Michelle's profile

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 208 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, well-prepared, reliable, friendly, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Listing showcased house beautifully.
7 months ago
Listing showcased house beautifully.

Michelle is an excellent and thoughtful writer. She paid attention to every upgrade in my house and found a way to mention them seamlessly in the listing. The listing also uniquely showed a floorplan which I would find very helpful if I were buying a home. Michelle also responds quickly to phone calls and texts and does not dismiss seller suggestions out-of-hand. The only reason I did not give Michelle 5 stars, and perhaps it is not fair, was because of her handyman referrals. Both individuals she referred did not call when they said they would causing a delay of several days in an already tight timeline for the completion of repairs. On the other hand, her referral of a cleaning person was first-rate. I recommend Michelle Metcalf wholeheartedly if you are looking to sell your house.

Seller review
A highly knowledgeable, determined, and energetic agent
7 months ago
A highly knowledgeable, determined, and energetic agent

Michelle showed up to our initial meeting thoroughly prepared with the necessary information to brief me on the current real estate market and her capabilities to sell my house. She kept me informed at all times along the way with feedback and recommendations. My house was on the market for less than 60 days before it went under contract and was eventually sold. Her negotiating skills are solid and won't allow you to get less than what she believes you deserve. I have another house that I am planning on selling in the next year, and will definitely hire her as my agent.

Seller review
Thorough and professional
8 months ago
Thorough and professional

Michelle and Andy know the Quail Creek market and properties well. Their help and advice were duly appreciated and resulted in a successful transaction in a difficult market.

Seller review
Kept with us over an extended period of time but never gave up.
8 months ago
Kept with us over an extended period of time but never gave up.

We were very satisfied with her determination to sell our home. Her and her team went the extra mile to find a buyer and close the sale. Several showings and open houses, phone calls and messages, kept us updated on progress. We couldn’t be happier.

Seller review
Professional and Understanding
8 months ago
Professional and Understanding

I live out of state, so finding an agent was tricky as I didn't know where to begin. Michelle came recommended to me by a locksmith whom I called out to change the locks on my mother's house once she had passed away. From the start she presented herself with the utmost professionalism, (they say we make our judgment on someone within the first few minutes of meeting them). Michelle made a statement both outwardly with confidence, poise, and dressed to impress, as well as inward knowledge and mastery of the real estate business. You get the whole package with her! From the start, she gave excellent advice on how best to prep my mother's home and have it "sale ready". She really has a knack for looking at a home in its present state and finding small details to improve upon that can brighten up a home; elevating it to an attractive and warm environment. Michelle was an excellent communicator throughout, and never missed an opportunity to keep me in the loop with feedback from other realtors and/or potential buyers as the house was being shown. She returned all of my calls and/or texts if I reached out, and has an enormous amount of patience with her clients. Buying or selling a home can be a very stressful event, and Michelle understands this. She is very good with listening to her clients concerns or worries, and helping alleviate any fears that come with this. Ultimately she sold my mother's home within months of it being on the market, and she, (along with her team), made the transaction as smooth and problem-free as possible. I am so pleased with Michelle and her team at RE/MAX Signature. Consider my review as doing your homework of researching an agent for you, and just hire Michelle for your real estate needs. You will be so happy you did!

Buyer review
Alaska to Arizona via FaceTime video!
8 months ago
Alaska to Arizona via FaceTime video!

We purchased the Arizona home from Alaska. The home was even better than expected! This was made possible by Michelle going the “mile” for her clients.

Seller review
Job well done Michelle!
9 months ago
Job well done Michelle!

Michelle helped me with two properties,buying and selling.Michelle is a very talented realtor, and i would recommend her to all looking for a seamless real estate process...thank you again Michelle!

Seller review
Great Realtor
9 months ago
Great Realtor

Michelle helped is sell our home to the right buyer. She was professional, ethical and full of hope during the ups and downs of the home selling process. We highly recommend Michelle.

Seller review
Michelle was amazing.  Friendly and professional.
9 months ago
Michelle was amazing. Friendly and professional.

Michelle thought of, and helped us with, everything. We were an out-of-state seller and Michelle made the process easier than I could have imagined. I would highly recommend her to anyone in a similar situation.

Seller review
Always on top of it!
10 months ago
Always on top of it!

I’m so thankful that I found Michelle, her and Andy were such a great team and really helped us sell my dad‘s house with the care and professionalism that we were hoping for. They were both very informative and helpful. Write up to the last moments when the documents were signed! Would use them up again in a heartbeat if I was buying in Arizona!

13 - 24 of 208
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent