Sarah's profile

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 54 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sarah's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, supportive, reliable, patient, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent realtor who we highly recommend
12 months ago
Excellent realtor who we highly recommend

Selling a home can be a daunting process, even in a favorable market. With the current challenges, we were particularly concerned. However, Sarah made the experience as smooth and stress-free as possible. Her excellent communication kept us informed at every stage, and we always felt like we were her top priority. She was responsive, patient, and proactive in addressing any concerns, even during moments of anxiety. Sarah's professionalism and unwavering support truly shone through, and we're so grateful for her hard work." I highly recommend Sarah. Don’t hesitate to have her help you sell your home.

Seller review
Sarah is good
about 1 year ago
Sarah is good

I really appreciated everything that Sarah did for us. She stayed busy showing my home which sold in about 6 weeks. She also listened when I had stressful moments. She was very caring and understanding. You can't go wrong getting Sarah to sell your home!

Seller review
The right agent in a "tough market"
about 1 year ago
The right agent in a "tough market"

There's no question that the first half of 2025 was a time of rapid (and not great for sellers) changes in the SW Fla real estate market. We needed an agent we could trust to understand the demands of that market, tell us the truth as sellers, and do the legwork to market our home well and bring in the right buyer. Sarah did all of those things for us, leading to s successful sale and helping us be set up for our next home. A great agent!

Buyer review
Exelent oportunity working with sarah
about 1 year ago
Exelent oportunity working with sarah

It was a pleasure working with sarah as a realtor representing me on the purchase af my property always answers the phone and all my questions will use her again in my next purchase

Buyer review
The only agent we would use when buying or selling
over 1 year ago
The only agent we would use when buying or selling

I have both sold and bought a home in Naples and I used Sarah both times. She was knowledgeable about the area, quickly understood my needs and could help me see the pros and cons of each property. She was flexible in accommodating my schedule and was helpful all the way through (and beyond) the buying and selling process. Initially having used a different agent and found them unknowledgeable and only focused on a sale, I found Sarah to be very different as she is interested in helping you make the right next step, whether that is buying or selling. I would not hesitate to recommend her.

Buyer review
EXCEPTIONAL!
almost 2 years ago
EXCEPTIONAL!

Sarah was extremely knowledgeable about all things real estate - neighborhoods, trends, building materials, financing, contracts, etc. She has been a realtor in Naples for over 17 years - and grew up here - which makes a huge difference. She was honest, kind, and hard-working + great sense of humor. She helped me find the perfect home, and I would never consider using another realtor than her.

Buyer review
Peace of Mind
about 2 years ago
Peace of Mind

Our experience with Sarah was top notch! From start to finish we knew we were in good hands. Buying a home from 1400 miles away can feel daunting, but Sarah made the process easy. We had the utmost confidence in Sarah and appreciate all of the attention to detail she provided. Sarah's partner Lenore, was so kind as to take a video while walking through the Property, so we could see the detail not provided in the pictures online. This was so very helpful. Sarah was also prompt in her communication, easy to talk to, knowledgeable in her field, and made us feel like we were her only customers. We HIGHLY recommend Sarah and Lenore. If we were to do it all over again we wouldn't change a thing. Thank you Sarah and Lenore. :)

Buyer review
Great realtor!
over 2 years ago
Great realtor!

Sarah is an exceptional realtor that knows the Naples market very well. She provided excellent communication throughout the entire house buying process. Highly recommend, if you're look for an honest, down to earth realtor.

Seller review
Professional, Caring and Diligent Agent!
over 2 years ago
Professional, Caring and Diligent Agent!

It was truly a pleasure working with Sarah, and we are so thankful that we chose her to sell our home. She is extremely knowledgeable of the Naples Market and was always available to guide and support us through the process. She made what we imagined to be a very stressful experience relatively smooth and worry free. We highly recommend her services!

Seller review
Exceptional Guidance and Support
over 2 years ago
Exceptional Guidance and Support

Working with Sarah McCandless was an absolute pleasure from start to finish! As a first-time home seller, I was quite nervous about the process, but Sarah guided me every step of the way with patience, expertise, and a genuine commitment to my needs. She provided invaluable advice, answered all my questions promptly, and ensured that I felt confident and informed throughout. Thanks to her dedication and hard work, my home sold smoothly and at a great price. I couldn't be happier with the results! I highly recommend Sarah to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, supportive, and proactive real estate professional.

13 - 24 of 54
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent