From 66 reviews overall

Jennie Finlay
Keller Williams Realty - Boise

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Wilder
TBD Allendale Road Wilder
Jenny was great to work with. We spent a long time looking for the right place. Once we found it, Jenny made sure we got the property purchased. She has continued to provide information and support through out our journey to make this our forever place.
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Wilder
703 Prince Avenue Wilder
She is amazing, kind and won’t stop until she finds the right home for you! We love the home we found and it’s all in thanks to her! She helped us anytime with any questions and was a amazing agent we were blessed to have!
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Malheur County2026From 40 reviews overall

Amanda Muller
Homes of Idaho

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in Wilder
28392 Fox Ln Wilder
Amanda was the best agent for me and my family in our situation. Moving from out of state with three kids and living in short-term rentals while trying to find a new home—let’s just say it was hectic. Having her in our corner made all the difference. She stuck with me through a long house hunt that started back in the spring—while I was still trying to sell my other home—putting up with me and all the places we saw along the way. She really put in the time, shared her connections, had my back, and wasn’t afraid to jump into the chaos (mosh pit story to follow, lol). She pointed out things I would’ve missed—whether it helped or hurt the sale—and always kept it real. She followed up when places called back and gave her honest opinions at every turn. One example: she smelled moisture in a basement and made sure the inspector specifically targeted that area, which led to the necessary repairs being addressed. That kind of attention to detail matters! What I appreciated most is that she never pushed me toward anything I didn’t want. She actually listened to what I was saying and what I was looking for, instead of trying to sell me something just to close a deal. She shared her knowledge of Idaho without hesitation—especially the ins and outs of country living. She worked without asking for anything in return and kept me laughing through a process that could’ve easily been overwhelming. She even made sacrifices behind the scenes to help get the deal done. One thing I really loved about her was her down-to-earth approach and good common-sense advice. Fun fact: she goes to shows and gets in the mosh pit! I’ll tell you right now—if your realtor isn’t mosh-pitting, they’re probably not the one for me. Bottom line: Amanda is solid, smart, and 100% someone you want on your side—and she’ll always have a special place in my heart.
City Winner
ratemyagent award
Marsing2026