From 368 reviews overall

Tammy O Lyne
KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY (PINEHURST)

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 28374
201 Crescent Court Southern Pines
Tammy has been our go to realtor for years. She’s never disappointed us. Once again, she came through. Our home sold very quickly. Her marketing was first rate. Tammy is personable, but also extremely professional. Her great rapport with other realtors makes the selling experience smooth and pleasant. We highly recommend Tammy and her agency!
15 Bel Air Dr Pinehurst
Tammy and her team have a lot of experience and have done a lot of deals. They know how to address the sensitive issues in a diplomatic way and make sure everyone has a positive outcome. We had nothing but a very good experience with Tammy and team.
5 Kahkwa Trail Pinehurst
Tammy was thoroughly knowledgeable and professional in every aspect of the sale of our home. She was very instrumental in assisting us in negotiating the final sale price of our home when some structural issues were revealed. She and her team worked diligently to provide the best support and expertise we needed. I highly recommend her services.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
North Carolina2026County Winner
ratemyagent award
Moore County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Pinehurst2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Cameron2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Carthage2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Southern Pines2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 28374
665 Lake Forest Drive Southeast Pinehurst
I have know Colleen for some time and she is wonderful. She took ownership of the process, was extremely detail oriented, and then followed up with every step following closing. I cannot recommend her strongly enough. She knows the market extremely well. Thoroughly recommend her.
From 56 reviews overall

Cherry Amanatidis
Premier Real Estate of the Sandhills

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 28374
32 Elkton Dr Southern Pines
We have bought many houses over the years, and Cherry and her partner Nick are a powerhouse team. She is a student of the marketplace who constantly updates her information on houses in the market[place, trends, prices, and builders. Her network helps her know when things might come on the market, and her price sense is spot on. Cherry keeps her clients informed. Never once did we say,” gee, I wish she would call us.” We felt as though we were partnered with Cherry.. After having bought and sold lots of real estate over the years, Cherry and her partner make things work the way modern real estate should work. Supportive, informed, judicious, ethical, with access to information needed to make good decisions. We have had three exceptional transactions with Cherry and Nick and offer our highest recommendation.
26 Calhoun Lane Pinehurst
Working with Cherry was genuinely one of the smoothest parts of what’s usually a stressful process. She knows this market cold — not just the listings, but the neighborhoods, the comps, and the builders of areas. That kind of local depth is hard to fake and easy to appreciate when you’re making a six/seven-figure decision. What stood out most was how thorough and efficient she was with the paperwork. Every document got a real explanation — not a “just sign here,” but an actual walkthrough of what you’re agreeing to and why it matters. For anyone who’s been out of the market a while, that clarity is worth more than most people realize until they need it. Response time was consistently fast. Questions got answered, updates came through, and nothing fell through the cracks. In a market where timing matters, that reliability isn’t a small thing. Beyond the professional competence, Cherry is just a genuinely good person — patient, honest, and invested in getting you the right outcome rather than just closing a deal. You can feel the difference between someone who’s transactional and someone who actually cares. She’s clearly the latter. And if you’re lucky, Cherry’s husband Nick will be part of the process too. The two of them complement each other perfectly. While you’re naturally drawn to the visual side of a home — the finishes, the layout, the feel — Nick is quietly checking the things most people miss. He’ll get into the attic, inspect the overall build of the house, and look for evidence of damage. The kind of walkthrough most buyers don’t know they’re missing until something goes wrong after closing. Together, they’re not just helping you buy a house — they’re helping you buy the right one.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Moore County2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 28374
42 Oxton Cir Pinehurst
Jim Hurt did a great job finding us a smaller home that fit our needs perfectly. He was also able to sell our previous home in two days, well above asking price. Jim was always honest and candid with us throughout the entire process and in the end we were very happy with the great service he provided. I would highly recommend Jim Hurt to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, personable and professional realtor.