From 28 reviews overall

Krissy Carnahan
Realty ONE Group Destination | Key West

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 33036
119 Cortez Dr Islamorada, Village of Islands
Krissy was outstanding at her real estate knowledge, worked around the clock to help us with any questions we had. Working with her made the purchase of our newly acquired unit very easy and seamless. Glad to have her as our realtor.
230 Biscayne Boulevard Islamorada, Village of Islands
Working with Krissy to sell our home was truly special — not only because she’s an outstanding Realtor, but because she’s also a dear friend. From the very beginning, her communication and efforts were , clear, and reassuring, which meant so much to me throughout the entire process. Our sale was far from simple and became a very convoluted, but Krissy handled every challenge with professionalism, patience, and confidence. Her sales strategy, strong negotiation skills, and deep local knowledge made all the difference in getting us to a successful closing. She never missed a detail, always stayed one step ahead, and made sure we were informed every step of the way. We couldn’t be more grateful to have her— and we would wholeheartedly recommend Krissy to anyone looking for a truly dedicated, skilled, and caring real estate professional.
G1/119 Cortez Drive Islamorada, Village of Islands
I worked with Krissy to sell my condo in Islamorada, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From day one, she was professional, prepared, and clearly knew the local market. Krissy helped me decide on a smart listing price, guided me on which improvements were worth doing, and arranged beautiful photos and marketing. We had strong interest right away and closed a fair deal very quickly. What I appreciated most was the communication. She kept me updated at every step — showings, feedback, offers, and next steps — so I never felt in the dark. Any time I had a question, Krissy responded quickly and explained everything in a way that was easy to understand. In the end, we accepted an offer that I was very happy with, and the closing process was smooth and well organized. I would absolutely recommend Krissy Carnahan to anyone looking to sell their home.
County Top 5
ratemyagent award
Monroe County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Islamorada, Village of Islands2026Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 33036
From 70 reviews overall

Sandra Tuttle
Island Welcome Real Estate

Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 33036
1082 Bay Dr Monroe County
Sandy helped us find our home in The Keys. She is super knowledgeable of the area and super easy to work with. I was not in town for the closing and she went above and beyond to make the experience go smooth for me. I would highly recommend her.
29462 Geraldine Street Big Pine Key
Sandra Tuttle did an excellent job of advertising my house through Home.com and other means available to the large public. Her descriptions of the house and location were right on and definitely geared to the correct potential buyers. She works hard and successfully sells! Thank you Sandy!
County Winner
ratemyagent award
Monroe County2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Big Pine Key2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Cudjoe Key2026From 0 reviews overall
Scott Ofstein
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Realty
Avg. sale price
Sold (as lead agent)
Reviews in 33036
Reviews collected on RateMyAgent will appear here