838 real estate agents in Indianapolis
Nathan Pfahler
Last 12 months in Indianapolis
Avg. sale price $336k Sold (as lead agent) 14 Properties for sale 6
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 323 North Audubon Road, Indianapolis
This was the second property that Nathan sold for me. He is so experienced knowing how to market a property, this was a historic home. The property sold within days (less than a week). With his negotiation skills we received more than asking price. He has a great positive attitude. I rate him the #1 realtor in Indiana and will always use him as my realtor.
Seller of 5302 East St Joseph Street, Indianapolis
Nathan knew the neighborhood and have experience on how to market a rental property that needed some repairs. He sold the property in 4 days, and we received the full asking price. He was wonderful to work with and answered all my questions. I would recommend him to anyone. He is the best realtor I ever worked with.
Seller of 323 North Audubon Road, Indianapolis
Even though I did not get the pleasure of meeting Nathan face to face, he handled the sale of my cousins 2nd property extremely fast. He was right on top of all offers and the house sold immediately. Everything went very smooth and closed escrow with no hiccups. I HIGHLY recommend Nathan for any real estate needs. Thanks for everything Nathan. You’re simply THE best!
Accolades
Damian Szostak
Buyer's Agent | Licensed Real Estate Agent | Sales Agent
Last 12 months in Indianapolis
Avg. sale price N/A Sold (as lead agent) 0 Properties for sale 0
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Seller of 5408 Mesa Verde Dr, Indianapolis
Damian is an excellent realtor and I highly recommend him. He's so professional and dedicated to his career. What stands out the most was his patience and willingness to go above and beyond what others might have dismissed. We were faced with some issues during our journey, but Damian "rolled up his sleeves and got in the trenches with us" in order to reach our end goal. He's so kind and pleasant to work with. We would definitely use Damian again!!!
Accolades
Selling in Indianapolis? Pick the agents you want to hear from — we'll call you first.
Alicia McAvene
Broker | REALTOR® | Real Estate Agent
Last 12 months in Indianapolis
Avg. sale price $258k Sold (as lead agent) 6 Properties for sale 2
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 1751 Bluewater Court, Indianapolis
I would recommend Alicia to anyone wanting to sell or purchase. She is super personable, patient & looks out for you. Thank you for getting us connected and making us a game plan for us to get to our goal!
Accolades
Shelli Anderson
REALTOR® | Attorney
Last 12 months in Indianapolis
Avg. sale price $224k Sold (as lead agent) 7 Properties for sale 0
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Properties for sale
Buyer of 6726 Colleens Way, Indianapolis
My husband and I bought our first house at 23 years old, with Shelli's help. There was so much we didn't know but Shelli always took the time to explain all the steps of the process, and gave us honest and realistic possible outcomes when we were making decisions. We were grateful for her outgoing personality and both her knowledge & experience in real estate. We feel that she played a huge role in us ending up in the right house for the right price!
Accolades
State Top 10
Indiana2026