken care of. From the start, he let me know what to expect, what is happening and what the outcome will be. I highly recommend him for anyone looking for a smooth and transparent experience.
State Rd Millington
We had an excellent experience! Brett was super helpful and made the whole process smooth from start to finish. Communication was clear, all of our questions were answered quickly, and everything was handled right on time. We felt confident every step of the way. This was a big step for our business, and we couldn’t be happier with the service and professionalism we received. Highly recommend!
3353 Murphy Lake Rd Millington
Brett is amazing! From the beginning he had a plan. We sat down briefly to walkthrough a realistic timeline. Between selling our house with another realtor & buying one with him, he helped every step of the way - on both sides when needed. This was my 3rd home buying experience & he was on the ball every step of the way. He got me a contact for our home up North & worked hand-in-hand to get things moving along. We hit some rough patches in the timeline, trying to sell our home, but with the open dialog we had, it didn't feel like much of an issue at all. Brett worked on both ends & communicated efficiently. His realistic timeline & approach made the process that much smoother. Overall, we had a great experience & finally got into the home that we wanted. If we ever decide to move or build, Brett will be the guy we reach out to. Couldn't ask for a better Realtor - thank you Brett!
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Tuscola County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Millington2026From 131 reviews overall

Mark Tyler
American Associates REALTORS - Fenton

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Tuscola County
1204 Weeden Rd Caro
I say “last of the greats” because so many people these days don’t truly care about their customers. They just want to make a quick buck and move on. Mark has been working with us on and off for nearly 7 years. We took a break from house hunting about 2 years ago and only recently picked it back up when we found what would end up becoming our dream home. We didn’t hesitate to contact Mark and he happily got us setup immediately with a viewing. Long story short, Mark worked with us diligently and we ended up getting our house that checked basically every box we’ve ever had. 10/10 would recommend Mark Tyler to ANYONE.
1204 Weeden Rd Caro
My husband and I were on the search for our first home a few years ago and didn’t know really the ins and outs of home buying obviously. We knew we needed a realtor, searched around and we came across Mark. Once we talked with him we knew he was the one. He was very knowledgeable, accommodating, kind and patient. We didn’t end up finding a house but believed it wasn’t our time. About a month ago we randomly decided, let’s look at houses to see what’s there and found our dream home! We instantly knew we had to call Mark!! We were so excited to work with him again and the process was as smooth as can be on his end for us! We are so grateful and thankful for Mark and his team! If you’re first time buyers or looking for an amazing agent to work with, Mark and his team are amazing! 10/10!!
From 29 reviews overall
Carol Murtha
Prime Real Estate Group

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Tuscola County
9019 Cardinal Dr Millington
Working with Carol Murtha was one of the best experiences we have had in a long time. Carol was always available to go to the house we were trying to purchase. Her knowledge and friendly attitude was great! Carol would answer her calls when she was able to. If she was busy she would send a text saying she will call when she had a moment. We were never left hanging. When we needed answers to our questions she answered them right away. If she didn’t know, she would find out and get right back to us. Beyond being a realtor she was like a best friend. She would drive an hour away when we needed her to with no complaints…what a wonderful/sweet person she is. Great to work with. I would recommend Carol to anyone who needed a good realtor. Thanks Carol for ALL your help and compassion you gave us…even after we closed on our home. ☺️