Michelle's profile

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 53 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: strategic, supportive, resourceful, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Above and Beyond!
about 4 years ago
Above and Beyond!

Michelle is an absolute pleasure to work with. Calm and collected, she guided us through the buying process in this competitive market with ease. She knew the central coast area ( San Luis Obispo and surrounding cities) inside and out and lead us to purchase in the perfect area for us. We encourage anyone looking for a central coast agent to contact Michelle. She will listen, tailor her approach to your individual needs, and help you find your perfect property.

Seller review
Great experience!
about 4 years ago
Great experience!

I have bought and sold more than a few homes in the past. I have to say that Michelle proved to be by far the best. She has years of experience and knowledge. Any questions or issues that arose were handled quickly and professionally. I would not hesitate to refer her to any of my friends or family.

Seller review
10 Out of 10!
about 4 years ago
10 Out of 10!

Michelle helped us sell our SLO condo, and the entire experience was a 10 out of 10. She is responsive, well-organized, and thoroughly professional. Her approach to marketing our property was perfectly suited to the market conditions at the time, resulting in more offers and a higher sales price than we had anticipated. She was also very helpful when we needed a referral for a plumber to complete a presale project. I don't write reviews very often, but when someone does such a seamless and fantastic job, you just need to acknowledge their efforts!

Seller review
Pleasure to work with!
over 4 years ago
Pleasure to work with!

Michelle was awesome, she has a deep understanding of the market and the entire process was incredibly streamlined. She took care of a lot of the background work and hired the best in the business to advertise our home. Our house was only listed for a couple days before we had a solid offer that we accepted. Thanks again!

Seller review
Wow! That was fast.
over 4 years ago
Wow! That was fast.

We were connected with Michelle by an agent who had just retired. We asked Michelle to look over our condo and suggest what improvements would help it sell for a good price. She had a few suggestions and closed our meeting saying "It won't take long to sell this." Michelle brought a potential buyer before we ever got to the listing agreement. The first people to see it made an offer and Michelle moved the paperwork along while we waited for new flooring to get through the backed up supply chains. When our installer was delayed, Michelle's network came through with a flooring installer who could start immediately. Overall, it was 12 weeks from our first meeting to closing, but it felt like 4!. We had one showing, no open house, and didn't even get the house on the MLS. Fastest and easiest deal we've ever made!

Seller review
Sales Experience
over 4 years ago
Sales Experience

Michelle was easy to work with, very knowledgeable about market. We received numerous offers and 3 of them were above ask price. We waited 4 days and settled on a quick closing 20k over ask. She pointed out a few things that we should fix for appearance and it made the world of difference. Highly recommend her. You won't be disappointed.

Buyer review
Seamless and Smooth
over 4 years ago
Seamless and Smooth

Michelle was very communicative and did a bunch of research for us on comparable homes to the ones that she showed us so we knew what the value of what we were looking at was. Ultimately it was about six week from the start of our serious home buying journey to offer accepted and she helped us through three offers. The last offer was a gold mine and came through Michelle's local and long time connections. We had a minimally stressful first home buying experience.

Buyer review
Best home buying experience ever!!
over 4 years ago
Best home buying experience ever!!

We have been waiting for years to finally move forward with the decision to buy a home on the coast. Michelle was patient, thoughtful, and so easy to work with on this purchase. We really appreciate her attention to detail, and her knowledge, and advice about real estate in this area. We are very happy with our home!

Buyer review
Michelle was the perfect fit for us
almost 5 years ago
Michelle was the perfect fit for us

Michelle was the perfect fit for us. We were first time home buyers in the Central Coast and Michelle was able to get us into the most fabulous home for us in an insanely hot market. It was purely because of her connections that we were able to get in and see this home and I think also a big part of our offer being accepted. She walked us through a few previous offers and made sure we were competitive but also realistic and understanding of our financial situation. She was easy to reach by text and phone. From the time we brought Michelle on board until closing on our house, with a 25 day escrow, the whole experience was just under three months!

Buyer review
Michelle did an excellent job facilitating the recent purchase of our home
almost 5 years ago
Michelle did an excellent job facilitating the recent purchase of our home

Michelle did an excellent job facilitating the recent purchase of our home. She regularly kept us apprised of all requirements, resulting in a fast and problem-free closing process. She also patiently adjusted to our changing preferences during the house hunting process, and took it upon herself to conduct research to address concerns we had with potential properties.

37 - 48 of 53
Michelle McElrath (Severance)
Contact Michelle McElrath (Severance)
What information would you like?
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent