Natalie Kay

Natalie Kay

FA: 100087082
  •   5   (10 reviews)

About Natalie

Natalie Kay is a proud Colorado "Native" and REALTOR® with Victory Dream Team at Keller Williams Advantage Realty. She serves the greater Denver Metro area and specializes in working with first-time home buyers. For Victory Dream Team, home is more than a house. With a background in higher education housing and property management, Natalie's skills are uniquely curated for helping clients transition seamlessly from paying rent to a landlord to building equity. Natalie is passionate about helping her clients create wealth and lasting legacies through real estate. Natalie's communication and organization skills (and raw tenacity) benefit her clients at every point of negotiating. Natalie is able to serve buyers and investors in every shifting real estate market by saving her clients time and money. Each transaction is treated with white-glove service and lasting relationships are formed. Every client receives the time and attention needed from consultation to housewarming - and beyond, with Natalie's extensive list of reliable vendors. First-time home buyers can trust Natalie's ability to thoroughly explain the home buying process and hold their hand during one of the most significant purchases of their lives. As a millennial, Natalie understands the obstacles a first-time home buyer can face and the doubts that prevent purchasing a home. Clients can rest easy in Natalie's capable, experienced, and patient hands because a "home is more than a house."

Natalie's reviews

  5  
Natalie has 10 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 6.
Review Natalie
over 2 years ago
Wonder Experience

Natalie is a top tier real estate agent. She is very responsive and incredibly knowledgeable. She also has a great network of trustworthy connections. My entire house search process from inception to closing was seamless with her and her team. There were multiple offers on the house I purchased, and Natalie was able to get me the house at a reasonable price despite all the competition. I highly recommend her to anyone that’s considering purchasing a home.

over 2 years ago
Natalie is top shelf

Natalie is hardworking and made the sale of my home stress free. I was not living in the same state as the house. Natalie went above and beyond to sell my house. She does more than other realtors and it shows!!

almost 3 years ago
Amazing Experience!

If you’re looking for a first class real estate agent, Natalie Kay is your choice! She is extremely professional, knowledgeable and will do what it takes to get the job done. My wife and I leaned on Natalie’s expertise throughout our home buying process and she came through time and time again for us. I was a first time homebuyer and was admittedly a little stressed going into this life changing process, but Natalie put me at ease with her vast real estate knowledge and professionalism! She communicated with my wife and I to make sure we knew exactly what was going on at all times and proactively informed us of the next steps to come. I would highly recommend Natalie to anyone who is in need of a real estate professional. Take it from me, she will not disappoint!!! Keep up the great work! 5 out of 5 stars! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

almost 3 years ago
A-MAZING!!

After reading our story I'm pretty sure you'll be interested in working with Natalie. Then once your transaction is done with her you will recommend her to everyone you know who is in the market for an agent. Natalie is extremely knowledgeable of the market for Colorado! Which is not a common skill in the Colorado market today. She made the process seamless from the selling of our townhome to the buying of our new single family home. From discussing all the minor and major details of the buying and selling in this market. To ensuring the post occupancy was right on track not only for us but for the buyer and sellers too. (who were not her clients by the way!) Every step of the way she was there and understanding of our needs, asking clarifying questions, making sure we understood what was going to happen, and what did happen. Most agents use industry jargon to make themselves sound more credible. Well, fact is that doesn't help the client in any way. Natalie put everything in simple terms and scenarios the average person can understand; we truly appreciated that level of respect. Any time we had a question (dumb or not) she answered it without hesitation. If she was not the person to have the answer she sure had the right person available immediately to give us that answer. We felt like we had the white glove service from start to finish. Can you say that about an agent you've had or talked to in the past? I certainly could not before Natalie. We are so grateful that now we can after our experience with Natalie. Because of the technique/advice she gave us we were able to sell our townhome for above market value to then purchase our next home below market value. This is a scenario that you do not hear about very often in Colorado anymore. We sat on the fence of a buyers and sellers market because of Natalie. In turn we got the house we wanted and deserved! Now, call her and setup a consultation. It doesn't hurt to ask! I encourage you to take that next step!

almost 3 years ago
She was amazing!

We were very picky and Natalie helped us find exactly what we were looking for!

almost 3 years ago
Great working with you!

I am a local lender and just worked with Natalie as she represented the sellers. Her communication with myself and the buyer's agent was fantastic. We all worked together to be able to close in just 3 weeks time. That take great teamwork from all parties to make it happen that fast. Great job, Natalie!

Show all 10 reviews

Natalie's properties

Natalie hasn't had any property sale activity in the last 12 months

EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent