RateMyAgentGo to search
Back Cayuga County

194 real estate agents in Cayuga County

Sorted by most reviews for agents in Cayuga County over the past 12 months.
View Nicole McRae's profileNicole McRae

Nicole McRae

5.0 (31 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price $223k
  • Sold (as lead agent) 4
  • Properties for sale 1
Anonymous3 months ago

Seller of 22 Sherman Street, Auburn

Nikki is very organized, thorough, and helped keep everything moving to keep my closing on track!

Nikki did a wonderful job! She added a touch of staging to help the property stand out and she worked tirelessly to close the sale as quickly as possible!

Accolades

Contact
View Kristin Shanahan's profileKristin Shanahan

Kristin Shanahan

5.0 (22 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price $346k
  • Sold (as lead agent) 6
  • Properties for sale 0
Anonymous9 days ago

Buyer of 11524 Southard Road, Ira

Dream house

Worked hard to get us our dream house. Very responsive and made all our showings work for our schedules. She is the best!

B&D Caswell8 months ago

Buyer of 245 Fire Lane 17, Cato

Above & Beyond!

Our time with Kristin was a true joy—we always felt connected, informed, and supported throughout the process of buying our first home. She went above and beyond to see our purchase through to the finish line, even when challenges arose outside of her control. Kristin was incredibly helpful in connecting us with a great lending team and guiding us on a competitive offer amount, which gave us confidence every step of the way. When delays occurred due to the seller’s side, she remained proactive, communicative, and reassuring throughout. We truly don’t know what we would have done without her and couldn’t recommend her more highly.

Accolades

Price Expert
Price Expert
Contact
Takes 40 seconds No address needed yet

Selling in Cayuga County? Pick the agents you want to hear from — we'll call you first.

Start with my neighborhood
View Tyler Mills' profileTyler Mills

Tyler Mills

5.0 (15 reviews)
  • Avg. sale price $117k
  • Sold (as lead agent) 3
  • Properties for sale 0
Theresa Shafer3 months ago

Buyer of 11589 Ferris Road, Ira

Was excellent to work with

Answer any and all questions in a timely manor. Help tremendously with the buying process

Margaret and Jermey6 months ago

Buyer of 8089 State Route 90, Cayuga County

Fantastic!

Answered every question or concern promptly. He made the process much smoother than expected

Accolades

Price Expert
Price Expert
Top 20%
Top 20%
Contact
View Marian Anderson's profileMarian Anderson

Marian Anderson

5.0 (1 review)
  • Avg. sale price $249k
  • Sold (as lead agent) 8
  • Properties for sale 12
Jeanette Smith5 months ago

Buyer of 6487 RT-90, Aurelius

The best of the best!

I met Marian in Fall of 2023 when she showed me one of her listings on Cayuga Lake. I fell in love with the house, but unfortunately we were outbid by a cash buyer. Over the next two years, Marian worked tirelessly to try to find us our perfect lake house home! She showed us literally dozens of homes, some in person and some virtual, since we live 3 hours away. I’m sure there were times when she thought we weren’t actually going to buy anything, but she stuck with us! In September of 2025, we closed on the perfect place! We are still doing renovations on the home, trying to make it our own. We can not thank Marian enough for being so awesome with us! I would HIGHLY recommend her to anyone. She is friendly and knows her stuff and she’s a great person who has now turned into a friend. Pick Marian to help you find your dream home!!!

Accolades

Contact
1 - 9 of 194

Cities in Cayuga County

Suburbs in Cayuga County

View nearby Counties

RateMyAgent
Sales:
(619) 566-0008
Quick Links
© 2026 RateMyAgent
Privacy PolicyTerms & ConditionsLicensingSitemap