Sarah's profile

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 53 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sarah's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, supportive, reliable, patient, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Found exactly what I was looking for
over 3 years ago
Found exactly what I was looking for

I had very specific list of what I wanted in a property, I needed a shop with the right dimensions for my boat, a good location for resale and a move in ready home that I could close on quickly. At the time (post hurricane) I had no access to internet which I thought might make looking at properties difficult but Sarah met with me in person, listened to my needs and found exactly what I was looking for! The whole process was easy and pleasant. I even called Sarah a week after I moved in, just to tell her how much I love being in my new house!

Buyer review
Great realtor who care about her clients
over 3 years ago
Great realtor who care about her clients

Sarah Did a great job handling the purchase of our property . She always made herself available when we needed her. I would highly recommend Sarah for the sale or purchase of your property

Buyer review
Sarah is amazing!!!
over 3 years ago
Sarah is amazing!!!

We first starting working with Sarah (found her info on line) while we were still living in Boston, and we knew right away she’d be the perfect agent to help us find our forever home in Naples, FL. Her communication via email and phone was prompt and thorough. When we arrived in FL, setting up showings with Sarah was easy. She was flexible and always worked with our busy schedules. Her market knowledge is amazing, and her determination to find us exactly what we were looking for was appreciated. Sarah ultimately helped us find a four bedroom newer home, in a private, smaller community in East Naples. Sarah helped us negotiate details and her suggestions were appreciated. She connected us with a local team of lawyers for our closing who were professional and on top of every detail. We would absolutely recommend Sarah to any of our friends, and family, so much so, that my mom used her next for another Naples closing (3 bedroom condo)! Thanks again Sarah!!

Seller review
Professional while personal
over 3 years ago
Professional while personal

Sarah guided us in a very professional manner through a very difficult sale in the middle of a natural disaster, hurricane Ian. We trusted Sarah completely while being far away from the US and she certainly delivered. Sarah was very communicative and made us feel safe during the whole process. We thank Sarah immensely for all efforts and we are very happy with her service.

Buyer review
Very Knowledgable and Experienced
over 3 years ago
Very Knowledgable and Experienced

We enjoyed working with Sarah on the purchase of our Golden Gate Estates home. She is very knowledgable of the Estates area, and is a seasoned real estate agent. She pointed out things that did not immediately occur to us during our home search. Our closing was a difficult one, due to some unusual circumstances, and Sarah and her team handled it with professionalism and poise. I would hire Sarah again to represent us in the sale or purchase of our next home.

Seller review
Pleasure to work with
almost 4 years ago
Pleasure to work with

Sarah was knowledgeable about the area and made the whole process easy. Responded quickly to all of my concerns. Professional and a pleasure to work with.

Seller review
Knowledgeable, patient, professional, consistent.
almost 4 years ago
Knowledgeable, patient, professional, consistent.

Sarah has been our family's go-to agent for the past five years. She has assisted us in three transactions and will undoubtedly be helping us in the future. What sets her apart from other agents is her ability to develop a relationship with her clients that extends beyond the closing. When speaking with Sarah, you will immediately notice her professional yet humble demeanor and expertise in real estate. From the purchasing side, Sarah was incredibly patient and accommodating to any listing I wanted to see. I never felt pressured or that I was inconveniencing her in any way. She was able to answer any question I had. I can always trust her guidance, and she is always just a phone call away if I have questions after the transaction. I have called her many times over the years for housing-related recommendations such as landscaping or plumbing, and she never hesitates to respond. When selling, Sarah is not pushy at all. She allowed me to take my time when deciding to sell and made the entire process incredibly painless. Sarah went above and beyond for our listing and even made sure to be present from the appraisal to the showings. She is consistent with her expertise, no matter the price point. I cannot imagine buying or selling with any agent other than Sarah!

Buyer review
Excellent
almost 4 years ago
Excellent

Sarah was very knowledgeable. She was always professional. She had an understanding of exactly what I was looking for.

Seller review
Considerate and Efficient, Sarah's Handling of Our Sale Was Excellent
almost 4 years ago
Considerate and Efficient, Sarah's Handling of Our Sale Was Excellent

My aging mother had owned a vacant lot in Naples and we feel fortunate to have been referred to Sarah McCandless. Her specific knowledge of the area and unique considerations for the property led us to successfully convert it to useful retirement funds. Her forethought with handling of the first offer we received prepared us better to eventually make the sale. With the entire transaction conducted remotely, her communication was excellent throughout and everything went smoothly. We consider it a Blessing that we ended up working with Sarah and enthusiastically recommend her.

Seller review
Sarah handled a complex transaction with competence, grace and patience.
almost 4 years ago
Sarah handled a complex transaction with competence, grace and patience.

We approached Sarah about listing a parcel that would have to go through probate not for just one estate but for two. She found us a buyer and managed to maintain that relationship even though outside circumstances kept causing delays and there were multiple out-of-state sellers. Her professionalism is beyond question - I am grateful she was our agent.

Seller review
Professional Caring Kind
almost 4 years ago
Professional Caring Kind

Sarah was available and willing to work with us — we were states away. Sarah was available and willing to listen to our concerns and support us every step of the way. Sarah’s expertise, skills, and knowledge in Real Estate made selling our property seamless resulting in a good selling price. Sarah’s uses technology and is familiar with various software platforms—which was a huge benefit. Overall I give Sarah my highest recommendation.

Seller review
Excellent
almost 4 years ago
Excellent

I’ve worked with many realtors, but no one compares to Sarah McCandless. Her knowledge,professionalism,dedication and her caring skills are outstanding!! I wish I could work with her again ( unfortunately we’re out of state now).

37 - 48 of 53
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent