Sarah's profile

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 57 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
24 days ago
An agent that is beyond exceptional in so many ways!

Sarah really knows her stuff! I went from not even being in the market for a new home to seeing one of her listings and immediately falling in love with it. From that moment on, Sarah made the entire process feel manageable and smooth. She communicated quickly, worked around my crazy schedule to get a showing lined up, and somehow were able to close in just 30 days! Even when potential hiccups arose, Sarah was always prepared. Not only communicating with the Sellers; she also provided me with a list of trusted contacts and resources to make sure everything kept moving and nothing fell through the cracks. Sarah also helped me find a lender who was able to guide me through the bridge loan process, a huge help in this spur of the moment decision to make a dream a reality! Her knowledge went beyond simply buying and selling a home — she was able to explain important differences and potential issues between a wood-frame home and a CBS home, and she gave me a clear timeline of what needed to happen and when. Now, Sarah is helping me sell my old house, and I couldn’t be more grateful to have her in my corner! I’ve known Sarah personally for many years, and while I never imagined I’d eventually use her as my real estate agent, I’m so thankful that I did. Throughout the entire process, as a Naples Native agent, she has been knowledgeable, responsive, organized, and trustworthy. Most importantly, I know I can rely on her experience and expertise, and that peace of mind has been invaluable. If you’re looking for someone who truly knows Naples, the real estate business, and will be there for you from start to finish, I whole heartedly recommend Sarah!!

25 days ago
Attentive, available, and right agent

Sarah listed and sold our property, and we couldn't have asked for better. This wasn't a standard Naples listing. Four-plus acres, fenced and cross-fenced, a chicken coop, and shop building — a place for someone who wanted land and animals, not just a house. That narrows the buyer pool considerably, and Sarah understood that from the first conversation. She never tried to sell it as something it wasn't. She was available for every question we had, no matter how small, and we never felt like we were bothering her. She was also present at every showing to make sure the property was secured afterward. With animals on the place, gates left open isn't a small thing, and she never once let that slip. That told us she was paying attention to what mattered to us, not just to the sale. In the end she found the right buyer. If you have an property and you're worried the average agent won't know what to do with it, call Sarah.

3 months ago
Wonderful Agent

Sarah McCandless is a wonderful agent when selling your home and helping to answer questions when purchasing a new one that is out of the immediate area. Sarah answers her phone calls and if she is unable to gets back promptly on the phone. She is a great communicator and kept us up to date on everything and if not on the phone via text. ( as there are a zillion questions) She was understanding of the emotional aspect of a selling a home you love and provided guidance with the nervousness of fear with buying a new one. Sarah never acted like we were a burden/bothersome. She always cheerful even when we knew she had a busy day. We found her to be very knowledgeable and went beyond the basics. She made to process easier to handle. Overall outstanding..

4 months ago
Excellent Communication & Seamless Experience

Sarah was amazing to work with. Her communication was excellent throughout the entire process, and she made everything feel smooth and stress-free. She was always available, kept me informed, and truly went above and beyond to help with my home sale. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a dedicated and professional agent.

4 months ago
EXCELLENT

We have used Sarah 4 to 5 times. Sales and purchases she always does perfect. Would highly recommend her.

5 months ago
Professional and hard working agents who works to get the job done. Great team!

From the first meeting, when my wife and I met Leonor and Sarah, we knew that these were the agents we needed to hire. Leonor came highly recommended by one of our neighbors, and right up until closing, they did not disappoint. After doing a walk-through of our home and property, Leonor and Sarah explained how they were going to sell our house, the various comps in the area, the condition of the market in our area, and how they would stage the home to make it more appealing to buyers. Immediately after the meeting, we made a decision that these were the agents who would sell our home. This was not the first agent who tried to sell our house. The first agent rarely got us a showing, and we received no legitimate offers in a year. We saw immediate results and started getting multiple showings once our listing became active with Leonor and Sarah. The best thing I found out with Leonor and Sarah is that they always reached out to the buyer's agent to see if there was any interest in purchasing the property, and just as important, we got feedback, which helped us prepare for future showings. They kept us in the loop so we always knew what was going on. Leonor and Sarah also held numerous open houses for our property, which led to several offers and the eventual sale. No matter what happened at a showing or a low offer, both Leonor and Sarah remained positive,e which helped us get through the sale of our home. We relied on both our agents' knowledge of their profession and the market, especially when we had two offers on our property: the first did not work out due to finances, and the second resulted in the sale of our house. We relied on Leonor and Sarah's negotiating skills and took their advice, and I am extremely happy to say that we sold our house. In closing, we would like to say Thank You to both our agents, Leonor and Sarah, for the tremendous job that they did, and we highly recommend these agents to anyone who wants to sell their property.

5 months ago
very easy to work with!

professional and helpful and easy to work with you - thank you for all of your expertise.

6 months ago
Exceptional Experience

Working with Sarah McCandless to sell our home was an exceptional experience from start to finish. Sarah is a master communicator who kept us informed at every milestone, providing a level of responsiveness and clarity that gave us total peace of mind throughout the entire process. Her market knowledge is truly unmatched, but what really set her apart was her hands-on approach to marketing. Sarah personally staged our home to look its absolute best and coordinated amazing professional photography and video that made our listing stand out. Her strategy for holding open houses was incredibly effective, driving significant foot traffic and generating immediate interest. Throughout the journey, she maintained the highest level of integrity and professionalism, handling every detail with grace. We cannot recommend Sarah highly enough to anyone looking for a dedicated, creative, and highly skilled realtor.

7 months ago
Excellent in all areas of Selling and Buying

Sarah and Leonor were exceptional partners in both our home purchase and sale. They consistently went above and beyond our expectations, providing a level of service that truly set them apart. As we are not full-time residents, they took care of numerous details on our behalf while we were out of town, which gave us tremendous peace of mind throughout the process. Their communication was always timely, clear, and helpful, and their deep knowledge of the market proved invaluable in guiding our decisions. We greatly appreciated their expertise and dedication. We would not hesitate to work with them again and highly recommend their team to anyone looking for outstanding real estate professionals.

7 months ago
Exceptional realtor—knowledgeable, responsive, and made buying my home stress-free!

I had a fantastic experience working with Sarah. From start to finish, she was professional, attentive, and highly knowledgeable about the market. She took the time to understand exactly what I was looking for and guided me through every step with patience and care. Communication was always prompt and clear, which made the process smooth and stress-free. Sarah’s dedication and expertise truly go above and beyond—I highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home.

1 - 12 of 57
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent