Michelle's profile

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 53 reviewsacross 9 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: strategic, supportive, resourceful, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Great͏ to work with and very knowledgeable of the local market
over 3 years ago
Great͏ to work with and very knowledgeable of the local market

Great͏ to work with and very knowledgeable of the local market. Michelle was excellent to work with and was very knowledgeable of the local market. Michelle went out of her way to help me and answer all of my questions. Communication was on point and her professionalism made for a smooth experience.

Seller review
Great to work with and very knowledgeable of the local market
over 3 years ago
Great to work with and very knowledgeable of the local market

Michelle was excellent to work with and was very knowledgeable of the local market. Michelle went out of her way to help me and answer all of my questions. Communication was on point and her professionalism made for a smooth experience.

Seller review
Wonderful Experience
over 3 years ago
Wonderful Experience

Michelle was great to work with especially since we don't live there- she handled everything and was always professional

Seller review
Five͏ Shooting Stars!!!
almost 4 years ago
Five͏ Shooting Stars!!!

Five͏ Shooting Stars She made all my dreams come true! * A Great Communicator * Attentive to my specific needs * Available, reliable & prompt * A universe of real estate knowledge * A calm touch to a hectic process If you want your wish to come true catch the shooting star, Michelle McElrath.

Seller review
Five Shooting Stars
almost 4 years ago
Five Shooting Stars

She made all my dreams come true! * A Great Communicator * Attentive to my specific needs * Available, reliable & prompt * A universe of real estate knowledge * A calm touch to a hectic process If you want your wish to come true catch the shooting star, Michelle McElrath.

Seller review
Michelle was an excellent communicator and extremely professional
almost 4 years ago
Michelle was an excellent communicator and extremely professional

She was wonderful to work with and was an excellent intermediator for the sale of our condo. She was knowledgable and professional and I would definitely recommend her or use her again for any Real Estate needs.

Seller review
Outstanding professional. She was ahead of every issue.
almost 4 years ago
Outstanding professional. She was ahead of every issue.

Michelle handled every aspect quickly and with efficiency. Strongly recommend her. She is well versed in the market. She worked with the buyers agent to complete the sale with lightning speed.

Buyer review
Look No Further If Searching For a Five Cities Realtor
almost 4 years ago
Look No Further If Searching For a Five Cities Realtor

My wife and I worked with Michelle to purchase our home in Pismo Beach and had a great experience all the way through. We were buying from out of the area and having a local realtor in the area where we were looking to purchase was critical. Michelle exceeded all of our expectations all the way through the process and would highly recommend her for anyone looking to buy or sell in the Five Cities area.

Seller review
Experienced and knowledgable
almost 4 years ago
Experienced and knowledgable

Michelle was referred to us by another agent, which in itself says a lot. Our first encounter was to get ideas and feedback for what we needed to do to prepare the house to sell. Michelle's knowledge and experience were obvious in this area and proved to be spot-on. The house showed well and sold quickly. Michelle was readily available to us throughout the escrow process.

Buyer review
Outstanding Realtor and Wonderful Person - Michelle McElrath
almost 4 years ago
Outstanding Realtor and Wonderful Person - Michelle McElrath

Michelle is in a class by herself - rare, unique and unequaled. Positive, energetic, compassionate and kind - intelligent, wise, thoughtful and refined - she brings these outstanding qualities and countless others to the table when working for you as a professional realtor. She loves her work and wants her clients to feel correctly placed in their new homes. After countless walk-throughs of homes in SLO county, it was easy for me to become disappointed when every home fell short of my expectations. "Nice house, but. . ." or "I could replace the roof, siding, paint, carpet, kitchen cabinets and the avocado green appliances and then it would be perfect!". . . or "It's easy to build a garage." Said no one ever. You all know the routine. Her positive phrase "For every home crossed off the list, we're one home closer to yours" was a constant source of inspiration and hope. Eventually we found the right one and we both knew it. Rest assured, when working with Michelle, you'll know it too. She simply is the best realtor you will ever find.

Seller review
I worked with Michelle to sell our property.
almost 4 years ago
I worked with Michelle to sell our property.

Michelle McElrath is an excellent agent. She was a pleasure to work with, very professional, personal, and knowledgeable. She coached us on how to prepare the property for sale. She put us in contact with local trade people for the maintenance items that needed to be done. With her help our property was fully ready to make a good first impression. She used high quality photos for the online marketing, and knew the market for proper pricing. She kept us updated regarding the listing, and apprised about the showings. Within a week we had multiple offers. Within 2 weeks, we were in contract for over the asking price! Thank you Michelle! Best realtor I have ever dealt with. Highly recommended.

Seller review
A great experience! Michelle knows her stuff and keeps in touch! Thanks Michelle for everything!
about 4 years ago
A great experience! Michelle knows her stuff and keeps in touch! Thanks Michelle for everything!

My husband and I live in the State of Washington. We dreaded the process of selling our property in Arroyo Grande. Michelle's brochure arrived in our mail box. I called her and away we went. She knows the market, calls when she says she's going to and priced our property right. The property had been a rental and she helped us work through selling it "as is" A cash buyer bought the property and we closed in 18 days. Great service! Thanks Michelle for all your help.

25 - 36 of 53
Michelle McElrath (Severance)
Contact Michelle McElrath (Severance)
What information would you like?
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent