Michelle's profile

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 208 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, well-prepared, reliable, friendly, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Extremely happy and satisfied.
almost 2 years ago
Extremely happy and satisfied.

Michelle took a property that had been on the market for far too long and turned a serious nightmare into a dream come true. I can't thank her enough for working with me and getting this house sold. She never gave up and in the end it all came together for a great thanksgiving and christmas present. She's the best.....

Seller review
Michelle Metcalf
almost 2 years ago
Michelle Metcalf

Michelle Metcalf was my realtor when I bought my Green Valley home 7 years ago. When I decided to sell my home and move back to Michigan, my only thought was call Michelle. Michelle knows the market in GV which is vital if you want to sell, but also when you want to buy. Her knowledge, expertise, and just all around great person was invaluable to me. Michelle is great!

Buyer review
Absolutely the Best!
about 2 years ago
Absolutely the Best!

She is everything anyone would want in a real estate agent and a person. She is very thorough and follows up with any questions or concerns. She is also very helpful and walks you through every step in the process of buying a home. She is also available whenever you need her. I would recommend her as the best and would trust her completely

Seller review
Marketing Professional!
about 2 years ago
Marketing Professional!

Michelle did a fantastic job with the sale of my fathers home. We were having an issue getting offers, and she came up with some ideas to entice buyers. Her idea worked! We had an offer within a week of the updates we made. Not only is Michelle creative, she does a great job with her marketing, and communications. She continually sent out updated flyers and communications on the property as well as held different types of open houses.

Seller review
Excellent agent
about 2 years ago
Excellent agent

Michelle is a wonderful agent and I would recommend her to my friends and family. She was easy to work with and she sold our house within one day.

Seller review
Why Metcalf over another?
about 2 years ago
Why Metcalf over another?

Just sold my home with Michelle. Couldn’t be happier and more impressed. In this market most homes sell themselves. Easy. We got an offer on the second showing. The hard parts are the negotiation, the inspection and the actual closing. This is where Michelle’s experience earned my respect. Our offer was insultingly low hey we ended up agreeing to a small percentage below ask. The buyers inspector was as unreasonable as his agent but we ended up with a short list of repairs and a fair monetary offset for recoating the roof. As out-of-state sellers, Michelle offered to handle all the repairs with her trusted, able and affordable contractors. We were also a family of 3 sellers and Michelle so professionally kept each of us informed - not an easy task. Our selling experience was beyond perfect. Hire Michelle without hesitation.

Seller review
Amazing agent!
about 2 years ago
Amazing agent!

Michelle was truly amazing in selling our Green Valley home! We are out of state sellers and not only was Michelle a highly effective negotiator on our behalf, she completely took the reins on getting a laundry list of buyer requested repairs taken care of for us! She has a complete and professional network of trades who rallied to meet a 10 day closing! As a former Broker and seller of several properties, Michelle is 100% the best agent I have worked with! Thank you Michelle!

Seller review
Michelle professionally and satisfactorily completed an extremely difficult sale.
about 2 years ago
Michelle professionally and satisfactorily completed an extremely difficult sale.

Michelle not only sold my property, she did it under very trying circumstances. She maintained an extremely positive attitude from start to finish, and never became discouraged. Michelle listed my property and had it under contact within 24 hours. Before the buyer's allotted time for due diligence was over, the buyer bailed because the totally functional plumbing was poly piping. Within a few days, Michelle had the property under contact again. Before closing, the buy forfeited his deposit due to personal reasons. Again, within a few days, Michelle had the property under contract. Once again, the plumbing issue resulted in the buyer bailing. The property was back under contract within 24 hours, and it resulted in a sale. During this process, Michelle coordinated and managed any and all interfaces with inspectors and contractors, and kept me totally informed at every step. It was totally efficient and transparent to me. Michelle maintained her positive attitude and professionalism throughout this grueling time. She was never displayed any signs of being discouraged. Without any hesitation, I recommend Michelle as the best person to handle your real estate transactions.

Seller review
Motivated!
about 2 years ago
Motivated!

Michelle is very motivated. She is knowledgeable and gave great advice before listing with her. You will not regret picking Michelle as your real estate agent.

Seller review
Got the job done!
about 2 years ago
Got the job done!

Michelle Metcalf immediately went to work to get our house listed. We were in MN. She got a house cleaner and professional photographer. The pictures were gorgeous with sun rises and sun sets. We worked with the first buyer until the terms worked. Do not share the cost of GVR or HOA fees!!! Why???!! Thank you Michelle.

Buyer review
Michelle is the Best!
about 2 years ago
Michelle is the Best!

I reached out to Michelle 8 months ago after reading her bio and recent reviews from clients like me. I knew I wanted to "land" in Green Valley eventually and needed a realtor I could trust and rely upon from my home base 1800 miles away. Since January Michelle has expertly guided me over a sometimes bumpy road to home ownership in Green Valley. I simply cannot thank her enough for her expertise and patience with this very grateful, senior citizen!

61 - 72 of 208
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent